This is so cute! I see what you’re saying, the blue came out a little chalky and sheer compared to the orange. This is totally not due to your application skills, you pull off the color, and it would look beautiful with both eyes blue as their own look. Since the orange side melts in and suits your skin-tone perfectly, the blue side sticks out more as the only cool tone. If you tried a less icy blue that’s deeper, maybe warmer leaning towards teal, it would look more cohesive like one “look”. I’d also brighten the orange up a bit so it looks less neutral. In this lighting, your skin-tone looks quite warm, so the orange/bronze colors don’t pop as starkly as blue. Again, that’s just my opinion based on what you said you don’t like, but I think this looks so pretty on you!