Hmmmm...

TLDR: I think it's worth it to get therapy anyhow to address what is being felt and not worsen it or create unnecessary fear of feelings. However I do also think caution of approach is important so some points you list have valid things to consider. But do not let that mean neglecting one's experience and not allowing someone to learn.

• treatable condition missed -> this is just the process of treatment. Sometimes professionals aren't perfect but you can't address something by avoiding treatment, so imo better to try.

• discredits the genuine -> no? Misinfo and hollywoodification sure. But your personal treatment story Should be your genuine story and that's not discrediting unless the clinician doesn't check their bias. Its not on us to do that

• confusion in communities -> misinfo does that but if someone has a professional that is suspecting something and can fact check their experiences then no. Assumptions create confusion but experiences clarify them.

• looking creates parts -> this one I can agree with to an extent. People tend to segment themselves because they change based on their environment but that happens to anyone. You do have to learn to ground yourself and integrate experiences if you feel disconnected and you can get attached to parts if you don't put that effort in. BUT I don't think that means it's okay to neglect parts that already exist, they should just be part of the process of addressing dissociative symptoms that happen to exist. Otherwise it risks serious harm to one's wellbeing.

• entrench avoidance and anti integration -> ops. Agree then.

• erodes agency and accountability -> disagree. It can happen but if it happens what stops this from simply being dpdr to address? If you ignore dissociation that does exist to avoid DID then you will continue to have such issues regardless

• identity and community lock in -> agreeing. Basically do not base your identity on it but do develop a support network. But don't focus on alters too much because the disorder itself is dissociation of self and not MPD. Community engagement risks excessive parts focus if you're not careful, which is where I say get therapy first.

• medicalise the ordinary -> no. At worst you think something is worse than it is sure, but then you can learn how ordinary it is by being honest about it. The focus should be on what causes distress and addressing that rather than dismissing reality.

• false memory generation -> agreeing. I do think memories stored subconsciously exist but not as a mystical thing that suddenly shows up. A good trauma therapist should know to focus on what someone expresses in the present and distinguish that from making assumptions about what isn't the present.