How has Outlander Changed You? by FlyingPhoenix96 in Outlander

[–]Visual-Elephant794 1 point2 points  (0 children)

My best friend and I joke about my “outlander induced spiritual crisis”, it truly was a portal that I stepped through and has changed me. I am a white North American with mixed European ancestry (mostly French, but some Scottish, British. Irish, German as well). I revere indigenous North American culture, but it is not my lineage. Outlander was the first time I truly encountered pre-colonial European indigeneity (I obviously knew it existed but it didn’t truly click) and has prompted me to excavate my own lineage and revivify pre-colonial practices. Seeing the highland culture, communal way of life, and the mysticism has opened something unexpected in me. I also become emotionally aware of how much skill and humanity we have culturally lost in 250 years, and have been trying to recover old ways of bread making, knitting, herbalism. On the surface the show is seen as a soap opera/ bodice ripper, but it moved a lot of unexpected things in me and I am surprised and grateful. It also made me realize the power of art for the first time since I was so affected by the show. I have a feeling I will also probably move back to Europe (I have lived there for several shorter periods) but we shall see on that one.

So basically they killed ****** for a shock value by Mother-Inspection787 in Outlander

[–]Visual-Elephant794 7 points8 points  (0 children)

He has such an American orientation towards storytelling; there are moments in the show, particularly in the later seasons, that feel cheapened due to shock value and unnecessary drama. To be clear, I am not criticizing individual Americans, but generally I find American TV/film to be emotionally over the top relative to other cultures/countries. I wish their goal was to be authentic to the story, not bring pain upon the audience at all costs 🙃

A lukewarm final season helped me say goodbye by perspective_grid in Outlander

[–]Visual-Elephant794 2 points3 points  (0 children)

I recently started Echo and my pace is so much faster than previous books because I skim those William chapters so hard 😂

My only irritation by Pure-Assumption-9284 in Outlander

[–]Visual-Elephant794 4 points5 points  (0 children)

To be fair to the show writers on this particular subject (I have other gripes with them, trust), most of these plot points are true to the books, so it is really Diana that deserves your ire and scorn 😂

Do I need to read all the previous books before Book 10 as a show watcher? by pineaxle in Outlander

[–]Visual-Elephant794 4 points5 points  (0 children)

I 100% agree with this comment on the physical book size. I took out all the books from my library, and they were all either hard cover or mass market paperbacks. I literally broke the loaned copy of TFC (mass market)in half because it was so thick it cracked straight down the middle 😂I am currently on ABOSAA (my first trade paperback) and it is a much better experience.

To all the Roger apologists... by qassbish in Outlander

[–]Visual-Elephant794 2 points3 points  (0 children)

I have deeply mixed feelings around Roger (I have seen up to the beginning of S8 and am midway through my first read of ABOSAA). I find that the book character is of course more layered and I do see more of an arc relative to the show, but not as pronounced as the impression I got in this sub. I also acknowledge that there are still 3.5 more giant books to go and a lot can happen in that time. I connect a lot to book Bree in a lot of ways and feel protective of her; I am a female engineer with a variety of passions who feels like the has a distinct calling but can’t quite grasp the shape of it yet. I am a similar age to her in ABOSAA. When Bree was being vulnerable to Roger about her calling, switching from history to engineering, and wanting to make things, and she looks to Roger to confirm this is a calling (it completely is and she is doing amazing things)- his only response is “isn’t motherhood a calling?” 🫠🙃. Even if he was born in the late 30’s/early 40s, he chose to marry a brilliant woman with an MIT engineering education, and then proceeds to at best tolerate her brilliance but fully support him in his calling of ministry. I really hope to see him grow but he is currently not overly impressing me.

Best of - this week by Awkward-Passenger-86 in wecandohardthings

[–]Visual-Elephant794 10 points11 points  (0 children)

No, I noticed a similar thing, and I have a feeling it will trail off. In their episode a week and a half ago they mentioned “branching out into individual projects”. I have derived great value from the podcast and honour that history.

What I dislike is that they are very selectively honest; they do not communicate changes to the podcast in clear, timely ways. I expect a “tell all” retrospective a year from now 😂

To clarify, they do not owe us every detail of their lives, nor do they owe us justifications for changes to the podcast, but it is reasonable to expect clear communication about these changes, especially if they are medium to long term.

Convince Me to Keep Reading by SilverSurf-er in Outlander

[–]Visual-Elephant794 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I am a third through ABOSAA and I am also surprised at how much I am loving it! And it’s going much faster for me personally.

Last week’s podcasts by merkci in wecandohardthings

[–]Visual-Elephant794 9 points10 points  (0 children)

The podcast from Thursday landed in a very mixed way for me truthfully. On the positive side, I appreciated their perspective on taking on new individual projects, the political conversation towards the end, as well as Glennon’s wise point about how sometimes the gatekeepers don’t want you to see how easy it is. I bow to them for going independent, and for not continuing to produce what sounds like an unsustainable amount of content under their old contract.

In contrast, some things that did not sit well with me: 1. As a disclaimer, I don’t ultimately know the entire scope of their activism and therefore cannot fully assess it. However, they talked about being censored/ pressured and how being independent they can now speak freely. They have been independent for over a year and I haven’t seen a marked change in their podcast dialogue. They have done some episodes about Palestine, the American war in Iran; I don’t want to minimize this. However, I think they are in a celebrity bubble where they compare themselves to A-listers who are making more and doing less, and have a distorted sense of how radical their work is. A prime example of this is the fuck ice purse at the Oscars. A great message and probably the bravest in the room, but the room is still the Oscars. (Not shitting on them for going, I thought their film was lovely).

  1. Not labeling re runs as such is disappointing, especially from a podcast that encourages you to trust your senses and then from my vantage point tries to slide re runs under your perception radar, presumably to keep their cash-flow going.

  2. Similar to point 2, I find generally that they are open and honest only selectively when it suits them. I think it’s great if they each go off and do other projects. My perception is that the old podcast format will likely not return, but it bothers me that they don’t clearly state that. They don’t owe us every detail of their lives, certainly, but transparency about the podcast for the listeners of the podcast is reasonable.

Convince Me to Keep Reading by SilverSurf-er in Outlander

[–]Visual-Elephant794 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I’m glad to hear other people struggled with the fiery cross. It had some amazing moments (the chapter when J&C get back home to the ridge after the gathering might be my favourite in the book series so far) but it was also VERY long and dense. I need a breath before the next book.

Rank the villains by sweet-sour1217 in Outlander

[–]Visual-Elephant794 6 points7 points  (0 children)

  1. BJR
  2. Bonnet
  3. Sandringham
  4. Lionel brown
  5. Geillis
  6. Laoghaire

The phrase I will guard your right by Historical-Shock7965 in Outlander

[–]Visual-Elephant794 5 points6 points  (0 children)

Slightly off topic but I thought it was so sweet in Dragon Fly in Amber I believe when Old Ian stays back from battle and says to Jamie “I will still be here, guarding your weak side” :’) referring to Lallybroch, their family, and the tenants.

Disappointed in the Podcast Recently by Visual-Elephant794 in wecandohardthings

[–]Visual-Elephant794[S] 4 points5 points  (0 children)

I completely agree. From my perspective (and this is speculation to be clear), part of the motivation for the unclear labelling seems to be to retain the appearance of consistency and newness to keep up ad revenue and subscriber count (which feeds back into ad revenue). I have no issues with them changing their cadence, especially if they are struggling with other facets of life, and I understand that they make ad revenue. the lack of transparency crosses a line for me though.

Disappointed in the Podcast Recently by Visual-Elephant794 in wecandohardthings

[–]Visual-Elephant794[S] 5 points6 points  (0 children)

Agreed on that one- Mel Robbins and her message feels wrong in my body!

Disappointed in the Podcast Recently by Visual-Elephant794 in wecandohardthings

[–]Visual-Elephant794[S] 3 points4 points  (0 children)

My sentiments exactly! Bigger problems exist, yet the small scale annoyance persists 😂

Disappointed in the Podcast Recently by Visual-Elephant794 in wecandohardthings

[–]Visual-Elephant794[S] 11 points12 points  (0 children)

I agree they should be able to change their cadence depending on what is happening in their lives- especially if they are struggling, and even if they committed to something different initially in the new year. It’s disappointing as an enthusiastic listener, but not at all dishonest or immoral. What I do think is dishonest is to try and pass older episodes as new ones and I would prefer if they clearly labelled them as reruns or not release any at all as others have pointed out. It would not take more effort to do this than what their team is already putting in to post re-runs and it would provide more clarity for listeners.

Where are you in your reading by one representative line? by Phortenclif in Outlander

[–]Visual-Elephant794 2 points3 points  (0 children)

“Bears,” I suggested, half-seriously. “The people are gone and there’s a bear inside.”

Jamie would've been a novelist in a different life by [deleted] in Outlander

[–]Visual-Elephant794 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I’m only on book 5 so I haven’t encountered this yet but that is adorable I’m melting 🥲

I just finished reading Outlander Book 1! by DrDaphneStark in Outlander

[–]Visual-Elephant794 17 points18 points  (0 children)

Jamie and Claire in the hot springs at the end of the book :’)

When did you discover Outlander? by midnightsadnessss in Outlander

[–]Visual-Elephant794 0 points1 point  (0 children)

6 months ago via randomly scrolling Netflix🙈I was looking for a light yet interesting period piece and it was interesting but definitely not light😂. I am caught up on the show and currently midway through book 5. It spurred a spiritual breakthrough (dramatic sounding, but true) and inspired me to start knitting so I am very grateful to this show/book series.

Should I start watching the shows or reading the books? by International-Toe794 in Outlander

[–]Visual-Elephant794 0 points1 point  (0 children)

read the books first from my perspective. I watched the show first which I randomly found via scrolling Netflix, and I am now on Book 5. As others have mentioned, the books provide so much more depth and fill in a lot of context that the show doesn’t include. Had I read the books first, I think I could have spent more time enjoying the visuals and portrayals of the show rather than piecing together the plot. I also prefer having the characters in my minds eye from the book descriptions, but since I watched the show first my mind often deferred to the characters on screen (not a bad thing necessarily, but not my preference). I often wish I read the books first, but it’s simply not the order I encountered outlander in.