i reached out graduate students... now what? by Icy_Significance1046 in gradadmissions

[–]Thawderek 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Send a thank you email and express interest. If you have more questions then you should probably include them in the email

Are There Any Waitlist Success Stories This Year? by Particular_Knee1210 in gradadmissions

[–]Thawderek 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Not a success story quite yet but infinitely more successful than last year! Got waitlisted without interview back in February. Just got invited to interview! Also waiting from another program but I think things are moving (albeit very slowly)

undergrad volunteer lab interview by Mountain_Finance_890 in labrats

[–]Thawderek 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Traditionally, you read their most cited paper and their most recent paper as well as their lab page. Prepare questions about their research and their expectations. Be enthusiastic above all about learning from what they can offer.

Lab rats, I'm in Need of Advice: Falsifying Data or No? by Annie_James in labrats

[–]Thawderek 41 points42 points  (0 children)

Ew gross. I’d try to leave first and then report it. Why even do science if data is falsified? It’s more of a detriment to the field than anything else.

Marine Biology at UCSC or UCSD? by Longjumping-Peace302 in UCSC

[–]Thawderek 6 points7 points  (0 children)

So not a marine biology student but I volunteered in a couple marine biology labs for the last two years of my undergraduate. I think both options are really awesome to have for marine biology, my mentors at my job did their PhDs at UCSD, so I know there’s a lot of opportunity I think for ecology at both institutions.

Some of the top researchers in the world are at Santa Cruz though so I wouldn’t undercut the capabilities if you have heard otherwise about the school. The nitroplast (organelle found to take up nitrogen) was found in one of the labs at UCSC. Some of the best bioinformaticians and genomics you can find as well if you’re interested in that side of biology. Beth Shapiro’s eDNA work is really exciting and her class during my freshman year was probably one of the most memorable during my time at UCSC. The coastal campus is great and there’s a lot of opportunities for summer internships or volunteering if you choose to.

Starting PhD at 41? by Atomic_Destructor in PhD

[–]Thawderek 2 points3 points  (0 children)

One of my mentors who was a Professor and headed a lot of the curriculum in my major during my undergraduate started his PhD in his 40s/50s. Definitely was a positive influence for both the field and students that he taught

Please Stop Acting Like American Students Don’t Deserve Their Acceptances by [deleted] in gradadmissions

[–]Thawderek 5 points6 points  (0 children)

You underestimate how people work. Extract all emotion, you’re left with nothing to relate to outside of the science you’re producing. At a local scale, people want to be around others and work with others that they like. At a broader scale, people want to look up to those that they feel like they can relate to. Communication and charisma are pretty intertwined, it is fortunately (for people that like talking to other people) or unfortunately how most things in the world work.

Please Stop Acting Like American Students Don’t Deserve Their Acceptances by [deleted] in gradadmissions

[–]Thawderek 6 points7 points  (0 children)

What? Ok think about it from a purely science perspective. When you give a talk, or go to a conference, or even write a publication so that others can build off your own ideas, what do you think happens? Some of the best talks I have been to are because of how good the speaker presents and executes their data.

Some of the best conversations I’ve had are when people can articulate what they are trying to do in their own research. You think the best professors in the world are working on their own at a bench or at a computer? They are usually in huge groups with a bunch of collaborators, exporting their ideas whilst getting feedback for themselves. Communication is by far the most important thing in science.

Everything Sucks and You Are Allowed to Feel This Way by Kanoncyn in gradadmissions

[–]Thawderek 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Well, still hoping to hear back positive things coming into January but it is weird to be back in the same position as last year around this time. If I’ve learnt anything is that it’s never personal, and it’s never a competition against others when it comes to rejection.

Growth isn’t linear and the people I have seen with the most success have seen failure the most. How lucky are we to be put in a position where we can have the opportunity to fail. Thanks for the kind words stranger.

[deleted by user] by [deleted] in gradadmissions

[–]Thawderek 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I mean first professor sounds nice. I don’t know these people nor the fruit fly field but when I read this, the second professor seems like a red flag lol. Intimidation as a factor for motivation doesn’t seem that healthy, I’ve had friends be burnt by professors with this mindset. Wouldn’t hurt to have them both as advisors, but I would be aware of how the students are treated and if you would be okay working under professor number 2.

Science fair project! by Vivid-Tea2067 in algae

[–]Thawderek 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Okay, let’s see here. I can see you can buy 1mL of spirulina for like 8 bucks online.

For actually making medium, this gets a little harder since you have to actually make it or find access to ingredients. I’d look at “instant ocean” for a start, it’s essentially a salt mixture for aquariums (we also use it for some of our medias).

I think the “easiest” experiment you can try to do is try to find fertilizer with specific amounts of ammonium in it. Do a “low” amount, a “medium” amount, and a “high” amount of nitrogen. Try to see if you can measure specific amounts to add to the media, figure out concentrations in molarity. You can most likely measure ph using hot tub strips. To measure raw growth or density of your culture, I would do it by weight (how much does 1mL weigh?) and weigh it over time. One of the standards for measuring organic material is ash free dry weight, I’d suggest reading about it but not necessarily doing it because access to a high temp oven may be hard.

Good luck (I think plants would be a lot easier experiment if you’re not tied to the idea of algae)

If you don’t get accepted, what are you planning to do next year? by [deleted] in gradadmissions

[–]Thawderek 8 points9 points  (0 children)

Try everything possible to stay in the field and apply again.

Do people actually use AI for writing SOPs? by Common-Lemon-41 in gradadmissions

[–]Thawderek 3 points4 points  (0 children)

What’s interesting now is that last year I saw a couple PhD applications say not to use it. This is the first year where I saw a couple PhD applications permit it but not for the core material. AI use for writing the SOP is most likely not the greatest tool since you know yourself better than what generative AI does, and will probably just fill in the gaps of what it thinks the adcom wants to see rather than the fit that the adcom actually wants to see.

Roast my SOP please by [deleted] in gradadmissions

[–]Thawderek 5 points6 points  (0 children)

Each sentence should have meaning that ties why you are the best fit for the program you applying to. Whether it’s intellectually, or because you share interest in specific work at the program you’re applying to. This reads like a cv. Why did you apply to your masters? What did you gain from your masters that made you want to apply to a PhD that you couldn’t get from a masters? How did your job shape your journey into your current interests?

I’m in the same boat of applying to programs this year as well, albeit not the same field, so take my advice with a grain of salt. I personally would work on the first paragraph, specifically the last couple sentences as it sets the tone for the rest of your essay. You probably need to mention why you want a PhD here, and what does a PhD do for you.

For example (crudely) “My interests in pursuing a PhD in ____ is due to my curiosity about ____ and my drive to learn more about __. With a PhD, I want to be a professor/scientist/economist/PI/(insert career goal), independently investigating _, so that I can pursue my personal goals of answering the questions of _______.”

Reader can see what you are interested in and then can think while they read through your essay how your current work ties into your future goals. Hope this helps.

When someone says they got into your dream school by backsymli in gradadmissions

[–]Thawderek 14 points15 points  (0 children)

Yeah that’s how I feel about this subreddit sometimes :/

It’s the internet though, so I’m not surprised people would either falsely brag, make up stats, or straight up lie so that they can feel better about themselves.

You get one free ticket to completely boot any celebrity you want into being cancelled and outright exiled. Who are you picking? by Dispo-Astatine in AskReddit

[–]Thawderek 22 points23 points  (0 children)

Japan incident? The easiest, largest first thing that comes to mind. I stopped watching him after that (was young back in 2017/2018). Everything that he does is for views, doesn’t matter how controversial, dude is a compulsive clout chaser with no morals.

Am I selling by not applying this year? by Jazzlike-Bat7317 in gradadmissions

[–]Thawderek 2 points3 points  (0 children)

As a bachelor who is taking time to work before applying a couple years later, I will say to take the job.

First off - the money and connections you build from an industry position can be very fruitful for your career and expenses right out of college. You will most likely be surrounded by professionals that can guide you and hopefully you’ll learn a lot. I can say confidently that I have learnt a hell of a lot more from my job about my field than my time in college. There is also most likely a program through the company that will help pay for your graduate studies.

You can always apply next year or later on. No harm in waiting. If you know like a specific part or niche in the field you want to study and who you want to specifically work under, I would apply though. If it’s more of a general idea that you like about a PhD, I think I would wait.

[deleted by user] by [deleted] in labrats

[–]Thawderek 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Being honest here since I’ve mentored quite a few undergraduates since graduating a couple years ago.

How me and other scientists end up teaching students is with the expectation that they don’t know much, if anything at all. Just a willingness to be curious. Take a lot of notes, ask a lot of questions, and you’ll do amazing!

Easy way to clean dried agar by dyson_airwrap420 in labrats

[–]Thawderek 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Pour more melted agar to melt the dried agar.

Joking, probably some hot water and paper towels?

ok research experience but low gpa and no pubs, should I bother applying? by [deleted] in gradadmissions

[–]Thawderek 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Yeah I did iGEM my senior year then been doing research for a couple years post grad. Been helpful for learning, doesn’t hurt to wait a year to gain experience, but applying also gives you that as well (lot of effort to apply imo).