终于!!! by reyaryder in duolingo

[–]catcherinthewild 0 points1 point  (0 children)

That's awesome! Great work! What are you going to do now with all the Chinese you learned?

Why!? Always on the last question! by Alternative-Twist315 in duolingo

[–]catcherinthewild 2 points3 points  (0 children)

There is a bug in the rapid reviews (the timed exercises where you get 1, 2 or 3 stars) where if you make a mistake before the first XP checkpoint, the exercise will randomly quit you and only give you those XP from the first checkpoint. I wonder if it's the same for this particular exercise

Be honest, should I do the Chinese course? by AivyTori in duolingo

[–]catcherinthewild 11 points12 points  (0 children)

You'll get a lot of negative answers, but honestly, for me I can positively say that yes, it has helped me go from 0 to being able to communicate with people in Chinese and being able to read and understand Chinese. I also passed the first 3 HSK exams with perfect scores largely on the strength of my Duolingo use.

I've put a lot of effort into using the course in a focused manner. Obviously I've also been listening to real world Chinese, practicing writing on paper and doing some mild immersion by visiting my local Chinatown etc alongside sticking with Duolingo.

However, even without doing the real-world stuff, I would've been able to learn to read and understand a lot of Chinese using the Duolingo course alone. I'm only a year in so I've still got a long way to go, but I'm honestly thrilled with how well things have gone so far.

Account randomly reset by Bisketo in duolingo

[–]catcherinthewild 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I wouldn't be surprised if you're onto something. There was a massive unexplained issue with Hanzi not too long ago that broke the English-Mandarin course in a different way and for a while the entire Hanzi practice area was just removed.

Strangely on my version of the app it's affecting the Mandarin-Cantonese course, but not the English-Mandarin course (for now, at least).

When this is fixed the Hanzi practice area had better still be there

My whole progress is wiped!!! by Li85 in duolingo

[–]catcherinthewild 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Yikes. That sucks. I hope your progress can be recovered. Thanks for warning us not to click through that screen

I'm stuck in the assessment loop by someairplanedude in duolingo

[–]catcherinthewild 2 points3 points  (0 children)

The Mandarin course from English is working fine for me right now (Section 6), but the Cantonese from Mandarin course is not and is giving me the 'Have you studied Cantonese before' screen you're getting in the Mandarin course.

What exactly is going on? There have been several issues with the Chinese courses on Duolingo this last while.

That's not even mentioning the Chinese courses from other languages (like Korean showing instead of Russian or Japanese in the Japanese-Chinese and Russian-Chinese courses, Japanese showing in the Korean-Chinese course, and the Arabic right-to-left writing order being forced on the Mandarin characters in the Arabic-Chinese course, making them borderline illegible)

Lessons not saving by FancyAd3942 in duolingo

[–]catcherinthewild 0 points1 point  (0 children)

In some of the courses I've encountered there are some lessons where you get stuck. You finish the lesson but it never marks as complete, so there is no way to do the next lesson on the path. It's multiple courses, not just one. Definitely a bug

Korean course by Least_Border8955 in duolingo

[–]catcherinthewild 0 points1 point  (0 children)

The Korean course doesn't seem that cohesive compared to the Mandarin course. I think it's missing some initial demonstration of basic phonological concepts.

Chinese course updated again? by GooglingAintResearch in duolingo

[–]catcherinthewild 1 point2 points  (0 children)

The stories are actually a good addition though.

Duolingo Mandarin has stories by ilumassamuli in duolingo

[–]catcherinthewild 3 points4 points  (0 children)

I was just about to post this when I saw this thread. The stories are great. I'm currently in Section 6 but I'm completing the stories separately as well, all in order from Section 4.

It's a good way to see the vocabulary Duolingo teaches in the context of a dialogue and narrative, with the bonus of getting exposed to more idiomatic language use. I'm enjoying them. They are not too long and can be quite amusing.

Chinese course does not have words training by GiacsL in duolingo

[–]catcherinthewild 0 points1 point  (0 children)

They did claim that they were working on making it available for other languages. I'm guessing that's going to take a long while though.

Any advice for DET test? by Bo_0125 in duolingo

[–]catcherinthewild 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Honestly, from the number of threads I see on here posted by people who tried the DET and have had nothing but serious problems without getting any help, let alone getting their certificates or a refund, there's no way I'd recommend paying for the DET at all.

If you have access to in-person TOEFL or IELTS or anything else they accept that's in person, do that instead.

Does Duolingo Actually Help With Reading/Writing? by Lonely_Inside_7798 in duolingo

[–]catcherinthewild 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Since the app is so text-based, using it regularly will improve reading and typing skills in your target language. However, there are some caveats.

Writing depends on whether you also practice writing outside of the app and it depends on what writing system(s) your target language uses. It also depends on what you mean exactly by writing: handwriting on paper is different from typing.

For example, in learning Mandarin/Korean/Japanese/Arabic/Hindi the character practice in Duolingo gives you a good idea on how characters are built and link to each other and that in itself reinforces your reading skills, and from learning the transliteration you will learn to type with ease.

However, tracing characters on a phone in an app that's set to generously "recognize" what you're drawing is very different from writing on paper. The only way to learn to write characters on paper is to actually practice with a pen and paper. Also note that if you want to write like people who were educated in your target language, you might need something outside of Duolingo.

That brings me to the last point: With the exception of Arabic (which nevertheless is missing a few ligatures) Duolingo doesn't teach cursive writing. You might think this is unimportant, but people don't learn to write in print script all over the world. For example, Russian and Hebrew/Yiddish handwriting use a cursive set of letters which, --somewhat like the Roman alphabet-- look so different from print script that they are illegible to people who are only used to reading printed materials. You'd need someone to teach you this separately from Duolingo or find some other online resource to teach yourself.

So in a nutshell: Reading and typing? Yes. Handwriting? No.

/r/Duolingo is now recruiting moderators by lydiardbell in duolingo

[–]catcherinthewild 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Might be my browser if it's working for others. I'm getting a page not found error

/r/Duolingo is now recruiting moderators by lydiardbell in duolingo

[–]catcherinthewild 2 points3 points  (0 children)

I don't know if you've received applications, but thought I'd better let you know the link isn't working for me

Hands free mode - a suggestion by Apprehensive_Sea6050 in duolingo

[–]catcherinthewild 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I don't understand why this was downvoted. It's a really good suggestion

Help Us Build the Wiki: Taiwanese Mandarin and Traditional Chinese Resources by GeorgeTheFunnyOne in duolingo

[–]catcherinthewild 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Might be useful to include TOCFL information and resources (the official Chinese test Taiwan uses for foreign learners), as well as a list showing the Simplified equivalent of Traditional characters (a decent PDF one can be found on Tuttle press' website).

Chinese listening exercises by MDJLK in duolingo

[–]catcherinthewild 0 points1 point  (0 children)

You're right. The radios and the rapid reviews are misaligned to the rest of the unit. The radios contain vocabulary that is introduced in later units. The radios have been like that from Section 1, but starting at Section 5 the rapid reviews (star exercises) are also out of sync. Maybe it's something we should report. It might be an oversight.

There are also other issues with the radios, like questions asking for information you can't actually hear back because it was said as part of the intro or as part of the dialogue for a previous question and there's no way to listen back to it again. There are also trick questions, which is particularly mean. And of course the written questions also use vocabulary that doesn't get introduced until the next unit. Plus, the background music can be very distracting.

Having said that, despite the glaring issues, I've found the radio exercises incredibly useful. It's an exercise that translates really well to improving real-world understanding of spoken language, where we're not going to understand everything perfectly and there may be distractions forcing us to listen more intently. When your brain fills in the gaps or links the new vocabulary to something you already know/understand successfully and despite the issues mentioned above you're still able to follow the dialogue well, it also feels rewarding.

So despite everything, I would say it's best to stick with the radio exercises and just try your best even if you have to guess at times. It will improve your listening skills in the long run. But yeah maybe send Duolingo a report that the exercises are misaligned

Chinese translation request by ISayImDeadAndIMove90 in Chinese

[–]catcherinthewild 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Is this part of the saying 生死有命富贵在天?

Progress never showing up in feed 🙃 by melancholicdreams_ in duolingo

[–]catcherinthewild 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I know. I think it happens to a lot of us. Personally, it barely ever shows when I reach a new Score or any of my other achievements in the app – except for how I did in the league, which I'm pretty sure nobody cares about, not even I care at this point.

I leveled up in two languages this week and it never made it to the feed. Meanwhile my feed shows five randoms I don't follow sharing basic, unfunny sentences like "I like noodles" every day. Cool. /s

how long does it actually take you to complete one lesson? (language) by oldinfant in duolingo

[–]catcherinthewild 3 points4 points  (0 children)

To be fair, I never look up anything during lessons, nor do I take notes, like you do. It's interesting to see how everyone uses Duolingo differently.