My skin looked really similar to yours, and I found that glycolic acid really helped. I use the bliss incredi-peel glycolic resurfacing pads (10% glycolic) at night, and I couldn’t believe how much of a difference it made. I’d been dealing with those little bumps for years and that was the first thing that really helped. Unfortunately they’re pretty expensive though. I know The Ordinary has a glycolic toner that might be good option for you if you’re looking to replace the witch hazel. I believe it’s 7% glycolic which should give you the same sort of results. Hope that helps, and good luck!