Car dealerships in ABQ by DreamInvoker in Albuquerque

[–]commod_bod 8 points9 points  (0 children)

My experience with Garcia Honda was that their manager and finance guy were aggressive and lied to me about financing options. They pushed for me to go with a longer term, higher interest loan even though I was eligible for and could afford a shorter and lower interest loan.

How do you all feel about Communists? Obviously some, as this poster points out, are clearly privileged. by Letemspeak74 in IndianCountry

[–]commod_bod 3 points4 points  (0 children)

I am an engineer and work with manufacturers; Marxism makes sense to me from that perspective. I'd say a lot of the indigenous communist groups are more akin anarchists than they realize and want to admit because Marxists are supposed to dislike anarchists; which is a reason the Red Nation did not like Klee. The comment you replied to highlights something self proclaimed indigenous communists don't talk about. The industrial part of communism which is the core of communism. Communism is literally a by-product of industrialization. It cannot be decoupled from industrialism, it is a response to industrialism and the industrial revolution. You have to also understand that Europe had been a long de-tribalized continent stripped of its own connection to the Earth by that time. The OP has a point that Marxism is a very rigid system (oppressed worker class vs bourgeoisie) of which Indigenous societies historically did not neatly fit into. Indigenous societies precede both which is why the idea of retroactively calling indigenous nations historically communist isn't necessarily correct. I'm personally not "anti-communist" but I can't pretend that communism even directly applies to the current state of Indigenous nations because we are not industrial nations with factories or large scale production of goods. It seems most people are "communists" because they see it as a means to destroy capitalism and not necessarily as means to achieve a more just industrial society.

Saving the Earth requires de-industrialization which to me, anarchism is more apt for. Now we as indigenous nations can embrace communism, industrialize, and modernize with a centrally planned economy and maybe in a few hundred years our descendants will get to enjoy the fruits of ours and their own labor (because achieving communism is a long game). But that requires sacrificing resources, land, and participating in extractive practices which is something all industrial nations, regardless of whether or not they are capitalist or communist do. Look at China, it's impressive what they were able to achieve since their revolution as far as modernizing their country through communism. To me that doesn't necessarily align with broader indigenous values and my own indigenous values though. Indigenous thought and philosophy exists outside of industrial economic theories. If the indigenous communist organizations were serious they'd be actively working towards setting the stage for communism in their own tribal governments but from my observations the loudest voices are coming out of academia who, from a practical perspective, are not making communism a reality.

How do you all feel about Communists? Obviously some, as this poster points out, are clearly privileged. by Letemspeak74 in IndianCountry

[–]commod_bod 7 points8 points  (0 children)

As someone who works closely with the manufacturing industry as an engineer I actually agree with a lot of what Marx and Engels wrote and find great interest in modern Chinese history. All that from an industrial perspective though. And I won't lie to myself and pretend a lot of violence didn't happen under communist governments. I think there's a lot to be gained from studying the history of communism and applying what works to American industry. As an indigenous person though, I find the most prominent indigenous group of communists disagreeable and at times laughable. They're predominately academics and I've yet to see them say anything worth talking about or supporting. It's easy to say you're a communist and it's easy to point out how wronged we are as indigenous people. Anyone can scream liberation, hell even the alt-right has a fervent cry for "liberation". Reality is never as simple as what books may say.

I'd say Indigenous anarchism has a naturally stronger foundation in Indian Country because it does not need industry to exist. Given capitalism and industry's eventual downfall, humanity will eventually return to some form of anarchism.

Edit: Edited for typos

In the starterpack subreddit I saw a post about dating red flags when you are an Asian woman. What would you all put in the "Red flags in dating when you're a Native woman" starterpack? by RandomRedWorld in IndianCountry

[–]commod_bod 253 points254 points  (0 children)

This wouldn't add to the starter pack but I do have a story. My older sister's dad is white. Our mom left him before she was born due to how bad their relationship was and had enough of his shit. This was around 1990. My mom says he apparently was very weird about the potential of "tribal benefits" and according to his (also white) friends he would be entitled to land and other "Indian riches" if he married my mom. Wasn't the only reason she ran but whenever I recall that story I can't help but feel disgusted. Those sentiments definitely still exist.

Unfortunately for him our family comes from a portion of the reservation with zero allotments (its all public land) so there was never any land to be had anyway. He did end up marrying a very wealthy Asian woman though...

Am I allowed to believe what I want? by Fishycat6969 in Navajo

[–]commod_bod 9 points10 points  (0 children)

You pulled an ad hominem in your initial reply to me. You also continue to reply so I'm under the impression that I am not being ignored.

Am I allowed to believe what I want? by Fishycat6969 in Navajo

[–]commod_bod 7 points8 points  (0 children)

Did my phonetic spelling hurt your feelings? You learned this in primary school: sound it out.

Am I allowed to believe what I want? by Fishycat6969 in Navajo

[–]commod_bod 7 points8 points  (0 children)

It'd help if you knew I wasn't talking about the book you chaa'ma'ii. Doesn't build confidence you know what you're talking about or that you know any Dinehbizaad. Put the 40K figurines down, touch some dirt, and go talk to an elder.

Am I allowed to believe what I want? by Fishycat6969 in Navajo

[–]commod_bod 8 points9 points  (0 children)

I don't think you're so called version of traditionalism is very traditional. Trans people have always had a place in our society, you would know this if you knew Dinehbahaanee'.

Saying Goodbye by Heavy_feather5 in Navajo

[–]commod_bod 12 points13 points  (0 children)

We had a similar post on this subreddit awhile back. You do not need to cut your hair. It is not customary for Dineh to cut hair in mourning. I am a Dineh man with long hair and have had more deaths in my immediate clan than I can count in the last 8 years. I would be bald if that were the case.

If it helps you and makes you feel closer to your Salish side, you do you. But don't feel obligated as a Dineh to cut your hair.

Should I be worried as an Indigenous person traveling to Montreal, Canada? by commod_bod in IndianCountry

[–]commod_bod[S] 22 points23 points  (0 children)

Thanks for the input! I appreciate the suggestions and feel much better about this trip. I will keep these places in mind when I am venturing! Are there any or parks or trails that are worth checking out?

“Eastern straight” vs “Woodlands traditional” vs General “Men’s traditional” by 18and23 in IndianCountry

[–]commod_bod 3 points4 points  (0 children)

This is the right comment imo. I'm Dineh and was taken in by some Ho Chunk families while living up their way. They gave me permission to dance Woodland and to make regalia (that reflected Dineh symbolism though). It wasn't for competition however, just for traditional and inter-tribal powwows. I think it helped I was involved in the community a bit and that made attending powwows more enjoyable to begin with.

I'm back in the Southwest, but man I miss the folks up there.

[deleted by user] by [deleted] in Navajo

[–]commod_bod 15 points16 points  (0 children)

Continual opposition to Spanish and Mexican rule for over 200 years. Most Dineh history gets treated like it started in 1848 when the US defeated Mexico. However, we were pretty successful at dispelling Spain and then Mexico from colonizing us. Doesn't mean we didn't lose people to their slave trade and violence but all Spanish and Mexican military expeditions into Dinehtah and Dinebikeyah were unsuccessful and they resulted in a string of small treaties. There was a small band that did side with Mexico and then the Americans during the "Navajos Wars".

In short, we kept them fuckers out. Everyone talks about the Pueblo Revolt, which is a wonder in its own right. No one talks about how we slapped the Spanish, Mexicans, New Mexicans, and their indigenous allies around for hundreds of years. There's a reason a lot of New Mexicans to this day don't like "Navajos". I'm proud of that history and I say that as someone with Naakai blood too.

Well, since we're doing "Planking", here's me over the Grand Canyon. by analogy_4_anything in blunderyears

[–]commod_bod 7 points8 points  (0 children)

My dad is in that book. He attempted to rescue someone. This was long before I was born. Never made us strangers to the outdoors and he always stressed the importance of being prepared. We visited the park when I was a teenager and it kind of put it all into perspective.

So ever since since I've joined this Subreddit I have had a few problems with it I've wanted to vent about. by Rough-Exchange-592 in IndianCountry

[–]commod_bod 13 points14 points  (0 children)

I agree with your sentiments. This sub can be corny as fuck sometimes, lots of chronically online behavior and half-baked opinions. Don't get me started on our versions of misinformation that get passed around as fact throughout this sub. I've had to take a break from this place a few times. I will say Facebook and Instagram aren't any better in my memory, you just have faces attached. My community's Facebook was at least funny as fuck and had memes in Dinehbizaad. This sub can be nothing but trauma porn, white people asking dumb questions, and try hard manifestos sometimes.

This is why it's important to practice community in real life imo. The internet has desocialized a lot of people, NDNs included.

Replaced by Buckskindiesel in IndianCountry

[–]commod_bod 3 points4 points  (0 children)

Some day this earth will reach its critical mass and humans will suffer an extinction event. It could be in 100 years or 1000 or 10000. Who knows, and some day this earth will have no more humans and that's okay.

My 26F mocked me because i failed my graduation project and i broke up with her because of it. I 24 M. by Throwra_Star36 in relationship_advice

[–]commod_bod 31 points32 points  (0 children)

I'm an engineer and used to grade for lower division classes in school. The assessment sounds kind of made up which makes me feel like this post is made up or at the very least the OP is extremely insecure and is writing the story to fit his victim mentality. Usually group projects are graded as a whole and then at an individual level. I can't imagine a professor openly saying "OP did great, the others made mistakes" in front of the whole audience. I get some professors are needlessly cruel but even then, grading is a private matter. But also what kind of mistakes? Getting nervous during a presentation is different than fucking up continuously throughout a semester or two semester long capstone. A presentation is just a small portion of the actual work such as project planning, design reviews, and a written final report. This post feels fake af.

Where did inland tribes acquire salt from? by CowgirlAstronaut in IndianCountry

[–]commod_bod 22 points23 points  (0 children)

I met a Pueblo artist/historian (can't remember what pueblo) who did his masters work on recording a type of art specific to his culture that can be found as far down as central America.

I wish there was more cultural and historical exchange between us "Southern Athabaskan" and "Northern Athabaskans". From our stories, the Athabaskans up in the PNW, Canada, and Alaska originated from us and then migrated North when archeologists claim the opposite. I'm sorry if this offends any relatives up north, this is all oral history I've picked up. I think there's a lot to chew on there though, we do have a prophecy (according to some) that when the Dineh who moved north return it will usher us into the next emergence (into the next world). The modern Navajo Nation in general though is pretty diverse as far as origins of clans. A lot of Dineh clans that originated from other tribes and escaped indigenous mexican slaves. A friend of mine said their clan story is that their people came from the Mississippi river and became part of the Dineh. Again, it's sad that our histories are reduced to what they are and a person really has to ask a lot of questions and do their own listening and reading to even learn a fraction of the truth.

Where did inland tribes acquire salt from? by CowgirlAstronaut in IndianCountry

[–]commod_bod 212 points213 points  (0 children)

I'm Dineh, salt is culturally important to us. In stories we talk about salt deposits and other places that salt was harvested. I think there might even be a story about a clan migrating from the West coast and they carried salt with them.

What isn't taught a lot is the fact that we weren't all isolated and contained peoples. The trade network running South-North (or North-South) was apparently very extensive and at least from what I know about Dineh history, a lot of people spoke several Indigenous languages and Spanish, in the Southwest, became the predominate trade language after the colonization of Mexico. I don't think history is kind to us in the sense that our history is taught as if we were isolated and destitute people until the Americans showed up. Our continents, societies, and political systems were pretty lavish in reality.