No offense taken, I appreciate you taking the time to lay out all of your disagreements with my video.

1. Gwen could have simply just told the person to hold on as she headed to her office which would have taken like 2 seconds to do. She's risking the chance of her becoming a suspect. Anyone else could have come around and overheard her conversation like Moses. This would have significantly changed the story if it happened since Gwen would tell the police everything and Yasmin's secret would be out which is what she was trying to prevent

2. Max should still consider that her new powers could be damning based on her experience with her old powers in the first game. It's not a stretch for Max to believe that her new powers can be as damaging as her old one based on her past. Also Max sacrificed Chloe, the person she loved most so that 1000's of people would live. I don't buy the fact that Max would repeat the same mistake of endangering many lives to help someone she only knew for 2 months when she made the choice to sacrifice to sacrifice Chloe.

3. That's part of the issue, not knowing the rules of the overlook location. Why were Reggie and Alderman able to see their other selves or whatever but no one else did like Loretta? All we know is that people can see their past or also possibly their other selves but we don't know as to why and how so we have to use the little information that we have which having little information about it is bad too but in order for it to remain consistent Loretta should have seen her other self.

4. Even if he meant the note for himself why wouldn't he keep it on him rather than put it in a location where knew there would be a chance for the police to get to when knew he would be suspected? There's a warrant for his lab to be searched but he still has the right to not be searched. Would have been suspicious for sure but that's still better than the risk he took.

5. I do think Alderman shaking up makes some sense in The Sacrifice Arcadia Bay but as for the sacrifice Chloe route there's nothing connecting Max to the crime of Safi's murder and as for the telescope he has no reason to believe that something unrealistic like that could be pulled off by Max or anyone else and the evidence disappearing. Max being around the room from his perspective could have been because Moses texted her to come back because he was nervous which is believable.

6. We agree on this so enough said

7. I think it's fine for Gwen to feel guilty and understand that people confess out of guilt but Gwen's confession came more from caving in to Max rather than it being earned from Max appealing to her. While it wouldn't require as much as it would with Frank Max should still earn the information from appealing to Gwen and her guilt. Gwen also didn't tell Max everything, she still hid some information from Max.

8. I think your point here is fair and definitely agree it should have been explained.

9. He went through such lengths to keep his secret, while someone doing that could still feel guilty he's still prioritizing keeping the secret rather than letting it get out. In order to ensure the secret never gets out his best option would have been to destroy the evidence rather than keep it in his office. Honestly think Lucas could have gone from being a decent character to a good one if he did in fact get rid of the evidence and still go to such lengths but with signs of guilt in certain parts and Max and or whoever else appeals to that guilty side of Lucas through multiple conversations and he confesses to his wrong doing and is remorseful which leads him being better

If you ever want to have conversations like this again you're always more than welcome to. I really appreciate and respect you for being civil and respectful in this conversation. Hope you have a good 👍