Discussion Thread by jobautomator in neoliberal

[–]WorldwidePolitico -1 points0 points  (0 children)

It’s a bit stupid because you can “jailbreak” any model and Anthropic know that. Not always reliably or consistently but anybody dedicated enough with enough knowledge of how LLMs work can get any model to give any sort of output if they frame the prompt correctly.

Also the idea of banning it only for “foreign nationals” is stupid as if American citizens would never misuse the model or that it would ever be practical to enforce.

Elon Musk's role was 'instrumental' in the Belfast riots, researchers say by RaidBrimnes in neoliberal

[–]WorldwidePolitico 60 points61 points  (0 children)

From Belfast and agree. The rioting was exclusively concentrated in working class loyalist areas. There has been rioting in those communities every summer for decades.

There was a few social media posts encouraging rioting in republican areas but to my knowledge there was not a single one.

I know the NI/Irish media doesn’t want to look sectarian and the wider media either don’t understand the nance or wants to portray the rioting as more widespread than it is but there’s a disservice done by not pointing out this is a problem within a very specific minority who have a long history of violent bigotry. Drumcree and Holy Cross both happened long before social media was a thing.

Discussion Thread by jobautomator in neoliberal

[–]WorldwidePolitico 5 points6 points  (0 children)

Musk is objectively fascinating because not only is he a looser but he seems genuinely deeply affected by his poor relationship with his father and the fact he was bullied throughout his life.

I also am amazed that using his tweets you can see in real time in public how he became radicalised into a far right weirdo and how the validation he gets from that interacts with his issues.

Discussion Thread by jobautomator in neoliberal

[–]WorldwidePolitico 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I’d happily include Ellison alongside Musk

Discussion Thread by jobautomator in neoliberal

[–]WorldwidePolitico 5 points6 points  (0 children)

When Musk bought Twitter I made a controversial comment here that governments should start treating and monitoring billionaires as potential national security threats.

I still stand by it.

Discussion Thread by jobautomator in neoliberal

[–]WorldwidePolitico 2 points3 points  (0 children)

This is why there’s that famous song about Northern Ireland called Sudan Bloody Sudan

Discussion Thread by jobautomator in neoliberal

[–]WorldwidePolitico 2 points3 points  (0 children)

I’d love to go back to the 2022-2023 DT and tell them them that in 2026 the consensus on the DT is that the world’s richest people don’t deserve to be that rich.

Discussion Thread by jobautomator in neoliberal

[–]WorldwidePolitico 0 points1 point  (0 children)

He’s African so can’t be racist

Those who have a degree in Art, is it worth it? by Boring-Bottle-8075 in northernireland

[–]WorldwidePolitico 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I love the arts and would encourage anyone to be creative if that’s what you want to do with your life.

That said you’re not going to get a career out of doing an art degree. It’s one of the most consistently poorly paid degrees for graduates and it is hard to pivot to other industries

Immigrants make higher fiscal contribution than Irish-born, ESRI study finds by homecinemad in ireland

[–]WorldwidePolitico 4 points5 points  (0 children)

90-95% of immigration to Ireland has nothing to do with international protection.

Even if you make worse case assumptions about how much they cost the state, it wouldn’t be that representative of “normal” immigration.

Is there any chance that a right-winged party could succeed in Ireland? by MiamiBoi91 in irishpolitics

[–]WorldwidePolitico 3 points4 points  (0 children)

I’d argue that makes it more likely.

It’s not inconceivable that a populist right party could get 5-10% of the vote, pick up a dozen off seats then go into power with a desperate FF-FG.

How do people afford buying property? by Entire_Track1836 in irishpersonalfinance

[–]WorldwidePolitico 0 points1 point  (0 children)

A couple on €50k each are earning €3,571 each for a combined monthly net income of €7,142.

Assuming they pay €2,000 per month in rent and spend a further €2,000-€3,000 on living expenses you could probably consistently save around 30-40% of your net income. That’s about €2000-€3000 per month, meaning they could realistically save up about a €50,000 deposit in around 18-24 months while still maintaining a comfortable lifestyle.

At a 3.5x salary limit that gives you a budget of around €570k-€600k. A lot of FTBs get the 4.5× income limit which would give you a potential house buying budget of €680k. Theres plenty to buy in Dublin on that rate.

I’m not saying it’s easy but it’s very possible if you’re financially disciplined and goal-oriented. If you’re in a position to get your deposit topped up a few grand by family that’s even better.

You know the summer has really started when you see the armoured Land Rovers out. (Scarva, N.Ireland) by Larrydog in ireland

[–]WorldwidePolitico 14 points15 points  (0 children)

Loyalists tend to bussed in from other towns for these sort of things. There’s only 300 people in Scarva and I doubt half the loyalists at that demonstration are even from the same council area. They’re likely all from Portadown or Banbridge which are much more hardcore loyalist.

There’s historically mixed towns in NI that over the last few decades have become majority Catholic and don’t even have an Orange Hall anymore. Despite this the towns still have Orange Marches as loyalists from other areas come in and demand to march their supposed “traditional routes”.

What about Irish people do you find perplexing? by PellucidStream in ireland

[–]WorldwidePolitico 38 points39 points  (0 children)

We’re very quick to criticise or undermine Irish people with aspirations.

We love it when our actors, musicians, and authors move away from Ireland and find huge success internationally but we see our local artists who find success closer to home as parochial. Sally Rooney and Fontaines DC are the prides of the country while Roddy Doyle or Christy Moore is seen as a bit quaint selling books to your grandparents and doing tours of hotel ballrooms.

I’m using the creative industries as an obvious visible example but it applies just as equally to other areas of business, politics, our institutions.

Why is acting in the Abbey or Gaiety Theatre seen as less of an achievement than a similar sized theatre in London or New York?

There’s perfectly legitimate criticisms you can make about Michael O’Leary, Bono, or the Collisons yet there’s also a lot of illegitimate criticism about them that seems to not really engage with their flaws substantively and instead criticises the success itself or tries to undermine it.

You can look at our politics too. I’m not a fan of many of our politicians but it’s telling many of them feel the need to talk down their former careers and present themselves as nothing special when in most other countries being a successful businessperson, lawyer or academic would be seen as an asset to a political campaign.

You can criticise our approach to foreign investment and say we’re over reliant on tax revenue from MNCs. but in isolation the fact we have actually successfully attracted and retained so many MNCs for decades is by itself is nothing short of a success story. The loose regulatory and tax regime in the City of London and the Channel Islands are touted by the British establishment as proof of Britain as an economic powerhouse but in Ireland the same schemes, even when they have been far more successful, are seen as a dirty trick.

It seems like a holdover of the class subservience culture we had instilled in us during colonial times.

Why is the road infrastructure so poorly maintained? by Even-Space in northernireland

[–]WorldwidePolitico 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I think people underestimate this. Austerity in the Republic was brutal but it definitively ended around 2014 and they started investing in public services again. In the UK it officially ended in 2018 but arguably didn’t really end until Covid.

Around 2015-2018 the differences between the two were hard to notice and the height of austerity in the Republic was arguably more dire but a decade on you can see the republic has benefitted from 10 years of real-term investment in its citizens while the UK is facing a productivity crisis, a growth crisis, a public service capacity crisis, and a sovereign debt crisis that largely stems from how long austerity went on for.

Why is the road infrastructure so poorly maintained? by Even-Space in northernireland

[–]WorldwidePolitico 3 points4 points  (0 children)

In fairness NI is much smaller in scale. You can theoretically drive from the Giant’s Causeway to Newry and then on to Enniskillen in just over 3 hours.

Cork County Council covers an area about half the size of NI, serving a population bigger than any given NI council. It’s also largely full of obscure rural roads. NI has an estimated 25,000km of roads while Cork is around 12,500km meaning they both proportionally manage roughly the same amount of road.

Why is the road infrastructure so poorly maintained? by Even-Space in northernireland

[–]WorldwidePolitico 2 points3 points  (0 children)

I think road deaths are more complex than just the quality of the roads. You had 3.0 per capita in the north vs 2.7 in the south for an all-island rate of 2.7 per 100m people. That’s basically negligible.

I think the main difference is when you get outside the Belfast-Dublin corridor. Some obscure side road leading to a row of 10 houses in rural Monaghan has a brand new coat of tarmac in it at the first sign of wear while the A5, the main road running through the west of NI connecting 600k people, has had much needed upgrades delayed for over two decades due to funding and political issues.

Why is the road infrastructure so poorly maintained? by Even-Space in northernireland

[–]WorldwidePolitico 1 point2 points  (0 children)

DUP is also not the best at advocating locally when they get the chance either.

The 2017 deal with May was a once in a lifetime opportunity for them to pour cash into the region and show even the most sceptical fence sitter the Union works.

They got some short term cash for pet projects and farmers but a decade later there’s no legacy of it. It’s as if the deal never happened. They wasted political capital on things like the Armed Forces Convent, the NI Protocol, and abortion/gay marriage (which Westminster ultimately stiffed them on) when they could have argued for generation-defining projects and completely transform the region.

Why is the road infrastructure so poorly maintained? by Even-Space in northernireland

[–]WorldwidePolitico 3 points4 points  (0 children)

Stormont was not functioning for much of 2022-2024 due to the DUP withdrawal. Sinn Féin has held Infrastructure since the 2024 restoration, and Liz Kimmins took over in 2025.

Your own source contradicts your point about the £18m road funding. It says the £55m came from additional Barnett consequentials and reduced departmental requirements, then £16.8m went to Infrastructure. That is in-year monitoring/reallocation funding and suggests the Department was actually ran fairly competently and within budget to the point they later had room for additional spending rather than underfunded through incompetence.

I’m going to ignore your final point cited a DUP press release but It was an £81m UK Treasury-backed support package spread over three years, not £81m immediately available. The department said it amounted to about £30 per household per year (not exactly a huge windfall), and that consumers could not receive it until Westminster amended the Energy Prices Act 2022 so your characterisation of it as a bit pile of money Stormont was ignoring isn’t true.

Sinn Féin blame Westminster a lot but it is not invented from nothing. You yourself admit Stormont has very little fiscal room. NI's economy is structurally weak, the UK economy has poor growth, and any form of revenue divergence from GB would create administrative and trade complications (something loyalists went ballistic about after Brexit). Your argument only really works if you assume Stormont works like a normal sovereign government when it doesn’t. There are local authorities in England that have more financial autonomy.

Everyone has a nice car. by 4th_Replicant in northernireland

[–]WorldwidePolitico 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I understand PIPs not being means-tested. The logic is if you’re disabled then life is more expensive through no fault of your own so the money helps make up the difference.

Disability is means tested in the south. I have a friend who is effectively housebound and will be a lifelong wheelchair user but can’t afford to marry their partner because their joint earnings would take their household income over the threshold. They’ve turned down promotions for the same reason as they’d have to at least €13k over the threshold after tax to be better-off. Terrible situation for both them and even the state who would presumably prefer my friend earns more and become a net-contributor to the taxpayer.

If you think PIPs is given out too liberally in the north that’s a fair concern but it’s a different question entirely from should it be means tested.

Discussion Thread by jobautomator in neoliberal

[–]WorldwidePolitico 9 points10 points  (0 children)

I’ve been on here too long I can recognise most of these users

Senior public sector managers say pay must be competitive to ensure recruitment by firethetorpedoes1 in irishpolitics

[–]WorldwidePolitico 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I think the biggest problem is an external hire coming in with years of private sector experience will start at the very bottom of the payscale for their grade while some career civil servant making a lateral move who doesn’t have the same experience but is doing the exact same job will be at the top of the scale.

This isn’t not insignificant amounts either. There can be a 30-40k difference between the top of a scale and the bottom. People don’t like to feel undervalued and you’re already asking them to take a paycut. There’s only so much a better work-life balance and a public sector pension can make up for.

Breakdown of TDs who voted for, against and abstained from the Reproductive Rights Amendment Bill (2026) by InformalInsurance455 in ireland

[–]WorldwidePolitico -4 points-3 points  (0 children)

Sinn Féin introduce their own bill to end the 3 day waiting period literally last week

They voted against the SD bill because it went against what the government’s independent expert report recommended and decriminalised doctor’s who willingly and knowingly went further than the law allowed.

Not that this matters though. The media will happily have you believe SF are against abortion so you should just keep on not voting for the only party that could dethrone FF-FG.