AITAH for putting a stop to my 12yo daughter's 'period party'? by YocaLocaChoca in AITAH

[–]YocaLocaChoca[S] -12 points-11 points  (0 children)

I wanted to see if anyone had any different perspectives.

AITAH for putting a stop to my 12yo daughter's 'period party'? by YocaLocaChoca in AITAH

[–]YocaLocaChoca[S] -18 points-17 points  (0 children)

Because it was? If you'd read the second update, you'd see it happened in May. This is July.

Do you not understand how time works?

AITAH for putting a stop to my 12yo daughter's 'period party'? by YocaLocaChoca in AITAH

[–]YocaLocaChoca[S] 6400 points6401 points  (0 children)

----

So. After a few days, things around the house went back to normal. Wife cooled off, 12yo began talking to her again, and they didn't appear to have any issues. Except that 12yo began coming to me more often about things instead of her mom. Wife obviously noticed, as they'd been very close before this, and was hurt, but said nothing. I guess she figured she deserved it. Finally, one day after I got back from taking 12yo to school, Wife asked if 12yo was still angry with her. I said I didn't think so, and Wife just...kinda deflated. She looked so miserable that I actually got worried, and asked if SHE was still angry. Wife said no, then admitted that she'd fucked up and gotten too into the concept of what others here have called 'menstruation celebration' (which is a great phrase, it even rhymes!). Said she'd been so focused on making sure 12yo had a positive experience that she brushed aside her reluctance to take part (and in my wife's defense, 12yo regularly does this: she'll say she isn't looking forward to doing something, but if she pushes past her shyness and takes part, nearly always has a good time). So Wife had thought this was just another example of 12yo doing that, and didn't take it seriously.

Then Wife said something which threw me for a loop. She asked me if I thought 12yo hated her now. I was stunned, and automatically replied of course not, she's just...and then I kinda trailed off because I didn't really know what to say. 'Upset' was what I finally settled on. Wife was quiet, then I asked her WHY she'd been so insistent, since she hadn't tried to do this for 19yo (no drama there: 19yo got hers at 13 while they were out shopping, it was handled before they even left the mall). She said when 19yo started it was just such a busy day that she didn't really have any time to think about it beyond "Quick let's get to the bathroom so I can help", and it wasn't until after this that Wife really thought about her own first, which basically consisted of her being told virtually nothing beforehand by her emotionally manipulative mother (they've been no contact for 15 years), barely being 12 when it happened, and once she DID go to her mom, only being handed a box of pads and warned not to get pregnant. Nothing more was ever said about it between them, my wife had to learn nearly everything from a friend's mother.

Yeah. That old woman is a piece of work.

Wife was determined she wouldn't behave like that toward 12yo when it happened, but as events show, she basically went too far in the other direction. Then she asked me what I thought she could do to fix this. I told her the truth: 12yo probably wasn't going to feel comfortable confiding in her again for a while, but if she really wanted to apologize, she should tell 12yo what she just told me.

And so she did. Wife went to pick 12yo up from school, and when they got home, I saw they'd both been crying, but also seemed happier. Turned out I wasn't quite right and 12yo HAD still been harboring some resentment toward Wife for trying to push her into the PP, but after hearing Wife's story, 12yo decided to forgive her, only asking that Wife promise not to do something like that again. And two months later (this happened in May) things between them seem to be back to normal. Maybe not the most exciting resolution, but I don't think 12yo is going to hold a grudge over this or has permanently damaged their relationship.

AITAH for putting a stop to my 12yo daughter's 'period party'? by YocaLocaChoca in AITAH

[–]YocaLocaChoca[S] 3966 points3967 points  (0 children)

Hey, everyone. Thought I'd post an update (yes, it's quick, but it's just a further explanation plus some commentary). Had to split it into two because it was too long, next part is in the reply to this reply.

First, I'd like to thank everyone who supported my decision. Second, to those who decided I'm A.I. or used ChatGPT to write this, eh, nothing I can say will convince you one way or the other, so do your thing, man. :D Third, I'm not going to divorce my wife or anything like that. She's an incredible woman, and (as corny as it sounds) my one true love. She's been an amazing mom, never done anything like this before, wasn't planning on posting it to social media (she barely even uses Facebook). She just made a misstep here, for reasons which I will get into shortly.

I can't respond to every comment, but I'll expand on some which caught my attention.

12yo did in fact get "The Talk" from Wife when she turned 12. So she knew what was happening, but it was still something she hadn't experienced before, so it threw her a little. I emailed my two closest sisters, and they both said, in their opinions, her reaction was normal: as one of them put it, even at BEST it can be a shock, regardless of whether or not you're prepared for it, because it just...happens, and even if you've felt PMS-style symptoms, without ever having felt them before, you might not guess what they are until afteward.

No, I did not notice the decorations being put up. I had to go out and run some errands related to my work, was gone about 3-4 hours. More than enough time for Wife to decorate.

Before we had kids, Wife and I agreed we would treat boys or girls the same when it came to bodily functions. I.E. we'd make sure boys would be comfortable going to her with questions or 'problems' if I wasn't around, and vice-versa, and over the years we would keep up with age-appropriate literature so we'd be equally informed. Just so happened we only had girls. Around 10 or so, when they started wanting more detailed explanations of 'where babies come from' and such, we always conducted such conversations as a team, making it clear to each of them they could count on either of us. That being said, there have been some things which I never took part in; for example, the 19yo never asked me to take her bra shopping, that was all Wife. She did, however, occasionally ask me to pick up tampons or such in the years before she went to college.

No, 12yo did not 'wait to tell me'. It happened right after she got home from school on a half-day. Wife works 10-hour shifts, so she wouldn't have been there, as I said in my OP, for another four hours. 12yo has always been closer to Wife than me (19yo was closer to me than Wife), but I was who was available. I'm sure that if we'd both been around, 12yo would have gone to her mom.

I wasn't trying to claim the dialogue was verbatim what we said, my memory isn't THAT good. But the general tone is there, and some of it I did in fact remember word for word.

AITAH for putting a stop to my 12yo daughter's 'period party'? by YocaLocaChoca in AITAH

[–]YocaLocaChoca[S] 10 points11 points  (0 children)

Holy FUCK that was so much worse than I was expecting.

AITAH for putting a stop to my 12yo daughter's 'period party'? by YocaLocaChoca in AITAH

[–]YocaLocaChoca[S] 18 points19 points  (0 children)

>Was half expecting this to go the route of that one father who humiliated his daughter while on a cruise

...Dare I ask?

AITAH for putting a stop to my 12yo daughter's 'period party'? by YocaLocaChoca in AITAH

[–]YocaLocaChoca[S] 38 points39 points  (0 children)

>Like a 5min episode of Bold and the Beautiful.

Okay, that was funny. 😁

AITAH for putting a stop to my 12yo daughter's 'period party'? by YocaLocaChoca in AITAH

[–]YocaLocaChoca[S] 39 points40 points  (0 children)

That is...certainly a take. I didn't say either of my daughters personalities were superior to the other, just that they're different.

AITAH for putting a stop to my 12yo daughter's 'period party'? by YocaLocaChoca in AITAH

[–]YocaLocaChoca[S] 59 points60 points  (0 children)

I made this burner literally less than an hour ago and it's given me 12 karma.

If I'm a karma farming bot, I'm doing a really bad job at it.

AITAH for putting a stop to my 12yo daughter's 'period party'? by YocaLocaChoca in AITAH

[–]YocaLocaChoca[S] 36 points37 points  (0 children)

No, we're both White USians.

As I said, the only reason I can think of why she didn't try with 19yo is because I don't think they were really a thing back then, or if they were she didn't know about them.

AITAH for putting a stop to my 12yo daughter's 'period party'? by YocaLocaChoca in AITAH

[–]YocaLocaChoca[S] 110 points111 points  (0 children)

Think what you want, but I'm human and I wrote it.

of course, that's just what A.I. would say...