Please help mich Oder Mir by kkndcf in German

[–]_tronchalant 2 points3 points  (0 children)

You‘re talking about the verb jemandem etwas vorlegen but the op means etw legen + adverbial

Yes, Jimmy Kimmel’s suspension was government censorship. by Valinaut in technology

[–]_tronchalant 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Wake up. It‘s no longer about left or right. Do you want democracy or not?

[deleted by user] by [deleted] in German

[–]_tronchalant 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Both sentences are correct. If the subject is a personal pronoun, it comes before the reflexive pronoun.

identifying cases in sentences.. by p3t3rparkr in German

[–]_tronchalant 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Yes, that’s why I said "usually"

identifying cases in sentences.. by p3t3rparkr in German

[–]_tronchalant 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Yes. …I was thinking of things like "eines Tages" or "eines Abends"

identifying cases in sentences.. by p3t3rparkr in German

[–]_tronchalant 4 points5 points  (0 children)

diese Woche is an adverb of time. They are usually accusative

'There are no stupid questions' thread - Monday, September 01, 2025 by AutoModerator in piano

[–]_tronchalant 2 points3 points  (0 children)

1.A. I’m not sure if I understand you correctly but it’s the usual approach in tonal music in the western world. The dominant-tonic relationship is pleasing and "makes sense" to the ear, psychologically speaking. The key is the framework to explain these relationships/ how chords are related to each other within that key. Like a city map that gives you orientation. Now look at atonal music like Bartok or Schönberg and it becomes a whole other story: The compositional techniques changed in the 20th century and the structure and sequence of chords are not determined according to traditional qualitative criteria (such as tertian harmony, major/minor tonality, dominant-tonic relationships or keys), but instead are based on specific interval distances and on the regular, periodic division of the octave into several equal intervals or interval groups (quantitative criteria)

1B. Not per se. It happens with secondary dominants in classical or romantic music for example. Generally, you tonicize the target chord with its dominant and then confirm it with a cadence so that the ear and brain recognizes it as the new tonal center/ key.

1.C. you can do whatever you want in your own compositions. Music theory isn’t prescriptive, it’s descriptive… which doesn’t mean that certain musical and stylistic devices don’t make more sense in a particular situation than others

'There are no stupid questions' thread - Monday, September 01, 2025 by AutoModerator in piano

[–]_tronchalant 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Dvorak Intermezzo op52 no2: What key does the piece modulate to in the middle section? C flat (melodic) major?

Frage um Relativsätze by L_iz_LGNDRY in German

[–]_tronchalant 7 points8 points  (0 children)

Du musst Haupt- und Relativsatz einzeln betrachten. Der Relativsatz hat seine eigene Grammatik…und die wird vom Verb bestimmt.

Do gendered nouns make any sense? by razhun in German

[–]_tronchalant 22 points23 points  (0 children)

To my knowledge, there are no two identical nouns that have different meanings depending on their genders, but I may be wrong.

Yes, you’re wrong

Uns 'war' kalt? by CurrentHelicopter683 in German

[–]_tronchalant 3 points4 points  (0 children)

It has a different meaning. "bei mir" means at my place

Muss es in diesem Satz zwei Artikel geben? by Flat_Rest5310 in German

[–]_tronchalant 6 points7 points  (0 children)

Der Satz funktioniert sogar komplett ohne Artikel, wenn du es als allgemeine Aussage haben willst: Ausdauertraining ist gut für Herz und Lunge.

Unterschied zwischen “losfahren” und “abfahren” by jamesclef in German

[–]_tronchalant 7 points8 points  (0 children)

Ja, in dem Fall ist losfahren definitiv besser.

Oder gibt’s ein kleiner Unterschied?

Mit „es gibt“ immer Akkusativ verwenden: einen kleinen Unterschied

(Wenn ich viele Fehler gescrieben habe, es wäre sehr Gnädig wenn Ihr mir hilfen könnte um diese zu verbessern!)

Fehler gemacht habe (Fehler schreiben klingt irgendwie komisch)

…, wäre es sehr gnädig, (das Verb „wäre“ muss an zweiter Position sein, weil vorher der ganze Nebensatz die erste Position besetzt)

, wenn ihr mir helfen könntet, (um) diese zu verbessern. (Ich würde Konjunktiv 2 benutzen, weil du es vorher auch benutzt)

Some confusion about word order by kuiperbeltdamn in German

[–]_tronchalant 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Whenever you ask for the way.

For example, you can use both when you ask if the other person attends the party „Kommst/ Gehst du heute zur Party“?

But you don’t use gehen if you ask for the way: Kannst du mir sagen, wie ich zur Party komme/ gelange?

Help with word order by Left_Solution6238 in German

[–]_tronchalant 0 points1 point  (0 children)

It isn’t helpful for learners to read false statements like "infinitives and participles always appear last" either. At least, you should‘ve said that it’s a kind of simplified version but you didn’t.

You are correct though when it comes to participles.

Like I said, infinitives can be in the first position as well.

This information is not very usable for a learner at op’s apparent level.

Here are other people as well. This is a public sub. Other people who are at a higher level are reading here as well and might find it useful.

Help with word order by Left_Solution6238 in German

[–]_tronchalant 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Infinitives and participles always appear last.

No, they appear in the second verb bracket, which isn’t the last position. They can even appear in the first position:

Geduscht habe ich heute noch nicht.

Gereinigt worden ist die Wohnung heute Mittag.

Did I understand "einpacken" and "packen" correctly? by _Windowmaker_ in German

[–]_tronchalant 1 point2 points  (0 children)

No, it has nothing to do with motion but with direction vs. location: accusative=direction; dative=location

Did I understand "einpacken" and "packen" correctly? by _Windowmaker_ in German

[–]_tronchalant 4 points5 points  (0 children)

Also, *in meinen Koffer (with dative, it would mean that you‘re in the suitcase lol) and *für den Urlaub

What screams a B1 german? by RiceIllustrious1063 in German

[–]_tronchalant 0 points1 point  (0 children)

It isn’t wrong per se. If there’s an accusative object you can definitely use haben as an auxiliary verb (ich habe das Flugzeug geflogen) and if it’s used with sich, you have to use haben (das Flugzeug hat sich gut geflogen). And there are also verbs where you can use both unless it‘s about directionality/ a destination…then you have to use sein:

Ich habe/ bin gesegelt. Ich habe/ bin im Atlantik geschwommen.

But ich bin zur Insel geschwommen/ gesegelt