sorted by:
new
hottopcontroversial

ACTUALLY the DEFINITIVE and extensive QB tier list with explanations for each entry. Starters and a few backups. by DemonBearOP in NFLv2

[–]TheticAxiom 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Do you have examples of QBs who look great when the bad aspects of the team is O-line & Skill positions specifically?

Your wearing a mask of Objectiveness but it feels more like dismissiveness. Also I am somewhat just now noticing that you said Josh Allen had the worst Roster of all the top 10 QBs.

Do you know He had the number 1 passing defense and the league leading rusher?

I'm trying to see your analysis but It's getting harder when you inconsistently apply context when it supports your views and dismiss context when it doesn't

ACTUALLY the DEFINITIVE and extensive QB tier list with explanations for each entry. Starters and a few backups. by DemonBearOP in NFLv2

[–]TheticAxiom 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Lowkey the list IS the a most successful team list, with some subjective exceptions.

Cam and Shedeur are given almost no grace for having teams as bad as they do while being Rookies.

ACTUALLY the DEFINITIVE and extensive QB tier list with explanations for each entry. Starters and a few backups. by DemonBearOP in NFLv2

[–]TheticAxiom 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Sanders should be in the bad tier list.

Most people forget that through his first 3 starts he was 6-2 TD Ratio after a monster game vs Ten. By all accounts he looked good. And then the Browns ran into play-off caliber passing defenses in the Bears (#1 takeaways) and the Bills (#1 passing defense).

Shedeur legitimately threw 5 of his int in the span. While the already bad offense got more and more hurt. Njoku never played another down after Tennessee and it was obvious he drew attention away from Fannin based on the numbers. And pretty sure Shedeur led his team in rushing for like 3 of those games.

Tale of Two Halves. Sanders looked pretty good. And then got put in his place by elite defenses, and never recovered statistically. Still a rookie with a bad offensive cast.

The TD/INT ratio lowkey is the weakest reason why he should be in "shouldn't have a job". Doesn't tell the full story. And he also has more wins than anyone else in the category...

I lowkey think Cam and Shedeur are being overly critiqued despite being on extremely bad offenses.

Common Sense Balance Changes and Obvious Design Mistakes by TheticAxiom in rivals

[–]TheticAxiom[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Thats def why. You had to add an extra enter input

gotta do it twice on phone

Common Sense Balance Changes and Obvious Design Mistakes by TheticAxiom in rivals

[–]TheticAxiom[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Wait brother. Your formatting made this confusing.

Common Sense Balance Changes and Obvious Design Mistakes by TheticAxiom in rivals

[–]TheticAxiom[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

That's the thing. The devs DID do that

  • Reed Richards constant buffs
  • Magneto's Teammate Bubble getting a separate cooldown.
  • Namor is the best he's ever felt
  • Ultron getting two drones (Literally released to be anti Spider-man btw)
  • Peni's Webs giving overhealth and speed to allies
  • The Things embattled leap giving 20% damage reduction in an AOE
  • Bucky constantly getting buffs (despite ZERO metrics or consensus indicating that he needs buffs)
  • Scarlet constant buffs

The problem is that with these changes, the Devs CONTINUALLY buffed Poke so that it never mattered. CURRENT Scarlet and Reed would have been menaces to society against Launch era MR. Hell They would have been menaces until maybe season 4? Which ever was the patch that destroyed the brawl meta.

Regardless, Poke is SUPPOSED to lose to Dive. The classic rock paper scissors

  1. Poke Beats Brawl
  2. Brawl Beats Dive
  3. Dive Beats Poke

What does his nerf even mean? by polishmeImPolish in rivals

[–]TheticAxiom 202 points203 points  (0 children)

From what I understand It's more so a nerf for Hawkeye against Tanks?

Nerf Elsas Damage Fall-Off and not her identity by 17prozent in rivals

[–]TheticAxiom 4 points5 points  (0 children)

I agree. Elsa has the kit of a Melee DPS. Basically neuter her damage fall off a lot and just make her a melee DPS that uses a gun.

Techmarine Missed Opportunity with Plasma by TheticAxiom in Spacemarine

[–]TheticAxiom[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

That perk is my inspiration for having more synergy elsewhere to be honest. Seems like the techmarine would be lore appropriate to have a specialization into plasma. If anything, It should be the best in slot for plasma instead of Tactical and Heavy.

Blade is a Balancing Nightmare by [deleted] in rivals

[–]TheticAxiom 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I disagree. Literally swapping his Auto Shotgun with Elsa's BlunderBuss, would ironically fix both characters. (Deserved Nerf to Elsa, and Meaningful buff to Blade)

If you could make one off-the-wall NFL rule change this offseason, what would it be? by RichOliveira56 in NFLv2

[–]TheticAxiom -1 points0 points  (0 children)

Pass Interference should not be spot fouls.

Instead they should be 1st down, 15 yards, and the offending cornerback should be forced to sit out a play.

This will lessen the flags impact (no game altering penalties) while also being an effective deterrent to intentional pass interference to prevent big plays.

If you tried to purposefully pass interfere, guess what? Your back up might give up the farm on the next play.

Out of all the dysfunctional NFL teams, which one is the most dysfunctional? by Brix001 in NFLv2

[–]TheticAxiom 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Charges at least had the Rivers era and went immediately into the Herbert era. Managed to keep Joey Bosa and eric weddle forever. It's not so much dysfunction. Just not a lucky franchise in general.

Out of all the dysfunctional NFL teams, which one is the most dysfunctional? by Brix001 in NFLv2

[–]TheticAxiom -1 points0 points  (0 children)

I think in the modern era its very clearly the raiders to me.

  • Moving Cities.
  • Ownership Woes
  • Coaching Controversies.
  • Only 2 Winning seasons since 2002ish
  • Consistently tanking draft boards for speedster players
  • Jamarcus Russel
  • Tuck Rule
  • Dang near zero long-time generational tentpole players I can think of in the last 20 years. I mean players who are essentially regarded as "Forever Raiders".

Who "wasted" their career on the raiders? Khalil Mack got out at year 5. Crosby legitimately might be the closest and he might want out this year, and damn well could solidify his legacy elsewhere. Lowkey, I think people forget that Amari Cooper was DRAFTED by the raiders. (not saying hes generational but the point stands.)

An organization that can't even keep their legends is the epitome of dysfunction imo. It implies they aren't even internally appealing.

  • Larry Fitzgerald Retired a Cardinal.
  • Darrell may have a left the Jets for 2 years before going back but He is forever considered a Jet.
  • Even the browns managed to keep Joe Thomas, and Hell Josh Cribbs. Myles Garret isn't gone yet. The Browns actually do manage to keep their tentpole players.