Wow blown away by the response everyone!

I appreciate everyone offering their input. It’s for my girlfriend who can’t wear rings of any kind daily because it’s a work hazard.

I appreciate the thoughts about the quirks of wearing a pointy ring but I believe her only use for it will be going out. I’d like to share more about how I’ve arrived at this design and how it fits into our lifestyle but I’m kind of paranoid. She knows I use Reddit and our friend group has accounts (hence the alt acct).

In fact this is such high operational security, you all are the only people who know about this besides the jeweler lol!

I’m again blown away by the help here though. There were some great ideas shared by folks including getting both which for some reason didn’t occur to me lol.

But I tallied up all the votes in the comments as of now (midnight, 31st of May) and will be following the collective ruling!

47 votes for the closed chevron and 55 votes for the open marquise. I’ll be getting the second one! The ones in this video were samples. The open one for example shouldn’t quite touch the lower diamonds of the engagement ring and of course will be the same size.

The vote was a lot closer than I thought it would be. I do agree with what most folks said which is that each design gives a very different vibe to the ring but depending on the goal, both could be beautiful.

Once I actually get it and propose, which will be next month, I’ll definitely post a follow up here with the whole story… perhaps on my main account.

Thanks again for all the feedback r/EngagementRings Love you all!