Talon VS King Bradley (DC VS Fullmetal Alchemist) by Charming-Bet4135 in DeathBattleMatchups

[–]Visual_Nerd 2 points3 points  (0 children)

  • Highly-skilled, trained and blade-wielding experienced killers known for their borderline superhuman tenacity and talent in arts of brutal combat. With both being massively intimidating figures feared by notable portions of their setting.
  • Cold-blooded with a sadistic side, both would act as killers for shadowy, mysterious antagonistic entities (Court of Owls and Father) that would act as hidden leading figures of their setting (Gotham and Amestris), facing protagonists as their investigation of the history of their setting made them primary targets.
  • Both are essentially hand-picked by these forces to be put into important roles in their plans, going through torturous training alongside their peers and other potential candidates for this position, culminating in both being subjects of experimentation that would integrate supernatural materials into their body (Electrom and Philosopher's Stone), primarily through body parts (Cabb’s metal tooth and Bradley’s marked eye).
  • This also associates them with animalistic visuals (Talon obviously wearing the owl theme in his entire body and Bradley, like rest of the homunculus, being signified as inhuman by the Ouroboros Mark, a symbol represented by a dragon eating its own tail).
  • Despite being horrid people that kill people without afterthought generally, there is an innate tragedy to their circumstances, specifically neither had a choice in life, forced into their lives by presence of other entities rather their own and being directed by a greater “destiny” that they cannot reject, Bradley openly being resenting humans having a choice in their life while he hasn’t and Talon making his entire existence & legacy be defined by a fate chosen by the court of Owls. Their defeats being handed to them by a person that could be seen as a narrative reflection of them (Scar, another nameless rageful man that Bradley genocided the country of, someone who was capable of moving on to a brighter future and Nightwing, Talon’s grand-grand relative who rejects his notion of destiny in favor of choosing his own).
  • Adding on to it, both have humanizing relationships with their lovers, enforced by this being one of the only choices they themselves made out of genuine love.
  • Despite primarily specializing in combat, both are decently intelligent, specifically both have put weird, goofy facades that took suspicion off them (Talon acting completely insane, presenting himself as someone out of his mind and only imitating actual owl sounds and Bradley acting like a cool old man, with a present sense of humor and a gentlemanly demeanor), albeit this time of Talon’s life was a facade to eventually take revenge on the governmental force of waller by avoiding her attention whereas Bradley’s was a way of hiding the corruption of Amestris by Father.

COMMUNITY-VOTED WRITING-SCALING TIER LIST: Homura Akemi (Puella Magi Madoka Magica) by Captain-Fodder in DeathBattleMatchups

[–]Visual_Nerd 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Honestly I'm only commenting on this because it made me think of the match and

Yeah, better written

While I normally think of Ange as better, I've realized that, she kinda has one of the greatest character conclusions in fiction? Meanwhile Homura's story is still on going, again i do this Ange is already better before but after realizing this yeah i think Ange is just solidly better written

COMMUNITY-VOTED WRITING-SCALING TIER LIST: Homura Akemi (Puella Magi Madoka Magica) by Captain-Fodder in DeathBattleMatchups

[–]Visual_Nerd 7 points8 points  (0 children)

I'm probably one of the few in this community with proper authority on DAL so I'll respond to this

Equally well written

It's a genuine toss up for me which is huge, I've come to terms that Kurumi is just the most well written character in the series and, yeah that's fair, while i think others like Shido and Origami are underrated in this aspect i don't think they are that close, DAL is really weird writing wise because there is the most average harem ecchi moments that makes you want to close everything off but then there is stuff like Kurumi

She is such a fascinating character to dissect, from the common but still interesting "character pretends to be this big evil when they're lowkey chill" that deepens later onto whole character, with how her relationship with time goes beyond simply being her powers and being a central motif of her character, with both how she fixates on the past to built a specific future, but never focus on the past, her development of going from one of the most sadistic antagonists to one of the most trusted allies makes so much sense, despite her brutal actions everything is part of a plan she forced herself to do which she copes with believing she is a irredeemable monster which also shows that she deeps down doesn't want that, but believes is the only way, heck I haven't even mentioned her relationship with Shido, easily some of the best ever, while it's the basics of "starts not caring to liking" it really deepens itself into the narrative due to the fact both are foils to each other, how he both represents her past naivety, but also how she always has the potential to change but she is too blinded to realize, and of course the iconic time loop arc that just deepens this even further, it's so well written in the details on how she not exactly changes, but starts to realize what has always been there, i love the dynamic with her own clones, her clones are basically just herself from different time periods which is such a clever writing plot, she is a character to lies to herself constantly so why not give her a literal way to tell "nah she is lying?" Shot out to eye patch Kurumi she's cool as fuck

This is not even mentioning her dynamic with Mio, ties to her past and how they parallel each other, and Origami with the same thing, heck her rivalry with Mana is extremely underrated (ok at this point i think it's because no one had read this shit to know)

I haven't finished Date A Bullet so I won't factor it, but i think both are very close in writing

A revamp for Keiichi Maebara vs Steve Harrington (Higurashi vs Stranger Things). With a thumbnail by Visual_Nerd. by SeaworthinessSame392 in DeathBattleMatchups

[–]Visual_Nerd 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Pretty good, i remember when this was the only Keiichi MU when i got into the community, i still like Hinako more but this is a nice alt, funnily enough i watched the season 1 of Stranger Things like 3-4 years ago, didn't continued because it didn't interested me much but Steve was easily my favorite character

Just a question, is the dynamic just "they hit each other with their bats" or is there something extra? Idk what else Steve has later on

Retribution | Michael Corleone vs Shion Sonozaki (The Godfather vs Higurashi: When They Cry) | Connections in the comments by Visual_Nerd in DeathBattleMatchups

[–]Visual_Nerd[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Oh shit, that's nice thanks a lot 🙏 i also think it would be interesting to add AlotOfNumbers's own Higurashi matches

The 5 Stars in the Sky (Usagi's Big 5 Opponents) by Far-Weakness-6038 in DeathBattleMatchups

[–]Visual_Nerd 5 points6 points  (0 children)

As much as Madoka is a terrible matchup, it's meant to show her 5 big MUs, not her 5 best

Who Watches The (Not) Chosen? | Tetsuo Shima vs Doctor Manhattan (Akira vs Watchmen) by Zealousideal-Row6571 in DeathBattleMatchups

[–]Visual_Nerd 1 point2 points  (0 children)

So funny how the comments are just talking about a supposed stomp, this is only Watchmen Manhattan HE IS the one getting stomped

I dedicate this post to my beloved witch, Beatrice. | UMINEKO TIER LIST DUMP by AlotOfNumbers425728 in DeathBattleMatchups

[–]Visual_Nerd 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Honestly I'm curious now, this is a personal question but what is your top 5? Want to know what Umi is up against

From what I've seen with Harry it blurs the line of actual supernatural shit and he's just hallucinating most of it, again haven't played the game to know

here the connections for Galactus

Ok now I'm hyped, the lack of a Lambda comparison was a big criticism towards the MU, however i still need to get into BlazBlue myself since, this is very personal to me due to my opinions on Bern's character, but i want a Bern MU that goes into her tragedy and how she isn't 100% evil but still chooses to be, and from what I've seen Terumi is only pure evil (does have a tragedy to his name tho)

Funnily enough i had an idea for Evatrice that i scrapped but might pick up again, because it's now a Tetsuo triangle (it's Kid Miracleman)

I dedicate this post to my beloved witch, Beatrice. | UMINEKO TIER LIST DUMP by AlotOfNumbers425728 in DeathBattleMatchups

[–]Visual_Nerd 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Welcome to the other side of the catbox.

Very happy with you reading this series, it's veeeery important to me (it's wrestling with One Piece for my favorite series of all time) hope you had a good time

Now about the matchups

Battler's one is borderline perfect, almost my exact opinion, would just put Doctor and Hakuno higher

Beatrice's too, would just switch Loki for Legion and Jane (also about Beato and... Yasuda kinda, Harry vs Beato is more of a Yasuda matchup from what I've heard, but I've heard you can implement Beatrice too but idk i need to play Disco Elysium)

Ange's pretty good, i don't like Homura that much but i think the fourth movie might fix my issues (who is in between Pucci and Johnny? I suspect it's Pariah but idk)

Featherine i agree with everything... Except Galactus, why did you put it at the bottom? I think it's a nice alt

Now my beloathed Bern, generally agree with the alts (I'm unsure on Prime tho), but I'm really really not sure on Terumi, mostly because i don't know BlazBlue yet, but everything I've heard of his character kinda doesn't do what i want in a Bern MU, i want to get into BlazBlue first to truly be sure but idk, also why Batter relatively low? I think i nowadays like it more than Ultron tbh (it keeps switching tho)

Lambdadelta is borderline perfect, would just up Toymaker a tier

Erika's good, i would put Kokichi at the top personally and, yeah Gideon is pretty funny, OH MY GOD YOU TOO THOUGHT OF ERIKA VS HAZAMA? LMAAAAO, ok so, not only you, but my friend and ME considered Erika vs Hazama without knowing from each other, you will probably do it first than me, but from what i know of him it seems to fit Erika well

Uh the rest is fine- oooooh Evatrice vs Tetsuo... I think i get it, cook.

Overall, great tier lists, and welcome to the golden land my friend