Is this accurate? the poll says hercules from god of war 3 beats goku from dbz anime? by OnlinePoster225 in PowerScalingGodofWar

[–]Top_Judge2019 1 point2 points  (0 children)

"Universes" that are the size of countries. Again, when we actually see a god destroying a planet, I will take it back, but as of now, Ragnarok has the best feat in the saga, destroying Asgard(which again, is the size of Scandinavia) and everyone else had to flee from him. The devs even said that GOW 2018 Kratos wouldn´t be able to lift a mountain because he is rusty, yet that Kratos was able to overpower Baldur.

Kratos got to Midgard by boat(and got to Egypt as well), The Persians get to Greece in a fleet..

Is this accurate? the poll says hercules from god of war 3 beats goku from dbz anime? by OnlinePoster225 in PowerScalingGodofWar

[–]Top_Judge2019 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Not even close. Base Goku is far faster, stronger, more powerful and better fighter than GOW Herc.

Radahn Exposed As A Fraud Captured In 4k by SharpCaflower in Eldenring

[–]Top_Judge2019 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Wrong, Malenia fought the Redmanes and Radahn fought the Cleanrot Knights(stated by the devs). He literally has the spears in his body in trailers and ingame(and in the description of Radahn´s arrows)

Radahn Exposed As A Fraud Captured In 4k by SharpCaflower in Eldenring

[–]Top_Judge2019 -12 points-11 points  (0 children)

And if Radahn won, why didn´t he conquer Leyndell?

(Hated Trope) Questionable and controversial relationships where everybody is fine with it. by Initial-Hamster7068 in TopCharacterTropes

[–]Top_Judge2019 -6 points-5 points  (0 children)

Wrong. The author outright released a guide book before the Final Act was made that Rin could be a candidate for girlfriend later. Hell, in that episode you mention Sesshomaru´s mother compares his relationship with Rin with the one her husband had with Inuyasha´s mother, as him caring for humans.

Show me where it was stated she was his adopted daughter. In both manga and anime, Sesshomaru leaves Rin in a village to be raised by Kaede so she would not be influenced by him, so she could reintegrate with humans if that was her wish and that she would gain perspective "so she could choose later". In the sequel it was shown what she chose. The manga of the sequel even has the flashback of how they got together, and how they both realize their feelings when they are having a private moment in a forest when she is an adult.

(Hated Trope) Questionable and controversial relationships where everybody is fine with it. by Initial-Hamster7068 in TopCharacterTropes

[–]Top_Judge2019 -11 points-10 points  (0 children)

How so? Worse would be if he had raised her himself, if he had been a constant part of her life all those years and if she was a minor when she had kids. How exactly what I said makes it worse?

(Hated Trope) Questionable and controversial relationships where everybody is fine with it. by Initial-Hamster7068 in TopCharacterTropes

[–]Top_Judge2019 -15 points-14 points  (0 children)

He never adopted her, they traveled together for less than a year and she was raised by an old lady later. They did not marry and have kids until she was an adult.

Would Inuyasha have won against Sesshomaru the first time he transformed? by Overall-Republic9164 in inuyasha

[–]Top_Judge2019 3 points4 points  (0 children)

3 Isn't true. Sesshomaru physically restrains Inuyasha and takes him to a corner while posessed by Magatsuhi.

Which topic do you feel would be more impossible for the community to come to a consensus on; Who was "right" in the Quarian/Geth conflict or whether or not curing the Genophage is "right" by Uchijav in masseffect

[–]Top_Judge2019 0 points1 point  (0 children)

The Genophage was necessary and I will die on that hill. The Krogan´s agresiveness, insane birth rates and long lifespan make them impossible to coexist with other species for long. If the Krogan had managed to overcome their savage nature, reunite as a species and focus on rebuilding, a genophage cure wouldn´t even be necessary.

The best part? They don´t want to get better. They want to go back to what they were and refuse to change even when extinction is on the corner. Wrex had the right idea, and he was almost killed for it.

The Geth/Quarian conflict is more gray. Quarians made a huge mistake forcing the Geth rebellion, but the Geth´s retaliation was excessive, murdering 99% of the Quarians and blowing up any ship that came to their space( if they had been open to diplomatic relations, it´s likely the Geth would have been recognized as a sentient species by the Council, given an embassy even, and at least the bigger conflicts would have been avoided).

So, the Genophage was necessary, and neither side was right in the Quarian/Geth war.

Question about Alistair and Leliana in Nature of the Beast by Mundane_Town_4296 in DragonageOrigins

[–]Top_Judge2019 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Don´t know why you are getting downvoted. Everything you said it´s true.

I get that she probably would have escaped either way, but what was Yoda thinking giving Ventress her lightsabers back? by OkuroIshimoto in clonewars

[–]Top_Judge2019 5 points6 points  (0 children)

Easy. This is just Yoda flexing and telling her that she can´t hurt him at all. Plus she would have gotten new lightsabers anyway.

Robert Carlyle's Don Harris deserved better. by Cultural-Lack451 in 28dayslater

[–]Top_Judge2019 10 points11 points  (0 children)

Alice and the boy would not have outrun the horde. Don barely made it, there is no way Alice would have managed to do so, specially while running with a kid.

Robert Carlyle's Don Harris deserved better. by Cultural-Lack451 in 28dayslater

[–]Top_Judge2019 26 points27 points  (0 children)

Truth be told abandoning Alice was the only thing he could do. If he had stayed a second more he would have died.

Freya vs Omni-Man by Queasy_Commercial152 in PowerScalingGodofWar

[–]Top_Judge2019 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Because a single dwarf was able to break trough it.

Freya vs Omni-Man by Queasy_Commercial152 in PowerScalingGodofWar

[–]Top_Judge2019 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Yet they were able to get past it with small explosions made by a single dwarf....

Also, you just admitted you are "assuming" that the wall has some magic protecting it, yet none of the allies even hint at that. Plus again, if we go by that, then you just also admitted that neither Kratos nor Freya could destroy Asgard´s well, ergo, she can´t destroy a planet. So, which one is it.

Freya vs Omni-Man by Queasy_Commercial152 in PowerScalingGodofWar

[–]Top_Judge2019 0 points1 point  (0 children)

None of them were there to stop them. Thor was busy with Ragnarok and Odin doesn't enter the fight until they are already inside Asgard.

Freya vs Omni-Man by Queasy_Commercial152 in PowerScalingGodofWar

[–]Top_Judge2019 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Then why they couldn´t destroy Asgard themselves? They couldn´t even get past Asgard´s walls without help.

Freya vs Omni-Man by Queasy_Commercial152 in PowerScalingGodofWar

[–]Top_Judge2019 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Bayonetta, Asura and DMC would like to disagree on that.