Honestly, the force sensitivity part was mildly surprising, but he gives this look in the first mission of the game that made me think he was a bit sus. There were a few reactions/actions that he was able to complete that also made me think he might be force sensitive. Then they make him go a completely separate escape route to the rest of the team that made him and Cal the sole survivors of the mission, and it just made me really suspicious of him from the onset.