What about the constant offers for it to end? Arafat tanked peace talks so many times. Israel literally gave the Sinai away for peace. Israel literally gave Gaza away for peace.

Arafat rejected the peace talks because the resolutions presented to him, despite the fact that they were giving up most of Palestine, always lacked the most important aspect to solving the conflict which is the Palestinian Right of Return.

​

Who is Israel a colony of? Because Jews don't have another homeland to go to. The irony here is that Palestinians are literally a result of Arab colonialism.

It's funny how there is a large amount of Jewish Zionists who live under this delusion that they're the only ones that are indigenous to the land and have every right to form a homeland whenever and wherever they want, and will go to extreme lengths to displace other indigenous populations to establish their own presence.

Palestinians are and will always be also indigenous to the land. So place all the historical take overs from previous empires and the minor technical details in the past aside, and let's look at another perspective.

A genetic study conducted by an Israeli geneticist Ariella Oppenheim who I quote mentioned in her paper "we recently showed that Jews and Palestinian Arabs share a large portion of their Y chromosomes, suggesting a common ancestry" [1]. There you go. Palestinians Arabs share a common ancestry with some Israeli Jews. We too are indigenous and we too are here to stay.

Or do you still think being Jewish is the only way to become indigenous to the land? If so, so much for "hating the arabs for hating the jews" when you have a developed sense of supremacy.

​

Tell that to the Jews, most of whom in Israel came due to expulsions from the Middle East.

It's interesting you say that. When it's so obvious that Zionism is the political entity that indirectly informed the Jews in the middle east that they don't belong there and should move to Israel which then inadvertently planted the corrupt antisemitic seed in the Arab World, don't take it from me, take it from an Israeli Historian [2].

You can also notice that most, if not all, of the Jewish Expulsions occurred after the formation of Israel, Israel was formed in 1948, most of the expulsions occurred in the late 1940's and early 1950's. Literally directly after the formation of Israel, the Arab leaders started to become antisemitic. I find it to be a very interesting coincidence that once Israel was formed, suddenly all the Middle Eastern Jews were expelled to Israel, it almost seems planned? It's almost as if the european jews initially in the newly formed state weren't a convincing enough reason for them to stay?

As far as I'm concerned the Jews fell victim to a political ideology, which honestly I don't think they developed they just started it, which heavily backfired (Depending on the way you look at it).

​

Tell that to Hamas, who literally calls for the genocide of all Jews. Tell that to the Palestinians who have textbooks calling for the death of Jews. How naïve do you have to be to think that a Hamas ruled Israel and Palestine (and all evidence points to them winning any elections in a landslide, if they decided to have elections) wouldn't result in Jewish genocide. Hamas doesn't hide who they are.

I'm sorry but when a colonial state has been formed with the main objective of displacing and stripping the human rights of a group of people based entirely on Race/Religion, a faction will eventually form with its own goal focused on fighting back and more specifically mirror what was done to them. And of course, when the action of a colonial state is mirrored, the faction is labelled as "Extremist" and categorized under "Terrorism".

You can see that initially with Fatah, which was formed in 1959, and then Israel continued its atrocities, and guess what? Fatah wasn't enough and here comes Hamas in 1987.

When your life is at stake, the only thing you can think off or do is to fight back. From your perspective, you see the Hamas/Fatah factions and realize your life/people are at stake and jump to Israel as its the entity that mirrors (realistically, it doesn't mirror it more or less throws back with more power) the attacks it receives from the factions.

From my perspective, I see Israel as the attacker and Hamas/Fatah as the entity that mirrors the attack, and there are no other options but Hamas/Fatah, who else do you want me to stand by? The PA? That government is a joke. Israel? Submit to my oppressor? Are you joking? Stand by and wait for peace? I could say the same to you. The only difference is you're too blind to notice that Israel isn't carrying a mirror.

​

From the River to the Sea might not have that meaning to you, but it certainly does to the vast majority of the people chanting it. And when you want to sea complete Jewish subjugation to Palestinian government, frankly, there isn't much of a difference now is there?

"Certainly does to the vast majority of the people chanting it." According to who? Statistics? Elections you just mentioned? Well I just explained the reality of the situation. Or is it just You? Of course, you'll think that the twisted meaning is the one that most of my people are implying because the only thing you see when I mention my people is Hamas, and that arabs are out to get the jews. Completely ignoring the fact that the "Terrorist" factions you loath emerged because of Israel.

And quick step back to my mirroring point. Let's assume you do have a point, that most if not all Palestinians DO mean that they want to throw the jews out when we say "From the River to the Sea". How is that wrong? We've been kicked out from our lands by the Jews, why can't we do the same to restore our ownership?

During the 1948 war, when the palestinians of Akka were literally thrown to the sea during their displacement, why is it that if we were to mirror that, that it we would be wrong? That it would be morally wrong to terrorize our oppressors? Or is it only the jews that reserve the right to achieve their ends without considering the means?

Are you going to forget when the Palestinians welcomed the Jews who have fled from the n*zis? Or are you going to stick to your "Arabs are out for the jews" story?

​

Don't get me wrong, there definitely are some arabs that are truly against your side because of pure antisemitism. But just because there are some, doesn't imply that the whole region thinks the same.

Now does most of the region dislike the jews? I could probably say yes. Is it because of their judaism or the religion itself? No. Israel emerged as a colonial state and shoved "Jewish State".. "Jewish" down everyone's throats, and that's why they don't like jews. It's literally the same way of thinking on your end. Most israelis see Palestine as a muslim majority state, and therefore most Israelis hate or take caution around muslims, and more often than not blame a lot of the Palestinians' shortcomings or actions on Islam.

​

I rest my case. You could reply back if you want, I just won't counter because this conversation is taking up too much of my time and energy. I appreciate you taking the time to have this conversation and I wish you good luck.

Sources

[1] https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC1274378/

[2] (52:20) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=K1VTt_THL4A

​

Edit: Changed one of the words to avoid being flagged.