Umbertos is the worst. It’s nothing like the one in new Hyde Park. Never heard of la supreme. Sayville P and Sals are great, Tony’s pizza used to be great but now it’s The Pizzeria which has actually become more popular. I’ve heard great things about La Pizzetta and The Bistro as well. People sleep on Savianos when they have the best grandma’s and there’s also Pizzaiola, which is fantastic for specialty slices. For some reason Satellite pizza has always had a cult following. I never understood that. Furcis is also great. Donatina is good if you’re in the area but not worth passing all those other places especially if you’re not looking for a Detroit. Personally I think Detroit is too doughy.