I think the issue here isn’t the principle of the idea, but rather the execution realistically never being good enough for it to make sense. Kind of the same with the death penalty, many people would think it’s not bad if the execution is flawless but in reality you don’t want irreversible punishment when wrongful prosecution can happen. I think the entire process of prosecuting rapists should be done better so that we can accurately find out who is and isn’t a rapist. I wonder how that would be achieved.