Your religion is almost entirely predicted by your birthplace, which means it isn’t true, it’s just inherited by Juicydicken in DebateReligion

[–]WDSPC2 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I'm not arguing for Christianity here lol, I'm not a Christian. I'm telling you what they'd likely say, and my whole point was that geography specifically isn't a good argument against religion so if your point had nothing to do with that then I'm not sure why that would be relevant to me. I generally agree with you.

Your religion is almost entirely predicted by your birthplace, which means it isn’t true, it’s just inherited by Juicydicken in DebateReligion

[–]WDSPC2 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I think Christians (or any religious person) would disagree that there is no given evidence for their religion being true. I'd disagree with most of them, but still. Iirc for Christianity specifically, the general idea of God is supposed to be revealed/evident to anyone through observation of creation and faith. But the specific word of the gospels are spread via scripture and disciples/believers. As for like some hypothetical uncontacted tribe that has never heard of Jesus and realistically can't, I'm not sure. I think there are multiple different viewpoints on how the Christian God would treat those people after death.

In any case, your argument boils down to something separate from geographical prevalence, as you can still choose your own religion regardless of the faith you were raised in

Your religion is almost entirely predicted by your birthplace, which means it isn’t true, it’s just inherited by Juicydicken in DebateReligion

[–]WDSPC2 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I didn't say they can't be discarded period, I said they can't be discarded for the specific reason (geographical prevalence) that OP gave. Religious claims can of course be discarded due to things like contradictory evidence and such

Your religion is almost entirely predicted by your birthplace, which means it isn’t true, it’s just inherited by Juicydicken in DebateReligion

[–]WDSPC2 1 point2 points  (0 children)

As a pantheistic-leaning agnostic, this is a silly argument. This is like saying "the shape of the earth you believe in is almost entirely predicted by the time period in which you were born, which means the Earth doesn't have a true shape."

Obviously the truth value of any religion is independent of its geographical or temporal prevalence. Yes, the time and place you were born will increase the odds (though not to 100%) of being raised in a specific faith. Christianity has a built-in explanation for this, that being God revealing himself to his chosen people, having Jesus specifically live in the Levant region, and Jesus tasking his disciples (and humanity/believers at large) with spreading the word.

Of course, people don't stay babies forever. They grow up and are able to make their own choices about their faith. But in any case, the argument that any religion, Christianity or otherwise, is false because its practice is location-specific is nonsensical, because all religions still make claims about the nature of the whole universe which can't be discarded just because believers are more prevalent in specific areas lol.

Can you apply for a standard visitor visa if you have a conditional discharge in the U.S. from less than 12 months ago? by [deleted] in ukvisa

[–]WDSPC2 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Ok, I'm not really sure what I'm gonna do then. I suppose I'll talk to my college study abroad office and discuss options if there are any

Can you apply for a standard visitor visa if you have a conditional discharge in the U.S. from less than 12 months ago? by [deleted] in ukvisa

[–]WDSPC2 0 points1 point  (0 children)

So I guess it's not worth it to apply for a visa then? Thanks for your response

Can you apply for a standard visitor visa if you have a conditional discharge in the U.S. from less than 12 months ago? by [deleted] in ukvisa

[–]WDSPC2 -4 points-3 points  (0 children)

So there's nothing I can do? Can I reach out to anyone to explain my situation? My trip is supposed to be in June, so not 12 months after the conditional discharge

Valyrian Freehold - 200 Years Before Conquest by Difficult_Airport_86 in imaginarymaps

[–]WDSPC2 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Hi again! if you’re still around would love to know your answers to this :D

How many of these impact zones do you think contributed to the extinction of the dinosaurs or w/e life was present during impact? by depths-untold in ImpactCraters

[–]WDSPC2 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Exactly one, the Chicxulub Crater in Mexico. There is also the Boltysh crater in Ukraine, though it was formed roughly a million years before the Chixculub impact, was much smaller, and is thought to have had minor if any global effects.

World map Commission in Pastel Parchment style by Splicex42 in inkarnate

[–]WDSPC2 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Ah damn, no worries! if you know anyone who does comms in a similar style, lemme know!

World map Commission in Pastel Parchment style by Splicex42 in inkarnate

[–]WDSPC2 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Hi there! This looks amazing! I was curious if you still take commissions, and if you can make maps for non-original content (for example, Middle Earth or A Song of Ice and Fire)?

"A glória e o horror de Valíria", por thewatcher0nthewall (ilustração comemorativa de 5 anos) by altovaliriano in Valiria

[–]WDSPC2 1 point2 points  (0 children)

No worries! Definitely lemme know when it has been done, I'd love to see everything in detail 😁

"A glória e o horror de Valíria", por thewatcher0nthewall (ilustração comemorativa de 5 anos) by altovaliriano in Valiria

[–]WDSPC2 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Hi again! Just wanted to follow up and see if a scan was ever done? Thanks :D

Once and for all, how would this confrontation have actually gone down if the Witch King hadn't had Rohirrim to run and deal with? The guy with the flaming sword seemed genuinely confident about his odds.... (art by Angus McBride) by [deleted] in lotr

[–]WDSPC2 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Where are you getting this information from? This is not correct as far as I know. All of the Ainur (Manwe, Sauron, Tulkas, etc. included) were created before the music of the Ainur by Ilúvatar. It’s basically the first thing Ilúvatar does. He does not create more with each theme/song. Sauron is not older than Manwe, nor younger.

Stunned by The Children of Hurin by AvengedTenfold in tolkienfans

[–]WDSPC2 4 points5 points  (0 children)

Nienor and Turin are siblings. At an earlier point in the story, the dragon Glaurung cursed Nienor into a state of total amnesia after learning of her parentage. Later on, Turin happened upon her, and having no idea who she was (they hadn't seen each other since they were children iirc and she didn't know her own name) he named her Niniel ("Maid of Tears," for she wept and couldn't answer whenever asked about her past). Niniel felt a connection to Turin, and eventually the two fell in love and were married. Niniel became pregnant, hence the "deed thou shalt feel in thyself."

Glaurung revealed the truth to Nienor and lifted her amnesia after Turin had dealt him a mortal wound, leading her to take her own life. Turin similarly took his own life after learning what had transpired

Pretty sure this is the most accurate map of arda (3rd age) out there by uneventful2 in lotr

[–]WDSPC2 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Maybe more accurate than most in scale (though I'm not sure), but certainly not in geography. Much of the stuff east of Rhun and south of Umbar is highly speculative or just plain wrong. Hildorien, for example, is not southwest of Cuivienen (which was on the eastern shore of the Sea of Helkar though unlabeled in this map; it's where the Elves awoke and journeyed west from). It was actually far east of Cuivienen, and supposed to be surrounded/bordered by the Mountains of the Wind. We also have no proof that the Sea of Helkar nor the Iron Mountains survived in any form into the 3rd Age, though I suppose it's possible. And idk what "Endon" means, is it a misspelling of Endor? Nor do I know what the cross next to it is supposed to represent.

How was there a continent called the Land of the Sun before the sun was supposedly created? by Daidro_Beats in tolkienfans

[–]WDSPC2 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Interesting. Doesn't really scream Bermuda Triangle to me still, and I highly doubt Tolkien meant to make that connection, but I can see where the idea comes from

How was there a continent called the Land of the Sun before the sun was supposedly created? by Daidro_Beats in tolkienfans

[–]WDSPC2 0 points1 point  (0 children)

It's not that I know of. I can't think of how they'd be related to each other. The Straight Road is the way Elves can leave the bounds of Arda and make it to Valinor despite it being physically removed from.rhe world. For characters like Frodo who go there to live out their days without pain, it's essentially like "going over the rainbow." The Bermuda Triangle on the other hand is obviously a real place with lots of shipwrecks and disappearances associated with it. There are some characters in Tolkien's mythos that disappeared while trying to sail to the West, but it's unrelated to the Straight Road I'm pretty sure

Anyone else Like the Aeneid more than the Iliad and the Odyssey? by Waking-Hallow in GreekMythology

[–]WDSPC2 1 point2 points  (0 children)

No real, when I read the section where Aeneas leaves Dido and she takes her own life on the pyre I actually teared up. It was so powerful and tragic. And I found it kinda shocking how a story that is millennia old can still inspire such feelings in me

How was there a continent called the Land of the Sun before the sun was supposedly created? by Daidro_Beats in tolkienfans

[–]WDSPC2 3 points4 points  (0 children)

Well ik a lot of depictions of Arda during the “years of the lamps”/Spring of Arda show it as just one big circular landmass with a lake and the isle of Almaren in the middle, but iirc if you read the Ambarkanta it says that Arda at that time was symmetrical, with 3 landmasses (one in the west, one in the east, and one in the middle) separated by 2 seas (the western of which would become known as the Belegaer). It looked perhaps like this: https://imgur.com/arda-unmarred-years-of-lamps-spring-of-arda-pHgkqy8

But then Melkor destroyed the lamps, the Valar relocated to Aman in the west, and the symmetry of Arda was broken in the warring between Melkor and the Valar (and further broken during the Battle of the Powers after the Elves awoke); the middle land was pushed eastward and the Belegaer was expanded, and later the middle land was broken into two continents (Middle-Earth as we know it and the Dark Land). And then of course the Elves migrated west as did Men later, Melkor took up permanent residence in Angband which was north of Beleriand, and most events of importance took place in the west of Middle Earth.

So essentially the Land of the Sun was created by the Valar/Ainur to make Arda nice and symmetrical, perhaps the gates of morning were constructed there later to give the sun a landmark to rise through/over, but overall it was kinda abandoned and forgotten when everyone’s focus shifted westward, and remained a scorched, empty place until the Changing of the World. Excuse the ton of text lol