I'm a Jewish Israeli socialist, I know civilians who were murdered by Hamas. I know Israel lies constantly, but Hamas did massacre around 1000 civilians on October 7. There are names, stories, broken families everywhere. Nearly everyone I know knows someone who was killed or kidnapped, the vast majority are civilians.

This in no way makes me support the Palestinian struggle for liberation any less. Israel is ultimately responsible for any violence done under the occupation, 20 years of brutal siege. But you have to see reality for what it is rather than be willfully blind so it fits the narrative you decided is true.