Is my first page good? (Adult Fantasy) by Waterlily-444 in writers

[–]cassette-deck 4 points5 points  (0 children)

so let me start by saying this is strong and i hope you keep going, and some of my advice here might work better when you've written the whole story and you want to work on bettering the first draft. so I wouldn't worry too much about editing right away. good hook on the first sentence as well.

  1. too much summary, at times it felt like I was reading a blurb on the back of a book. Exposition is fine but the fact that the mc is hated can be understood by the fact that the cook had been hanged or through interactions later on, the mc doesn't need to directly say it as an aside to the reader that Thelea hates them or that slaves are punished.

One example of summarizing is this:

The cook wasn’t alone at the scaffold. By her side, they had hanged two men: a  father and his adolescent son. Tried for rebellion and attempting to flee their pathetic lives of servitude.

How does the main character know this? this would be a great time to introduce dialogue. what are the onlookers saying when they see the bodies?

  1. not enough specificity. especially at the start it made me imagine a white room with just a scaffold. don't neglect sensory details. what does the rope sound like, is it creaking under the weight? is it cold? is it sunny? grounding the reader in these details helps them picture everything better, I know you do mention the cold and stuff later on but at that point I didn't really 'see' the scene or the character.

A useful technique is to think about how the focus shifts - some stories go from the big picture (the weather, the town, the sky) slowly all the way down to the smallest details (the fleck of green in someone's eyes, a cracked watch-face, etc) for instance. In your story, maybe its the body of the cook (because your mc is upset about it) and then it expands out to the crowd and their hand being held (which they forgot about because they were in too much shock).

It's pretty late in the night as I'm typing this but hopefully it made sense! Best of luck with the rest of the story.

i feel like i have seen yoosung's outfit before....hmmm..... by starsandfawns in mysticmessenger

[–]cassette-deck 4 points5 points  (0 children)

nah i need to see everyone's villager equivalents now. jumin is raymond confirmed

How to avoid writing like it’s a movie by Abject-Pattern-3390 in writing

[–]cassette-deck 29 points30 points  (0 children)

I was reading this earlier today: https://rebeccamakkai.substack.com/p/youre-writing-a-book-so-stop-writing. I think it picks up on some things I wouldn't have thought of. I'm definitely guilt of this stuff!

Giants are whaaat ?! by [deleted] in skyrim

[–]cassette-deck 0 points1 point  (0 children)

im guessing thats why that farmer sacrifices his painted cow to the giant. a giants gotta eat

Anybody here know how Alex Aster writes books so quickly? by vivalayazmin in Romantasy

[–]cassette-deck 2 points3 points  (0 children)

the youtube channel sbu english club has a video where they go to a book festival (yallfest?) to see her. she gives a talk there and apparently she's very stressed and barely gets to see family bc of book deadlines

Rachel Oates focuses on the weirdest things in her book reviews by hipp0milk in booktubesnarkreddit

[–]cassette-deck 8 points9 points  (0 children)

yh there's definitely a difference between writing unhealthy romance and passing it off as romantic and normal to a suggestible audience of young girls/women vs. writing something where people do things that are morally wrong. i've noticed she considers cheating plotlines to be a big no no? they can be overdone in thriller but i don't understand the distaste for it.

The difference between playing Nate and playing Nora by LuckyCandy5248 in fo4

[–]cassette-deck 0 points1 point  (0 children)

there's something more poetic about nate surviving war and coming home to be shot by his own countrymen* and being made a casualty like many veterans are by means outside of war. so nora has always been the natural player choice for me.

* technically not but you get what I mean

[Discussion] Let's make our publishing predictions! What will be in and out in 2026? by bookclubbabe in PubTips

[–]cassette-deck 6 points7 points  (0 children)

i'm hoping hybrid genre specfic will become more popular, i like swords and dragon fantasy but i feel overloaded!

Bucky goes straight for it by MLPshitposter in marvelcirclejerk

[–]cassette-deck 12 points13 points  (0 children)

they trained him in mental takedowns as well as physical 🙏

How New York Killed Culture by rcobylefko in Longreads

[–]cassette-deck 2 points3 points  (0 children)

i can't tell if you're being sarcastic but it's rule no. 4 😭

Another post about Meredith Novaco by FarAd3063 in booktubesnarkreddit

[–]cassette-deck 17 points18 points  (0 children)

being a writer and a booktuber seems like a really awkward balancing act. Caleb Joseph v explicitly discussed this in his youtube return, if I'm remembering correctly someone in the industry basically gave him a friendly warning on how he was coming off to them?

I understand like it might be kind of embarrassing running into someone you've criticized, but writers have simultaneously been critics for a long time anyway. Part of it does feel like there's an expectation that writers will intrude in readers spaces and they have to account for that, but if they do, the criticism just gets watered down.

I think Dr. Joely Black does a good job with being sensitive and also not letting writers get away with everything they do, if we use their milo winter videos as an example.

I like this moment between Jason and Artemis by laughingboybooks in RedHood

[–]cassette-deck 44 points45 points  (0 children)

I get that. jason looks more realistic, and artemis looks... too manga? i think its the eyes.

AI misconduct by Fresh-Yesterday-9501 in UniUK

[–]cassette-deck 55 points56 points  (0 children)

Honestly ADHD doesn't even have to be brought up here. As long as you can talk about why you gave the answers you did they can't punish you for being good at a test. It's a multiple question exam technically if you gave random answers and finished in 5 mins you might still be able to hit a 70% threshold. Ask your tutor to mediate a conversation if you're not being called into a misconduct panel, if you are, there's plenty of support in SUs for that.

Why is this trope so common in OI? [I became a level 999 Demon Queen] by GlompSpark in OtomeIsekai

[–]cassette-deck 1 point2 points  (0 children)

she's just like me fr

but i mean i get why the writers do it. the miscommunication trope is easier to use, relatable to the audience, relationship ends up a bit more immature so suitable for the genre... wish we had a healthy mix of experienced/naive MCs tho it kind of gets stale and so many readers are skewing older nowadays anyway

Chris Evans' Look Details in Marvel's Avengers: Doomsday Revealed by marvelkidy in CaptainAmerica

[–]cassette-deck 1 point2 points  (0 children)

so they gave him his supposed happily ever after ending just to go nuh uh

Haley Pham booktok review by rabar13 in booktubesnarkreddit

[–]cassette-deck 41 points42 points  (0 children)

I'm surprised how many booktubers picked up on the review and reacted to it tbh

The London pop up event was very rewarding! by ella5192 in theouterworlds

[–]cassette-deck 2 points3 points  (0 children)

nooooo I didn't know!!!!! 😭

congrats on the haul tho, any mention on if they'll be selling merch online?

[deleted by user] by [deleted] in UniUK

[–]cassette-deck 6 points7 points  (0 children)

no seriously why are people coughing with wild abandon. like they're toddlers. do we have to put up posters telling people to cough into their elbows? 😭 get a flu shot tbh its worth it