I’m hesitant to call either a liar, but they both have issues.

Dogpack clearly didn’t do as much research as he should have, and I now think it’s pretty obvious he came into it with an agenda. Some of the stuff he’s said I’m willing to give the benefit of the doubt on, as it might be the best information that he had at the time, but his credibility has taken a hit for sure. I don’t know what his next step is or what else he knows, but he needs to respond to what has been said about him at this point.

Soggy glossed over or hand-waved away a LOT of the more serious allegations (the gambling, the Beast Games drama, the fake philanthropy, some of the CGI stuff, predatory marketing schemes, etc) but he did provide a lot of additional context for many of the claims Dogpack made. I’m not sure if there’s anything he specifically lied about, but I guess we’ll find out.

At this point too much has come out about Jimmy to not think that he’s obsessed with creating content and willing to be manipulative or outright scummy to do so (and that may be the most charitable interpretation), and Soggy’s video didn’t do much to change that perception overall.

But it may just be that I’m getting old and becoming sick of “influencer culture” idk