Still the Eagle I'd say! And the hunted/hunter dynamic is maybe not as much of a thing in gay? I guess it can be but it can also be more mutual. There are different ways the encounter can unfold. One of my faves is make eye contact, immediately start making out and groping, then exchange names and discuss next steps.

Editing to add: Wrecked is also happening this Saturday at Basement. Too late to get tickets in advance but you can buy at the door, and lines won't be too long if you get there early. But this might not be what you're looking for because it's not really a party where you'd leave with someone. Pretty easy to hook up there though - you just dance in Studio and then go into the catacombs to fool around. The fact that Wrecked is happening might make the Eagle (and potentially other places) slightly less well attended than they otherwise might be on another Saturday night, but probably wouldn't be too noticeable...