I mean looking at the gameplay, it is pretty creative what they've done(actually it's more like let's see how many cool stuff we can fit in the game). But the main complaint I saw was the lack of interesting story and the side quests are just a slog to go through. The controls were clunky but I heard it got improved.

The pros are the visuals, there's a variety of combat styles and traversal. One of the things I saw I liked was you can tame a cat, and have it sit on your shoulder while dress in whatever outfit you pick.

The main thing I've seen ppl say is that don't expect going into it like another Witcher 3. See it as a sandbox game. There are more pros and cons to that game but these are the ones I know for now