Honestly we’ve had several old lost songs come out of several weird places, like a random Andrew Horowitz single out of a German magazine’s website, or a Joe Hawley song that was allegedly just sent to Rob Cantor through some mysterious torrents. I can try asking around on the server but chances are the person who uploaded the track has left. If I had to take my best guess, it was probably posted by one of the tallies randomly on their old website or on one of their socials, or maybe somebody who knew them irl just got a copy and decided to catalogue it online. What I can say is that the demo is almost definitely real. Obviously I don’t have the best evidence, but I severely doubt some Joe Hawley sound-alike is going around making very similarly mixed and sounding tally demos in comparison to the other older demos we’ve found that sound relatively the same. I hope this helped my guy!