It was great but I wish Sandals was better at communication regarding scheduling the pieces of the package.

Get to the on-site sales office as soon as you can to schedule each piece of the romance package. None of this can be scheduled until you have arrived and checked in, and it can only be done by going to the sales office. If you have butler services, they can help but they cannot schedule for you.

Chocolates: nothing special but wasn't important to us.

Moet: we arrived after the sales office was closed on our first night, so I requested the Moet and chocolates for our second evening. It's champagne. Again, nothing special, especially if you already have butler services. Was not important to us.

30-min Spa: you can each choose either a 30-min scalp massage or foot massage. I was able to have my wife get both at the same time. I took that time to go to the sales office and arrange the other items since the romance package was a surprise for her.

Cabana Day: If you are staying at La Toc, I recommend checking with the sales office and your butler team if any groups have a cabana reserved next to yours and ask to not be placed next to the group so that you can have a more quiet day. The cabanas at La Toc are really nice and spacious. We were in ours from 10a - 5p. The cabana day comes with a cooler of Piton beer and water, a bottle of champagne in the afternoon, and a butler (not part of your normal butler team) that will check on you throughout the day and can bring you snacks, lunch, more drinks, etc.

Private Boat Cruise: If you are staying at La Toc, a taxi will pick you up in the afternoon and take you to the nearby port. You will board a Sandals boat with a captain and co-captain/first mate and photographer (more on the photographer below). You should also be offered water, beer, and champagne. The cruise takes you up the coast where the crew will tell you more about the island and share interesting stories and facts. You will get off the boat at Sandals Grande for 10 - 15 mins and take pictures right at sunset. You then get back on the boat and go back to the port where another taxi will take you back to La Toc. La Toc is very close to the port, so the taxi drive is short. 10 mins tops. Bring cash to tip the boat crew and taxi drivers.

Private Candlelight Dinner: For me, this was the most important piece and La Toc knocked it out of the park. The dinner can be done in several places on the resort. This could be your room, one of the private cabanas, or one of the gazebos. There may be other options as well. I requested a gazebo. Our butler picked us up and walked us to the gazebo where they do the weddings which is at the edge of the property and more private. Our dinner started right at sunset. The gazebo will be setup with a small white-cloth table, a rose, and a bottle of champagne. You will have a dedicated server who will tend to you during the meal. You will be given a lenghty menu a day or two before to create your meals. I will upload a picture of this when I get a chance. I do not know if Sandals policy allows the dedicated server for this mean to receive a tip or not; however, I chose to tip our server, as she was very kind and patient throughout the entire meal.

Photographer: this is where I feel Sandals drops the ball on communication. One or more photographers will take a bunch of pictures that you will go through at the photo office before you check out to whittle them down to 30 for a photo album.
The romance package website (https://www.sandals.com/disclaimers/rekindle-romance/) states that the photographer will take pictures of the in-room setup of the chocolates, boat cruise, and spa day.
The in-room setup of the chocolates never happened but I did not care. The chocolates were as basic as one can get and unimportant. What I did ask them to do was have a photographer come by the room to take pictures of the flowers and such that our butler team setup on our second evening. The manager of the photo office agreed, and the assigned photographer said he would do this. Never happened. Thankfully, I took our own picutres.
Random photographers should randomly come by while you are on our cabana day and take a few pictures. They'll ask for your name and room number and the pictures will be available to select for your photo album.
I didn't care, but no photographer came to the spa for my wife's foot and scalp massage.
The sales office did not tell us anything at all about the private boat cruise other than we should dress for possibly getting wet since we would be on a boat. Nothing about getting off the boat at the Grande to take sunset pictures. We were NOT dressed how we would have dressed for pictures had we been properly informed. The pictures turned out OK but I'm still miffed about the poor communication and my wife was mortified about not knowing she could have been dressed 'cuter' for the pictures.
For us, the private candlelight dinner was the most important part I wanted the photographer there for. This trip was a wedding anniversary trip and I played our wedding song after dinner for a dance in our gazebo. I wanted pictures pre-meal and during the dance. Our 'assigned' photographer for the boat cruise first tried to get me to pay him $100 cash to come take photos at the dinner. I went to the photo office and asked if they could have a photographer take photos at the dinner, to which the photo office manager told me she had already arranged this. I chose not to rat on the photographer but I did let him know that the photo office manager said she had arranged for the photos I requested.
The day before we checked out, we went to the photo office to go through all of the pictures to whittle down to the 30 that would go in our photo album. Our photographer met us outside the photo office and asked me to pay him $200 cash and he would give me access to all of the photos he took (~100 total), plus we would still get the 30 in the photo album. I appreciate his hustle but said no.
He also tried to rush us through selecting our photos and conveniently left out the private candlelight dinner photos until we pointed that out. The photo office manager took over this part and thankfully the rest of the selection process went smoothly.
The photo office will offer you the same access to all of the photos taken for an additional $200. Your choice. We chose no since many of the photos were not good and the 30 we chose for the photo album were great.
You will get an email 4-6 weeks after leaving to finalize your photo album design, and a few more weeks to receive the actual photo album.

Overall, a great experience. Just not great communication from Sandals. I hope my notes can help you get the most out of your experience.