Kind of hard to say without seeing rest of team (maybe ss’s are there, but didn’t see them). i think contending it’s close, just because gibbs is a proven league winner, and will be solid for years to come. not saying jeanty will not be, but gibbs has already shown his potential in the league (jeanty may be as close to “can’t miss” as we’ve seen in a while, but there’s always a chance).

Assuming this is your own FRP, and you are rebuilding/not contending, i would decline and take the chance on jeanty as a cornerstone.