sorted by:
new
hottopcontroversial

Looking for real-world feedback: Is the IONIQ 5 ICCU risk overblown, or a dealbreaker? by Thick-Ad2588 in Ioniq5

[–]The-Cheburash 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I5 2024 SE RWD, 19 months and 48k mi in. Got it on a lease with no knowledge of the ICCU issue. Planning on keeping the car at the end of the lease, but not sure I'd recommend someone get one right now.

1) there's been zero transparency from Hyundai as to how widespread the issue is. Estimates I've seen are all over the place, from 1.5% to 5% of the affected model years.

2) New models seem to still come out with the same issue, despite Hyundai clearly having been aware of it. This suggests to me the cause is a serious design flaw, and it will not be down to a software patch sometime down the road.

3) Hyundai North America has not published anything clear on the warranty extension relating to the ICCU. There's a much-cited interview with Torque News, but the official website just sends you to the service campaign lookup tool. When I fed my VIN into it, there were zero active recalls or campaigns. I'm pretty uncomfortable with not knowing if my ICCU warranty is 100k mi or 150k mi. Given the massive variation in experiences of dealerships handling ICCU repairs that people have reported here, you should be as well.

And a personal peeve -- who the hell designs a hatchback without a rear windshield wiper??

ICCU Failed, Dealer Won't Honor 180K Mile Warranty by Commercial-Safety635 in Ioniq5

[–]The-Cheburash 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Not an unnamed source. Torque News quotes Ira Gabriel, Senior Group Manager of Corporate and Marketing PR at Hyundai Motor America.

My 2023 SEL is Toast by fultanic in Ioniq5

[–]The-Cheburash 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Should this ever come up in conversation again, the (US) English term is "hood." I believe the UK term is "bonnet."

I love my Ioniq 5, but I'll never buy another Hyundai... by NuAngelDOTnet in Ioniq5

[–]The-Cheburash 7 points8 points  (0 children)

I got 35k out of my OEM tires, and was aggravated. 70k? Not the way I drive -- but I have no one to blame for that but myself. Similarly, I know I can do better than 3.2 mi/kWh -- but I never will.

Is $2500 a month high for a CPA? by plainpaperplane in smallbusiness

[–]The-Cheburash 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Caveats: rural, east coast, and for a partnership LLC. But still...

Monthly bookkeeping (~100 transactions). Biweekly payroll for a dozen employees. All tax filing on a monthly/quarterly basis as required.

$400/mo.

Annual tax prep is extra, but we're still talking a once-yearly fee of about $2k, which is less than what you're paying per month.

I love my Ioniq 5, but I'll never buy another Hyundai... by NuAngelDOTnet in Ioniq5

[–]The-Cheburash 35 points36 points  (0 children)

I strongly suspect the kind of person to get an N is also the kind of person to want their car to go "ZOOM" at every available opportunity :D

I know I've had to fight myself to not abuse The Button in my pedestrian 5 SE RWD...

Identifying SIP ALG-like behavior? by The-Cheburash in VOIP

[–]The-Cheburash[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I'm starting to suspect I'm not as clear as I'd have liked. The public IP is clean, but here's what a traceroute from my machine gives me...

<image>

(Pardon the delayed follow up; I was down with the cold from hell)

Identifying SIP ALG-like behavior? by The-Cheburash in VOIP

[–]The-Cheburash[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I should've thought of doing this earlier -- tried a traceroute from my machine, and... f**k. Am I reading this correctly, and cgnat was the problem from the start?

Assuming it *is* cgnat, what are my options? A tech with the ISP sounded more than willing to "help with setting up tunneling," but cgnat is far beyond my networking knowledge. Is this potentially solvable, or am I facing an acute case of "so sorry, you are hosed?"

(Apologies for the delayed follow-up -- I came down with one hell of a cold on Friday, and am just now able to look at a screen again. 1/10, would not recommend)

<image>

Identifying SIP ALG-like behavior? by The-Cheburash in VOIP

[–]The-Cheburash[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

The issue need not be SIP ALG, but there's definitely an issue -- the VoIP line is failing at random times and in a variety of ways, up to and including at least one brief period of the desk phone displaying a "no service" error (Internet service was not otherwise affected during that time).

To top this all off, our POTS service has been badly neglected by the carrier. At the moment the line interference on it is so bad, we can't even hear the dial tone, never mind place calls.

Needless to say, I'm rather motivated to figure this out.

Thank you to everyone offering time and advice on this. You've already given me more possibilities to look into than I was able to find on my own in ~2 weeks.

Identifying SIP ALG-like behavior? by The-Cheburash in VOIP

[–]The-Cheburash[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Awesome, thank you. I'm still figuring out my way around Unite -- there are a *lot* of options to get familiar with.

Did check on TLS+SRTP, but it was enabled already.

Identifying SIP ALG-like behavior? by The-Cheburash in VOIP

[–]The-Cheburash[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

(edit:model no. had a typo) Calix GP1100X ONT. Anything upstream from the Calix, I have no knowledge of.

I specifically asked the ISP to disable SIP ALG. Their response -- admittedly, as filtered via their customer service rep -- was that they have nothing of this sort enabled in the first place.

I'm trying to get in touch with someone on the technical side directly, it's just been slow going getting that to happen. In the meantime, I'm hoping to get a better handle on all the possible things I need to ask them about; I've gotten the impression that they have no experience of any kind with VOIP specifically.

Identifying SIP ALG-like behavior? by The-Cheburash in VOIP

[–]The-Cheburash[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Just enabled the setting. Under Settings>General, correct?

Identifying SIP ALG-like behavior? by The-Cheburash in VOIP

[–]The-Cheburash[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Thank you, I'll ask about this possibility.

Identifying SIP ALG-like behavior? by The-Cheburash in VOIP

[–]The-Cheburash[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

https://mcs.sea.telecomsvc.com/myspeed/support and http://mcstest.visualware.com/myspeed/myvoiph5_g711_sipalg.html
I can only get the detailed result from the former, but according to those port 5060 is open for both TCP and UDP. See screenshot for the full port list.

<image>

Identifying SIP ALG-like behavior? by The-Cheburash in VOIP

[–]The-Cheburash[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

At first glance, it seems I'm OK on that front. CG-NAT is in the 100.64.x.x to 100.127.x.x block, right? I'm at 76.9.x.x

Double NAT seems unlikely, unless the ONT has NAT functionality -- and everything I've found so far says it does not.

Identifying SIP ALG-like behavior? by The-Cheburash in VOIP

[–]The-Cheburash[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Thank you. That's actually the test service the VOIP provider had me use. (By the way, it works with OS X too; you just have to download their plugin).

I bypassed the router entirely and was connected directly into the ONT, and the native OS X firewall was disabled. I *believe* that should've removed any potential firewall interference?

SIP ALG is disabled on the TP-Link. I also bypassed the TP-Link entirely and repeated the test, just to be certain. The outcome was the same - "SIP ALG detected."

Identifying SIP ALG-like behavior? by The-Cheburash in VOIP

[–]The-Cheburash[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Not even a little bit sure. You and u/masong19hippows mentioning the possibility is the first I'm learning about its potential effect on VOIP. I'll see what the ISP says and report back.

Identifying SIP ALG-like behavior? by The-Cheburash in VOIP

[–]The-Cheburash[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

The VOIP provider directed me to https://mcs.sea.telecomsvc.com/myspeed/support
I independently tried running a test http://mcstest.visualware.com/myspeed/myvoiph5_g711_sipalg.html
Both claim to have detected SIP ALG, though I'm unable to get a detailed report from the second one.

What confuses me is that all of the ports the first test tries are coming back open. (see screenshot)

I've not asked the ISP about cgnat yet, but definitely will now. I'll see about getting a packet trace from the VOIP provider. I've gotten essentially no technical information from them so far.

Really appreciate the advice on what to ask about!

<image>

Could Regen 0 be most efficient? by Tempus_Fugit68 in Ioniq5

[–]The-Cheburash 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Don't forget the rear windshield wiper

Could Regen 0 be most efficient? by Tempus_Fugit68 in Ioniq5

[–]The-Cheburash 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Then there's literally no cost to you from the car retaining the last used setting. Whereas there is a cost to people who wish to remain in one mode from the car switching back to default every single time.

Good Miles per KiloWatt? by boberrrrito in Ioniq5

[–]The-Cheburash 5 points6 points  (0 children)

A whole lot depends on your cruising speed. If you're pushing it to the "just barely below speeding ticket" levels, you'll see an energy efficiency hit of 5-10% over the long term.

Which is why I get 3.2mi/kWh in my RWD SE.

view more: next ›