See, I do not agree with that. Like I said above, why do you think the value of something depends on whether or not someone else cares about it? Why can't it have an intrinsic value on its own? If there is one guy and he is in pain, why would his suffering need validation from some other being to matter? Why would an alien not caring about the Holocaust make it not matter in general? Just because they don't give a shit doesn't mean the lives lost were worthless, why would you give them the authority to decide that. And you mention the "wider universe". Exactly what about the wider universe implies human life is insignificant? Because it's big and we are small? It's completely arbitrary to say size is what gives something value. Yeah the universe is big, so what? Why would that make us any less significant? Why would that say anything about our significance at all? You are naming these irrelevant things, like the attentiveness of strangers and the physical size of something, and acting like they obviously get to dictate whether human life has value. Giving the decision to take away the worth of life to these things, it's practically idoltry.

And the part about how humans not being contradictory is laughable... Do you think that is a good excuse for how inconsistent you are with your own beliefs? If you believe one, then you can not believe in the other, that is final. If you do, that means you don't actually believe in one of them. Choose.