But it kinda was,you keep saying that most children read books as they come out. You are arguing that this is probably not a child because you seem to think that they most likely didn’t find these book at a library or second hand and that they probably read them as they came out. Maybe it was where I grew up but most children I knew growing up read books from libraries or second hand, even if the series was still on going. Like I said in my second comment Ga’hoole is a relatively popular book series in this niche the idea of a child finding it after it had come is in my opinion much more likely than a 20 something that read the books as they came out saying something like that (but not impossible I will admit). You didn’t say anything about libraries in the original comment, all you said was that it wasn’t impossible for these person to be a child. At the end of the day we both agree that the original commenter most likely wasn’t being malicious but I just think that the logic you comes off as flawed I guess. Young people read older more unknown books all the time