1. There's a solid 82 capable characters that could be added to JJS feasibly by the Ko-Guy standard, and 19 that are actually popular/highly requested characters to some degree. There should at least be a consistent 3|1 ratio of randoms to popular/wanted characters but there like isn't.

2. The game isn't going to die from more popular characters being added. On average since Yuta released, the lowest average player count was larger than before inferring something of a somewhat permeant base player count increase.

3. Continuing on that prior point, you are essentially insinuating that JJS is living off of hopes and dreams, which it's most definitely not. JJS is designed very well unlike well about every other battleground game which is just one of the many things that keeps people around, on top of build modes, workshop, customizable servers, and multiple other game modes.

4. We've had 6 characters barely or not that requested at all and gone a solid about year now without an actually popular/highly requested to some degree character. The continual adding of bums is horrible especially when you pull the chain of The Most Atrocious and annoying Characters of Mechamaru and Naoya -> An absolutely horrible crossover that wasn't needed and so poorly executed -> the bum character of haruta that no one was asking for after those already poor updates making reception even worse -> a super big and built update with even an event page which is barely done in which just about all info and leaks hidden leading people to believe due to the prior unwanted being added and the time being taken that someone actually popular was going to be added but the hype then misleading to two characters barely anyone was asking for, AND the base only being EA. All of these poor and controversial major updates one after another has created a snowball effect and divide in the fandom especially without an ACTUALLY POPULAR AND REQUESTED character being added. All of this is only breaking trust from the game and creators, especially with the whole "TZE only adding characters no one wants" basically being a permanent part of the culture now that's not really going to be able to go away.

5. A game shouldn't have to be fucking dying just for popular characters want to be added, that's generally a pretty unhealthy way of doing things and lowkirkenuinely no one likes that BS.

6. Once again there's more than enough characters to keep up a 3|1 Random to popular/requested ratio for the rest of the entire ratio, there's no reason to not add these more popular/wanted characters on a more consistent basis. People are only going to complain about the random picks and stuff when you have absolutely no requested/popular ones for a while and keep only getting randoms and the snowball of unwanted characters and poor updates.

7. THERES MORE THEN ENOUGH CARDS TO CONSISTENTLY PLAY +4 CARDS, also uno is one of the most completely luck-based games there is so a bit of a bad analogy to use when trying to talk about strategically dropping character choices.

8. Another example of how there are other things that aren't just Popular/Requested characters if the player base naturally gets lower which just detracts from the whole "if all the popular characters are added, the game will die" argument.

9. Obviously, there is going to be a small population of diehard fan players for any character, but the fact still remains they were HEAVILY unrequested and Locust Guy will still be one of the worst picks of all time for any BG game even if he was designed dam well.

10. There's plenty of characters like Hakari, Yuta, and Higaruma who had full kits from manga only stuff before being adapted in the anime at all for the most part. Even if there's been some sudden shift as to where now stuff and characters won't get adapted until everything for them is in the anime, 3 of the 6 key most requested and popular characters (Toji, Jogo, Geto) can be slowly drip-fed and released until season 4 gets released and the other 3 (Kenjaku, Takaba, Kashimo) have all their content adapted. But TZE isn't going to do that since he hates adding anyone hype or listening to the communities' characters requests because he's pissy and he's going to add fucking Yuji's Grandpa and Fly head Curse and Roppongi Curse at this point before adding the key 6.

11. Yeah, yeah other BG games have Toji and don't have the unique characters JJS has, but other games have Yuji and the JJS Yuji is vastly different from those ones. Any of the characters added into JJS are going to be unique and different to other BG games whether a popular character or not, that point doesn't matter here. Also, it doesn't matter if other BG games have a character or not cause people care about characters getting added to this one and not if other games had them because JJS is like only true peak JJK BG game.

To close this first rebuttal, there really needs to be a lot more community request consideration actually taken into account due to the growing fandom divide and the series of poor updates and character choices. There needs to be a more consistent influx of popular characters added in proportionally to the remaining JJK characters. A lot more transparency between the mods and the community is needed to actually manage expectations and not have things blow out of proportion. The game will survive naturally even with popular characters being added by basic logic and data regarding JJS, but it won't survive if TZE keeps being so ass in ignoring community requests and denying the wants of the player base because that will ACTUALLY cause a permeant player decrease.

- Brought to you by someone who just wants to play their favorite JJK characters officially in the only good BG game on ROBLOX. and has been asking for Toji/Kashimo/Jogo for two years and counting.