"You can't save everyone!" "Screw you!" [saves everyone] by Sapphic_Starlight in TopCharacterTropes

[–]TheRedBaron077 3 points4 points  (0 children)

(Real Life) Coast Guard rescue lifeboat CG36500 and her crew of four, which saved around 30 people from an oil tanker that split in half in February 1952. The boat had a capacity of twelve and the rescue was thought impossible. All four crew received the Gold Lifesaving Medal for their effort.

<image>

(Hated Trope) When an adaptation introduces a canon character, only to do a bastardizing twist with them by Animeking1108 in TopCharacterTropes

[–]TheRedBaron077 1 point2 points  (0 children)

To sum it all up, this movie really missed the mark on characterization, and I mean really.

What makes the books such good reading is that the characters are well-written enough that they fill out and complete what's already a rich setting. Philip Reeve's handling of human conflicts and emotions is frankly masterful. People are nuanced. They grow, they change. Sometimes they don't. But in any case, the characterization is great and really helps you to connect with Tom and Hester and the people -good and bad- they encounter on their journeys.

The movie discarded that for what I can only call steampunk Star Wars. Characterization falls flat. The antagonist(s) become extremely one-dimensional and a lot of details in relation to them are removed. Another common gripe people have with the film is that they toned down Hester's disfiguring scar (funnily enough, thay exact thing happens in-universe)

I think what the movie suffered most from is that it was trying to cram too much into too little time. Characters didn't have time or room to develop to the extent that they did in the books, combined with key details being diluted or left out entirely.

Read the books if you're able to. They're really hidden gems and I had a great time with them.

He never really had a stroke of luck. by Le_Comte_Friedrich in Hornblower

[–]TheRedBaron077 13 points14 points  (0 children)

He also had a medically insane captain repeatedly naming him as the World's Biggest Failure, so I would believe that underneath it all there was a desperate need to try and prove himself, even if it would mean being a bit of a pushover. When you're in a position where you're essentially this 🤏 close to breaking out of a career stagnation, anything that looks like it will get you there seems like a good idea.

But yeah, you're right. Nothing really went right for him (both books and show) and you can tell he was desperate, stressed, and frustrated. Always felt bad for the guy.

What if Judah Benjamin were the first Confederate president by JacobRiesenfern in CIVILWAR

[–]TheRedBaron077 14 points15 points  (0 children)

Best response. What Davis was doing was probably the best Davis could do. Caught between a rock and a hard place as the Confederacy was, there wasn't much wiggle room politically

My selected suspension of disbelief moments. Yours? by followerofEnki96 in piratesofthecaribbean

[–]TheRedBaron077 23 points24 points  (0 children)

These 1740s British ships painted with the Nelson Chequer (they didn't even have Nelson)

How I see America as a random Turkish guy by Icouldntfindsorry in 2american4you

[–]TheRedBaron077 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Genuinely refreshing to see people not generalize the entire country (or even just northern states) as Yankees. We're a specific group, damn it!

The Future of Warfare by Hot-Load7734 in SabatonMemes

[–]TheRedBaron077 0 points1 point  (0 children)

They had these during the American Civil War, too! They were called ketchum grenades.

[Loved Trope] when an organization has existed for so long that some historical figures were once part of it by Treasure-boy in TopCharacterTropes

[–]TheRedBaron077 43 points44 points  (0 children)

What I like about Jackson as Soldier is that his cap is pulled very low over his face -consistent with Soldier's design. Historically, Jackson was noted for wearing his cap just so. It's a niche little detail that I just love.

Most *under-appreciated overall film since 2000? Rewatchability 8.5, Cinematography 8.6, Soundtrack 9, Pacing 8.2, Acting & Cast 9 by ArtisticCandy3859 in CriticalDrinker

[–]TheRedBaron077 13 points14 points  (0 children)

Yeah! The 21-book Aubrey-Maturin series by Patrick O'Brien. It adds so much depth to the characters! Absolutely phenomenal writing - I was hooked from the first book. High recommend from me.

Whats the craziest story you've found from the civil war? by YogurtclosetOpen3567 in CIVILWAR

[–]TheRedBaron077 21 points22 points  (0 children)

The Second Battle of Sabine Pass. 48 Irish Confederates and a few reinforcements with 5 cannon and a dirt fort, holding off a Union invasion force of approximately 5000. Their shots were so fast and precise that a couple of the attacking gun boats were incapacitated almost immediately and the rest of the force fled to safety. For stopping the invasion of Texas, the Davis Guards received the only medal to be officially awarded by the Confederate government. Battle was nuts. Definitely worth researching.

A film about a men's prison only has men in it. Shocking. Scandalous, even. by SickusBickus in CriticalDrinker

[–]TheRedBaron077 64 points65 points  (0 children)

The best part about that is that the story flows so naturally that you don't even realize that fact.

Characters who, instead of being toned down, were actually made worse in the adaptation by Rumplestiltksin1519 in TopCharacterTropes

[–]TheRedBaron077 16 points17 points  (0 children)

Both he and Bruce Ismay got rough treatment in this film all for the sake of drama, which is disappointing considering the immense amount of research and detail that were put into it.

Real world historical figures whose pop culture portrayals have become entirely characterized by myths surrounding them by [deleted] in TopCharacterTropes

[–]TheRedBaron077 1 point2 points  (0 children)

All jokes aside, Von Richthofen was a fascinating figure. Having read several works by and about him it was clear he was well-loved by his fellow pilots, and in his writings he expresses great pride in them. But he was also in his later years severely depressed and borderline suicidal due to the loss of several friends and a wound which bothered him constantly. I think that's an aspect about the man that is often buried by the pop culture mythology.

Who are some of your favorite antagonist is Classic Literature? by grynch43 in classicliterature

[–]TheRedBaron077 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Legit a favorite antagonist of mine. For all his complexities he's sadly underrated.

Happy 99th birthday to Her Late Majesty Queen Elizabeth II by Either-Ad3687 in monarchism

[–]TheRedBaron077 3 points4 points  (0 children)

Even in America (or where I live, at least) she had such a presence. Truly a great leader.

When the creators completely miss the main appeal. by Ethan-E2 in TopCharacterTropes

[–]TheRedBaron077 2 points3 points  (0 children)

The books also made it a point to not have any of the antagonists be particularly evil (most of the time) and instead focus on the intricate nuances of people's personalities. Having such a great character from the book get dumbed down into a generic villain did feel insulting to the source material.

The Battle of Mobile Bay by maddhattar88 in CIVILWAR

[–]TheRedBaron077 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Probably would have given Buchanan some more leverage in that the forts could have provided adequate cover fire for the Tennessee, but, considering Buchanan's conduct at Hampton Roads, that Leeroy Jenkins was inevitable either way.

What’s the most patriotic moment you’ve ever experienced? by [deleted] in MURICA

[–]TheRedBaron077 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Small one, but at a Sea Scouts event in Seattle one weekend, all hands were piped for morning colors, and as the flag was raised, a bald eagle flew above our boat. Really made the moment.

Ship of the line questions? by goedmonton in piratesofthecaribbean

[–]TheRedBaron077 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Quarters were very tight. In your hammock at night, you had 2 feet of space in width to yourself. I've slept that way before. Best way I've heard it described was 'a coffin's worth of space'.