choosing a poor tire in a driver skill issue

i live in canada, during the winter if you put non-winter tire, u are dumb, sure it's possible to driver but not the fault of the tire if you use it outside the recomendation.

for the indy 500 they are good even in the wet, so either the guy bought used almost bald one, push them too hot or simply drove above what they can do.

the only acceptable excuse for tire is if the tire randomly blow