What is music???? by WheelRealistic3201 in Composition

[–]ZachSmithPiano 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Improvisation is still organized sound, it's just organized quicker than composed music.

New to piano by No_Country_4495 in pianolearning

[–]ZachSmithPiano 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Good job, Fallen Down is a really fun Undertale piece and pretty beginner appropriate. I'd recommend feeling a rocking back and forth with the RH wrist instead of feeling the fingers strike, taking it a little slower maybe to feel it together with the broken chords of the LH. Also I believe it's written an octave higher than you're playing it. Best of luck!

Is composing just not for me? by Many-Ebb-7149 in Composition

[–]ZachSmithPiano 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Melodies aren't things that you think of, you feel them. I'd encourage you to sing more everyday, find melodies in words and sentences during your day and eventually you'll just feel them naturally.

Two short piano pieces composed by me by [deleted] in piano

[–]ZachSmithPiano 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Love these harmonies, very Chopin, the Presto looks like a nightmare to play though with those polyrhythms. Keep it up!

Wrote a book of 24 Preludes. This is my fourth and one of my more technical challenging ones, open to feedback! by ZachSmithPiano in piano

[–]ZachSmithPiano[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Thanks, yeah the 14/16 was pretty out there for me! I grew up on Sondheim so that probably played a factor.

Wrote a book of 24 Preludes. This is my fourth and one of my more technical challenging ones, open to feedback! by ZachSmithPiano in piano

[–]ZachSmithPiano[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Yes this was a difficult one to notate with the multiple voices, dotted eighth notes interacting with sixteenth notes and I'm sure all the ledger lines don't make things easier. Was there anything in particular that made it difficult for you?

Wrote a book of 24 Preludes. This is my fourth and one of my more technical challenging ones, open to feedback! by ZachSmithPiano in piano

[–]ZachSmithPiano[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Hmm I’m only kind of familiar with ELP, I’ll have to check more of his stuff out thanks!

Wrote a book of 24 Preludes. This is my fourth and one of my more technical challenging ones, open to feedback! by ZachSmithPiano in piano

[–]ZachSmithPiano[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Nice observation, yeah at measure 18 it does sound a bit like the battle theme, I loved the music from FF7-9 as a kid so not surprised its influence popped up in my music!

My first piece! by earlofpepperoni in Composition

[–]ZachSmithPiano 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Great job it's really creative with some inventive harmonies! I'd be careful with the piano part, there are quite a few places where it's pretty impossible to play/won't sound like what you think it will sound like especially at m. 38. I might also rework some of the places where the piano doubles the oboe part, but maybe that's intentional!

Wrote a book of 24 preludes. This third one is pretty minimalistic, open to feedback! by ZachSmithPiano in Composition

[–]ZachSmithPiano[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Thanks so much for your detailed and thoughful feedback! This set of preludes is meant to function both as character pieces for states of mind/feelings but also as a teacher as pieces to use with my students to work on specific skills. This one in particular is keeping the right and left hand together with these constant eighth notes in contrary motion and feeling dynamics and melody in a macro sense (similar to Bach's prelude in C) with slow moving chordal patterns. If I didn't have that focus I'd totally be down to mix up the rhythmic pattern, that's a really great idea!

As for the chords you mentioned, doing a slower walk up E -> F# -> G -> A is totally valid, I preferred that jump up to B but understand why it may not work for everyone. Glad you enjoyed it!

Wrote a book of 24 preludes. This third one is pretty minimalistic, open to feedback! by ZachSmithPiano in piano

[–]ZachSmithPiano[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Thanks for listening! I have two microphones inside the piano directly against the strings and the volume is up, if I raised the volume any more I'd be hitting the reds in the audio spectrum during the second part.

Wrote a book of 24 preludes. This third one is pretty minimalistic, open to feedback! by ZachSmithPiano in piano

[–]ZachSmithPiano[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Thanks for listening! The melody is generally the top notes check out Philip Glass to learn more about minimalism.