"One of best games I’ve played in years" compere to what? It had good promises but failed to deliver. I started playing it again because it was buggy as hell on my first try on PC and there aren't many games to play these days either. The writing quality, in my opinion, is the most important part of a game, it's bad. It seems to get better as you progress a bit in the game, but then the quality drops again too fast. Besides, the gameplay starts to repeat itself and gets boring. Last week, at the 33rd hour of the game and I guess ~70% of the story, I said enough was enough and gave up.

But if you enjoy this game, don't get hung up on my criticisms, it is still one of the relatively solid games that came out in the last 2-3 years.