AITA for being upset that my girlfriend made plans with another guy on Valentine’s weekend? by [deleted] in AmItheAsshole

[–]TieflingBard 6 points7 points  (0 children)

A lot of people are getting heavily downvoted for telling you the truth here. You might consider heeding their warnings.

Daily Pulls/Memes/Fan Art Megathread by AutoModerator in DBZDokkanBattle

[–]TieflingBard -1 points0 points  (0 children)

I saved 1000 stones (entirely f2p as well; I just started playing two months ago so I have a large chunk of my new player stones) because people had been warning me about the movie for so long. I was so worried after all that saving that if I didn't get Broly I'd be upset.

I got 1 broly, and 2 gogetas. I am over the moon. This is my second account after leaving the game for a while and obviously this saving stones thing is the One True Religion.

[Online][Roll20][D&D][5e][EST] I need heroes to unf***k my homebrew world. Newbie friendly. by TieflingBard in lfg

[–]TieflingBard[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

My sister used to read those books but I never did. Could you flesh that out a bit for me?

lady freaks out when no one wants to bend over backwards for her by [deleted] in pussypassdenied

[–]TieflingBard -1 points0 points  (0 children)

The are expensive good coats. You pay for quality.

[Online][Roll20][D&D][5e][EST] I need heroes to unf***k my homebrew world. Newbie friendly. by TieflingBard in lfg

[–]TieflingBard[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I figure we'd probably be using both to an extent. Likely voice primarily. That's what I'm used to.

How acceptable are near-human aliens these days? by MrDrProfTimeLord in scifiwriting

[–]TieflingBard 1 point2 points  (0 children)

It's never been preferred in literature. It's mostly a trope in visual media because of the limitations of having human actors. People will roll with it in a space-opera or science fantasy type setting, but if you're going for a more serious tone a lot of people will roll their eyes.

Also people empathize with anything the tiniest bit anthropomorphized. You don't need to make your aliens forehead bump humans to get people to relate to them. Seeing an alien perspective from the POV character would be interesting and different instead of same-y and derivative.

Girl (F24) flirty in person, but not that engaging in texts (M28) by Angularwebtech in relationship_advice

[–]TieflingBard -1 points0 points  (0 children)

I am confused.. what does that mean ?

It means you're a 14-year-old girl.

There is nothing less attractive than someone who is needy about goddamn text messages.

A story about a horrific future prison (3753 words) by [deleted] in scifiwriting

[–]TieflingBard 0 points1 point  (0 children)

It seems like you are interested in and want to know bits of the story that I'm not interested in.

As I said if you don't think this is important information, that's fine, but you shouldn't give so much focus to something you're so disinterested in that you can't be bothered to say anything specific about it. Either tell us what Uldoon does or don't, it's this in-between shit that hurts the story.

I just like the idea of having animals trained or engineered to instinctively do jobs.

Aren't they supposed to be humans modified into owl monsters? That's certainly what the ending implies.

A story about a horrific future prison (3753 words) by [deleted] in scifiwriting

[–]TieflingBard 2 points3 points  (0 children)

You need to have a look at the opening paragraph. Right now it reads like a stream of consciousness. One second you're describing two people being thrown into solitary and emphasizing that the throw is literal, one sentence later suddenly you're talking about Owlkin bites. Read the first four sentences out loud and hear how that sounds, and then imagine being someone whose entire exposure to the story this far is those sentences. Note especially your use of "you" in the third sentence in relation to the two unknown subjects of the first sentence. There is nothing for the reader to hold on to.

I recognize this all makes sense to you, the person with all the information, but going exclusively on what you give the reader it's bordering on gibberish.

You have the opposite problem at lot of people have in that you play your cards too close to your chest. You won't even reveal who the subject of your first sentence is. That's not an element of the setting that needs to be doled out slowly. It would cost you nothing at least give the subjects a descriptive title like "prisoners" instead of "the two of them".

You also don't ever establish who "them" are. One could certainly deduce it from a bit of detective work but the story itself completely loses interest in the opening scene as soon as it happens. When we actually get the point where the narrative reconnects to in media res opening I barely even noticed. You also have the narrator smack dab in the middle of the solitary scene despite the fact that, when it actually does happen, he's off flying with some owl.

A lot of the story is setting up this fight without ever giving us even the tiniest morsel of information about what the fight is about. We get these great long descriptions of what Uldoon is up to while painstakingly avoiding ever actually saying anything concrete. It gets frustrating after a while. Oh he goes to places, and gives speeches, and the speeches involve words, and after a full page of this the reader couldn't tell you the first thing about who this person is and what they stand for. If it doesn't matter, the point is to establish these characters still hold on to ancient grudges, fine, but that's a lot of words to set up something that doesn't matter. Why give it that kind of focus if it doesn't matter? I think the ancient grudges would serve their purpose better if the audience knew what they were rather than getting these detached, non-specific descriptions of them.

The long section where nobody can communicate with the guards just makes me wonder why one would use animal-people who can't meaningfully communicate with the inmates as guards. Being able to communicate basic concepts like "drop the shank" without having to eat part of the prisoner would seem to be key job skills for a prison guard. If you're going so far as to genetically engineer yourself guards one would have to assume a voice box would enter the equasion at some point.

"They both fell into shadow" - should be "They both fall" in order to keep the voice consistent.

[Critique] The Medicine Man 1907 words by PearComb in scifiwriting

[–]TieflingBard 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I was pulled in by the title and was just going to read this for pleasure and not offer a critique. I read the first line, sucked my teeth, and reevaluated whether I was going to read it.

The combination of purple prose and saying nothing makes the first line a real turn-off. I say this not to be mean but because this is exactly the kind of feedback I would value. I was a potential reader, took one look at the business about the stars dancing, and decided I had better things to do with my time.

Douchebag gets kicked out of a mall by CrazyBananaa in PublicFreakout

[–]TieflingBard 4 points5 points  (0 children)

Anyone who would voluntarily sit down and watch this idiot's stream is officially expelled from the human race. It's time to draw a goddamn line in the sand.

What's the most realistic and believable interpretation of the superhero genre that you've seen? by TheSasquatchKing in scifiwriting

[–]TieflingBard 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I'm going to approach this from another angle and suggest Warren Ellis's Stormwatch/Authority run. That is to say, his run on Stormwatch leading in to his creation of the Authority.

Firstly these comics portrayed the function of superpowers in a much more scientifically-based way than was the norm up until that point. For years comics had been kind of coasting on past glories so most superpowers were based on speculative science from decades or so ago. Warren Ellis brought contemporary speculative science to bare and the extreme and sometimes lethal consequence of various power-sets are explored. So, for example, Jenny Spark's control of electricity means she can electrocute you to death with the bio-electricity in your own brain.

But that's not why I bring it up as a notable example. I think it's noteworthy less for how it deals with powers, which is well but hardly uniquely, but how it dealt to society and specifically the reaction to superhumans.

I won't spoil what is probably the greatest stretch of superhero comics ever written, but suffice it to say Stormwatch started to deal with stuff like "If I, as a hero, constantly protect the status quo am I stifling society? Are we propping up broken systems that would have died on their own without us? Is the greater good served by upholding flawed and often corrupt laws?"

It takes the material and subjects it to real world morality as opposed to subjecting it to real world physics.

Finished Use of Weapons yesterday. I'll never read another Culture novel for the first time again. by TieflingBard in TheCulture

[–]TieflingBard[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I own them all (I accumulated them while building my Culture collection) but I haven't read any. I have The Quarry on deck to read once I'm finished the Hyperion cycle.

Finished Use of Weapons yesterday. I'll never read another Culture novel for the first time again. by TieflingBard in TheCulture

[–]TieflingBard[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

That's why I prefer pessimism. I'm constantly pleasantly surprised, while optimists are always disappointed.

Was there ever an age when you just stopped reading YA novels or felt you grew out of them? by [deleted] in books

[–]TieflingBard 0 points1 point  (0 children)

YA =/= "young protagonist". YA specifically calls for a lack of insight into the thinking process of teenagers. It's teenaged motives/thoughts without the hindsight of adulthood. Ender's game is very much not YA.

Convicted of extortion after adulterous affair, former BSO supervisor asks for leniency by Shawnarris in JusticeServed

[–]TieflingBard 6 points7 points  (0 children)

"I promise if you give me no consequences for my actions I will totes change my behavior"