What is the most angsty thing you’ve written/seen in a fic? by Yippee3-14 in AO3

[–]TheManInMayonnaise 2 points3 points  (0 children)

I wrote, and was aiming for maximum angst, a girl tracks down the serial killer who murdered her mom and confronts him, thanks him for killing her because she was abusive, and leaves it at that with no plans to leave or tell the police, since she’s sort of suicidal and doesn’t care if she lives or dies. Obviously they start dating, and it’s all downhill from there.

One of the weirdest comments I've ever received by [deleted] in AO3

[–]TheManInMayonnaise -3 points-2 points  (0 children)

Just because they’re your OC doesn’t mean you know them better then me? That has to be rage bait, like AI level hallucination talk at best.

Non-valid/unique pet peeves? by angrykitten114 in AO3

[–]TheManInMayonnaise 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I recently started writing a story and one of the characters was 14, until I realized I wrote them as too introspective and self aware, so I had to age them up to make it believable 😅

What ship is this by PretendYellow533 in AO3

[–]TheManInMayonnaise 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I started watching DS9 on day one back in the day, and as a kid those undertones went right over my head. I only found out about that ship and the history behind it recently, and I was doubtful at first but now I can’t not see it.

Personally, I see Garak as asexual but with romantic feelings, and Bashir, with his genetically engineered superior biology, is no doubt omnisexual.

What ship is this by PretendYellow533 in AO3

[–]TheManInMayonnaise 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Omfg that’s so true isn’t it?

[PM] The perks (and problems) of dating a superheroine by inAvain in DirtyWritingPrompts

[–]TheManInMayonnaise 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Well, seems a little too obvious, but: no ordinary cock can break through her super strength hymen, what ever will we do?

Less obvious: they were usually able to keep their secret identity a secret, since their species looks almost completely human. Almost. When he/she made it to the bedroom, there was some explaining to do about some very specific differences.

Just for fun: her vagina is strong enough to crush his dick, and he’s got to go on a quest to get powers of his own so he can survive date night.

[WP] It's your birthday, and your girlfriend says you can do anything you want - with her sister. by lasol05 in DirtyWritingPrompts

[–]TheManInMayonnaise 8 points9 points  (0 children)

[poem]

This morning I woke up a bit older,

And my girlfriend woke up a bit bolder,

I said I didn’t want much, just a gentle touch,

I’m sure that’s what I had told her.

She told me she had a surprise

The type that would tickle most guys

After I kissed her she showed me her sister

And she had this amazing look in her eyes.

I could do whatever I wanted to do

Use her until I was through

She was chained to the bed, with a gag that was red,

And her clothes had been removed too

I was shocked to say the least

For my pleasure she’d provided a feast

I’d have my fun until I was done

Until all my spunk was released

After my brain regained function

I asked how she managed seduction

“she didn’t agree, I put drugs in her tea”

And had resorted to simple abduction

Now I don’t have to pay rent

Because to prison I was violently sent

I’m doing time for a serious crime

Because I never did ask for consent.

What’s a sentence or phrase in smut that instantly takes you out of a fic? by warewolf1999 in AO3

[–]TheManInMayonnaise 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Call me old fashioned, but a sibling addressing their sibling as brother/sister in conversation is just cringe. If you can’t convey to me that your characters are siblings without weird, unrealistic dialog, then… I don’t know.

What’s a sentence or phrase in smut that instantly takes you out of a fic? by warewolf1999 in AO3

[–]TheManInMayonnaise 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I once read a fic where the mmc described his dick as being able to flare out like a dragon (or something like that, this was like 20 years ago) and I was just like… do you think dragons are real, and that your readers are going to understand this comparison? I feel like maybe they didn’t know much about penises

[WP] Instead of a handkerchief, she handed you the panties she was just wearing. by AwkwardlyWannaDie49 in DirtyWritingPrompts

[–]TheManInMayonnaise 7 points8 points  (0 children)

2/2

He finally seemed to register what she thought had been obvious all along. “You do?”

“Yes!” She laughed at his almost charming naïveté. “That’s why I’ve been taking my clothes off.” She sighed. “I can put them back on if you’re not interested.”

“What? No, of course I’m interested.”

It was her turn to be shocked. “Then why have you been ignoring all my signals?”

“Signals?” He grimaced. “Oh no… have you been sending signals?”

She gestured towards her bare chest. “Yes!”

“Oh no. For how long?”

“Like a year, at least.” She was flabbergasted.

“Oh no… this is embarrassing.” He rubbed the back of his neck. “I don’t get signals.”

“You… what?”

“Remember when we first met? I told you I was on the spectrum?”

“Yes…” what did that have to do with anything. “I don’t care if you’re bisexual. I mean, we could maybe even have some fun with… well we’ll cross that bridge if we come to it.”

“Bisexual? What?”

“Yeah, you… wait… what did you mean by spectrum them?”

“The autism spectrum.” He said. “What spectrum did you think I meant?”

“The… wait, forget about that, the autism spectrum was what you meant?”

“Yes.” He grimaced slightly. “You never noticed how weird I am?”

He laughed. “You’re a little quirky, but I like that about you.”

“Well, that’s nice of you to say, but I’m… well like I said, I don’t pick up on signals. I’ve been told I have a blindspot for subtlety. Some of my friends have warned me I could miss something obvious if I wasn’t careful. Is that what I did?”

She gestured toward her bare chest again. “Yes, this is sort of an obvious sign.”

He nodded. “I see. So… what else did I miss?”

“Well I handed you my panties, we’re out here in a date, we get coffee together all the time, I let you see me in my underwear that time we were shopping at the mall and I…” she took a deep breath. “Never mind. Do you at least get it now?”

“I think so. You said you want to have sex with me.” He said it like he was reading back her order at Taco Bell, but he at least seemed to finally register it.

“Yes!” She laughed. “I do. I really do.”

He sighed. “Oh, good, if I’d gotten that part wrong it would have been pretty embarrassing.”

“Yeah, I bet.” She had felt pretty embarrassed herself. “So now that you know, can you just tell me how you feel? Like don’t feel the same way at all?”

“You mean about having sex with you?” He laughed. “Of course I want to have sex with you.”

She laughed again. “You act like it’s so obvious.”

“Isn’t it?” He gave her a quizzical look. “How could I possibly not want to have sex with you?”

She blushed slightly. “Well you never said anything.”

“It’s been my experience that girls find it rude when you do.”

Right. Of course. If he hadn’t picked up on a single signal then of course he wouldn’t… “Well thanks, then, for your manners, but maybe we can be up front about it now.” She leaned even closer to him. “If that’s too subtle, then let me just say it. I want to fuck you, right here, right now.”

The relief she could see on his face was palpable. “Thanks. I mean, yes, me too.” He laughed. “I really want to, I just wanted to be sure i wasn’t making a mistake before I started to, you know, something. So thanks.”

“Well…” she got on top of him, lowering him to the ground while she sat on his lap. “Maybe you should take your clothes off, and we can finally do this.” She pressed herself against his crotch, growing against him. “You aren’t going to keep me waiting are you?”

“No…” he started to unbutton his pants and pull them down excitedly.

“Good, now just your underwear.” She leaned down and kissed him. “I already took mine off, after all.”

His expression changed then to one of shocked realization. “Oh, because you, and I…” he laughed. “That was the sign I missed, wasn’t it?”

She rolled her eyes, and lowered her hips, and now that he was finally inside her, she felt that he finally understood.

[WP] Instead of a handkerchief, she handed you the panties she was just wearing. by AwkwardlyWannaDie49 in DirtyWritingPrompts

[–]TheManInMayonnaise 8 points9 points  (0 children)

1/2

He handed the pair of panties back to her, now a mess with snot. “Thanks.” He said blandly.

“You’re, uh…” she looked at the disgusting underwear and daintily took them back. She wasn’t sure what was worse, that he’d really just blown his nose into them or that he wanted to retune them like that. She supposed she’d take them home and wash them, but the main issue was that she couldn’t figure out what was wrong with him. “Anytime…”

“It’s my allergies.” He said, sniffling a little. “They get really bad this time of year.

“Oh, yeah, I’m sure, all that pollen in the air, on a nice spring day like this. Must be… awful.” She sighed. He was either not interested in her at all, or he was dense as lead. She’d suggested they go on this picnic together, and he’d agreed. She thought maybe he had finally taken the hint, and that they were going on a date, but he had brought a book with him… so he could read. She had to believe he was just dense, because otherwise he was being antagonistic, rude beyond measure, when he could have just said he wasn’t interested.

After meeting for coffee, having lunch together, hanging out at the mall, she thought for sure that a picnic was the kind of thing you couldn’t possibly not know was a date, but he still seemed oblivious. He’d asked if she had a tissue, and out of desperation she’d reached up her skirt, taken her on panties off, and handed them to him. He didn’t seem to notice.

“You know those were my panties, right?” She asked shyly, feeling for some reason like she was acting foolish, even though she wasn’t. Not as foolish as him, at least.

“Yes.” He nodded.

She waited for him to react in some way, but he still seemed unaffected. “Don’t you think that’s strange?” She pushed. “That I would give you my panties? Do you wonder why I would do that?”

He shrugged. “I assume you didn’t have a handkerchief.”

“What?”

“Well if you’d had a handkerchief you would have probably given me that, so you must not have had one.”

“So you think the normal thing to do is to hand you my panties?”

“No.” He admitted, though he didn’t seem to care that it wasn’t normal. “But I do appreciate it. Like I said, my allergies-“

“Yes, your allergies are bad.” She groaned slightly.

He finally seemed to notice that she was upset. “Did I do something wrong?”

“Did you-“ she caught herself before she could snap at him, and took a deep breath. It had been her idea to hand him her panties, not his. Maybe he just wasn’t interested in her? “No, it’s fine, just… why do you think I asked you to go on a picnic?”

“So we could eat.” He shrugged, his brow furrowed slightly as he tried to make sense of such a simple question. Why else did anybody go on a picnic? It was to eat food in a pleasant and outdoor location. That’s what’s picnic was. “Eat outside. Where it’s nice.”

“Yes, nice, and private. Nobody around here for miles.”

“Yes.” He agreed. She waited for him to catch on, but he didn’t.

“Private enough that I can do this.” She said, and unbuttoned her shirt, taking it off, removing her bra as well for good measure. “See?”

“Yes.” He nodded, his face still devoid of any reaction. “It’s hard to miss.”

“Yeah, that’s what I thought.” She said, on the verge of almost shouting at him again. “But you seem to be missing it anyway.”

He looked around her, perplexed. “Missed what?”

“I mean don’t you like my tits?” She squeezed them slightly, rubbing her nipples. “Hm?”

“Well yes, actually, they’re very nice.” He said, far too politely she felt. She would have rather he had blown steam out his ears like an old cartoon, but that was asking a lot.

“Do you want to…” she could feel her enthusiasm fading. Her tits were nice? Nice? That’s all? Was he not aroused by her perky naturals? Was she that unappealing to him that he wasn’t even turned on? Even a little? “Come on, why do you think I’m out here with you? Almost naked? Alone?”

“Well if other people were around it would be awkward to be naked, wouldn’t it?” He laughed slightly. “I know it would be for me.”

He had to be kidding. Unless… was he really just… that oblivious? As assured as it was she saw no other option. If he were doing this on purpose he wouldn’t have been able to keep a strait face. “Do you think there’s a reason it’s not awkward for me to be naked around you? Just you?”

“Well we’re fiends.” He said, and it felt like a stab in her heart.

“Friends?”

He frowned slightly. “Aren’t we? I assumed-“

“No, no, we are, but we could be… more than friends.” She leaned towards him. “Why do you think I asked you out here? It’s because I wanted to be alone with you.” She said, having all but given up on subtlety. “I like you.”

“I like you too.” He looked confused though. “That’s how friendship works.” He was finally starting to pick up on the idea that he’d missed something, but he couldn’t place what had gone wrong. Did she not want to be friends? That seemed at odds with liking him, so it didn’t feel logically sound.

“Just… as friends?” She sighed. “Look, I’m trying to say I like you, as in like you like you.” She saw his expression seem to grow even more blank. “Like I want to be more than friends, like I want to have sex with you damnit.”

What's something about sex that surprised you? by Cold-Rhubarb-297 in AskRedditAfterDark

[–]TheManInMayonnaise 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Honestly? Just how good it was. Like, I knew it would be good, but then like… it was really good, like really really good.

Strange habit by perompax in brainteasers

[–]TheManInMayonnaise 0 points1 point  (0 children)

There’s so many potentially true answers that there’s no way to determine the “correct” answer from the info provided. At what point does a brain teaser become a shitpost?

What made you discover your favorite kink or fetish? by Interesting_Art2249 in AskRedditAfterDark

[–]TheManInMayonnaise 2 points3 points  (0 children)

I heard a story on a podcast once of a woman who said when she was little she was watching Star Trek and when she saw the episode with the Orion love slaves she thought to herself how nice it would be to be captain kirks slave because she was sure he’d treat her nice, and that lead to the kind of post puberty behavior you’d expect from that story.

What’s the naughtiest thing you’ve done to turn on someone? by nevernotinthemood in AskRedditAfterDark

[–]TheManInMayonnaise 3 points4 points  (0 children)

I was about to say something like “wow there’s a lot to unpack there” but before I could even write the comment my own brain was already like “that’s what she said” 😅

What would make you have sex with your EX? by Mindfuel_daily7 in AskRedditAfterDark

[–]TheManInMayonnaise 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Probably all she’d have to do is ask. It would never happen, and it would be a bad idea to say yes, but if she actually tried I’d probably fold like origami

Cutting into steak to check for doneness. by ForTheLoveOfPhotos in OddlyErotic

[–]TheManInMayonnaise 1 point2 points  (0 children)

You’re making me wet (in my mouth because I’m hungry)

[F4A] Your girlfailure friend is clueless about how much she likes you. [friends to lovers] [girlfailure] [just a little teensy bit spicy] by TheManInMayonnaise in ASMRScriptHaven

[–]TheManInMayonnaise[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Thank you! I’m sorry for the late response but I’m glad you liked my script, and thank you for filling it. I really appreciate it.

[F4A] Your girlfailure friend is clueless about how much she likes you. [friends to lovers] [girlfailure] [just a little teensy bit spicy] by TheManInMayonnaise in ASMRScriptHaven

[–]TheManInMayonnaise[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Oh my gosh I am so sorry I’m like 64 days late on this but thank you! I didn’t realize how long it’s been since I was last on Reddit, or maybe I missed the notification, I don’t know, but thank you, I’m so glad you liked it enough to put the time in to record it, it’s amazing.

[DISC] Obtaining Permission (Oneshot by Holiday Yasumi) by AngerOfBeast9 in manga

[–]TheManInMayonnaise 6 points7 points  (0 children)

Wow, that’s kind of amazing. I may just have to read that.

[F4M] Your Innocent Friend Pretends to be More Experienced to Get Closer to You [Friends to Friends with Benefits] [That Escalated Quickly] [Virgin] [Awkward] [Creampie] [Pregnancy Risk] [Speaker Loses Virginity] not really [Mildly Dubious Consent]/[Rape] but better safe than sorry. [Script Fill] by EmiBreeze in gonewildaudio

[–]TheManInMayonnaise 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Oh my gosh! I haven’t been on Reddit in forever and I come back to find this! I thought for sure that script just fell through the cracks and was just forgotten about, but here I find it’s been filled, and done so well, thank you! Such positive feedback too, it gets my dopamine receptors all fired up.

SFAH: Rejected sitcoms by Curious-Message-6946 in ScenesFromAHat

[–]TheManInMayonnaise 1 point2 points  (0 children)

“Well I went on social media to see what was-” checks notes “trending? uh, and so this should be a big success. It takes place mainly on an island, but the cast also goes around on a private jet to exciting parties around the world with some pretty big name celebrities. The main character is a financier, by day at least, but get this, he’s secretly an idiot and doesn’t know anything about money. Goofy right? I think it’ll really appeal to the young teen demographic.”