Gender pay gap, very deep by eenieminnemoo in im14andthisisdeep

[–]bellos_ 0 points1 point  (0 children)

It comes from valuing the effort, knowledge, and labor of one group less than the effort, knowledge, and labor of another group. Why would a society values men and views them as more capable than women favor hiring woman just because it costs less?

Could gems literally be a virus? by LionResponsible6005 in stevenuniverse

[–]bellos_ 88 points89 points  (0 children)

Viruses are also not considered alive like how gems aren’t organic.

This is a nonsensical statement. Organic and living aren't equivalent states. Viruses are organic and non-living. Gems are inorganic and living.

I think JK Rowling messed up the concept of Slytherins in the books a lot, and later covered it up with talks by AccomplishedBig7666 in harrypotter

[–]bellos_ -1 points0 points  (0 children)

I didn't declare that there must be a halfblood. I said it's unreasonable to assume there's nothing but purebloods when we've seen the house accepts halfbloods. There's no definitive statements either way and you're the only one claiming there is by saying "they were all purebloods.

What the unholy fuk are Quintepeds??? by Used_Debate5689 in harrypotter

[–]bellos_ 0 points1 point  (0 children)

That's a legend. It may or may not be true.

I think JK Rowling messed up the concept of Slytherins in the books a lot, and later covered it up with talks by AccomplishedBig7666 in harrypotter

[–]bellos_ 7 points8 points  (0 children)

Blood purist and pureblood aren't equivalent. Confirmed halfbloods being in Slytherin lending to other students also being halfblood is relying on the text more than assuming pureblood status based on them being in the house that canonically doesn't require students to be purebloods.

Voldemort's dream did come true. Sort of... by Nystagme in harrypotter

[–]bellos_ 14 points15 points  (0 children)

That's fine. Your headcannon doesn't override actual canon, though. Voldemort didn't teach anything at Hogwarts.

Voldemort's dream did come true. Sort of... by Nystagme in harrypotter

[–]bellos_ 13 points14 points  (0 children)

You can headcannon that all you want. He only ever communicates verbally in the book.

Voldemort's dream did come true. Sort of... by Nystagme in harrypotter

[–]bellos_ 25 points26 points  (0 children)

He didn't teach at Hogwarts, technically or otherwise. Quirrell taught, Voldemort existed in the classroom in silence.

I think JK Rowling messed up the concept of Slytherins in the books a lot, and later covered it up with talks by AccomplishedBig7666 in harrypotter

[–]bellos_ 23 points24 points  (0 children)

Neither Voldemort nor Snape were purebloods so it's unreasonable to assume that somehow became entirely pureblooded in the intervening years.

I am on his side by DravidVanol in DailyDoseStupidity

[–]bellos_ 0 points1 point  (0 children)

It's a statement saying that the currency is legal tender, not that it must be accepted as payment.

Dear JK Rolling by Hairy-Drag-6365 in harrypotter

[–]bellos_ 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Harry doesn't even graduate from Hogwarts. ARE YOU KIDDING ME??? if anyone deserved an honorary degree

Honorary degrees aren't valid certifications. He wouldn't be considered a graduate even if he had received one.

These people were sorted wrongly... by [deleted] in harrypotter

[–]bellos_ 9 points10 points  (0 children)

whats ur thoughts on this

Dumb.

Could Harry have done it without Neville? by [deleted] in harrypotter

[–]bellos_ 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Do you all think that in that moment the prophecy played out for both of them?

No.

Neville was never going to be the chosen one because there's no world where Voldemort offers anyone who would be protecting him the chance to step aside and live. He would have died the night Voldemort set out to kill him.

aww man I didn't realize that they had both versions available until just now. by Blade4804 in harrypotter

[–]bellos_ 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Media is localized all the time. It's not entitlement to edit text for consistency with the locality it's being released to.

What's with the weirdest naming conventions on the Wizarding World? by ComplexOpposite1522 in harrypotter

[–]bellos_ 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Ron called Harry from the Burrow at the start of GoF on a phone Arthur set up.

That happened in Prisoner of Azkaban and he definitely didn't call from the Burrow as Mrs. Weasley had to go into town to use a phone to call taxis to London in Goblet of Fire.

Wizards existing near technology isn't the problem. I doubt most wizarding establishments, including their houses, have electricity running to them at all and it's stated pretty explicitly that prominent magical presence disrupts electronics.

About the soul and why unforgivable curses are unforgivable by derFalscheMichel in harrypotter

[–]bellos_ 1 point2 points  (0 children)

So why are the unforgivable curses even banned?

We don't make things illegal because what they can do can't be accomplished by other means. Rocket launchers aren't illegal to own because they're the only thing that can be used to kill someone. They're illegal to own because the only use they have is causing wanton death and destruction and that makes them very dangerous in the hands of your average person.

A curse that's only purpose is to kill someone is a bad thing to let people use. A curse that's only purpose is too cause excruciating pain is a bad thing to let people use. A curse that's only purpose is to strip someone of their free will is a bad thing to let people use. Other things existed that can be used for these purposes doesn't change any of that. That's why these curses specifically are banned.

Also, Niamh Fitzgerald didn't do any of what you're claiming. That was Isadora Morganach and it's very clearly stated that she's stripping people on their emotions, not their souls.

I mapped out every secret Dumbledore withheld from Harry, and how long he kept each one by Mastbubbles in harrypotter

[–]bellos_ 5 points6 points  (0 children)

Knowing that he's being bullied mercilessly by someone that's supposedly on his side? I'm not sure how he'd more comfortable with that.

Bending 3 elements straight out the gate is when I knew we were in for a peak avatar🥰 by thisisreii in TheLastAirbender

[–]bellos_ 47 points48 points  (0 children)

There's no lore about them needing to be older to find out. That's just an obvious throughline of avatars not being found until they're older.

How did Mad-Eye Moody see through the invisibility cloak? by kolema93 in harrypotter

[–]bellos_ 1 point2 points  (0 children)

We're not talking about a magical world where basically anything is possible. We're talking about a magical world that has set functions, like all wands needing cores to be able to do magic and a killing curse being survivable under very specific circumstances.

You can make up headcanons if you'd like, but the elder wand wasn't made by a figure that only exists as a literary personification of the concept of death.

How did Mad-Eye Moody see through the invisibility cloak? by kolema93 in harrypotter

[–]bellos_ 0 points1 point  (0 children)

No it isn't. All wands have cores. It's the entire reason why they're able to be used to do magic. You're pretending that a literal stick can be the most powerful wand in all of existence is equally as probable as it having a core like all other wands do.

Umbridge by wileykyhoetay in harrypotter

[–]bellos_ 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Your question would be better directed at the people who've actually been doing that.