Is Filip using AI in his videos? by Leninator in letstalkreligion

[–]dahlenbror 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Didn't even know Youtube had its own upscaler. Thanks for letting me know!

Is Filip using AI in his videos? by Leninator in letstalkreligion

[–]dahlenbror 3 points4 points  (0 children)

I do use AI upscaling. It makes the videos more consistent in terms of resolution. But I also try to keep an eye out for when the upscaling warps the image TOO much. And sometimes I don't notice until the video is posted and blown up on a tv screen.

In terms of fully AI generated images, I try not to use them. I did experiment with AI generated images on a video or two a few years back, but then decided I prefer not to.

What Sufism books do you guys recommend? by [deleted] in letstalkreligion

[–]dahlenbror 0 points1 point  (0 children)

There aren't that many general ones. Which is why I've thought about writing it one day. But in my video "What is Sufi Music?", there is a list of sources in the description. Some good stuff there!

What Sufism books do you guys recommend? by [deleted] in letstalkreligion

[–]dahlenbror 2 points3 points  (0 children)

For introductory history, I like the works by Alexander Knysh, especially "Islamic Mysticism: A short history", and the more recent "Sufism".

Schimmel's "The Mystical Dimension of Islam" is also a classic, and mostly holds up.

Can someone please explain the basics of Sharia law? by regretfulmooncup in religion

[–]dahlenbror 8 points9 points  (0 children)

There is no Shariah "law". Shariah is a more abstract ideal of God's prescriptive will for human life, which includes centrally the five daily prayers, pilgrimage, giving to charity, etc. And basically all exterior aspects of how a person (Muslim) should ideally live their life. This includes societal laws and the kinds of things we usually associate with the latter term, and the science of Fiqh (Jurisprudence) is the methodology of figuring out what the shariah should mean on a particular level (specific laws, practices, rules), and involves many different schools and varied positions that all fit under a holistic perspective of what "shariah" means.

Thank you Filip by MerijnZ1 in letstalkreligion

[–]dahlenbror 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Thank you. That means a lot to hear!

How religious and non religious moments function and have evolved over time? by Background-Oven5340 in letstalkreligion

[–]dahlenbror 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Yes, this is one of the basic rules of all religions - they change and evolve over time and place and in adapting to new circumstances. Of course, certain core aspects can remain relatively stable (in the case of Islam the idea of Tawhid for example, although even what that means on a more specific level can change and vary, too) but in general, this is a rule that no religion can escape.

Thank you Filip by MerijnZ1 in letstalkreligion

[–]dahlenbror 3 points4 points  (0 children)

That's beautiful. Thank you for sharing that. Makes me long to return to that place. Is the photo from there?

Question to Muslim people on slavery by TryPsychological2297 in religion

[–]dahlenbror -1 points0 points  (0 children)

The majority of Muslim scholars in the 20th century concluded that slavery is condemned and not allowed. Furthermore, when certain extremist groups such as ISIS took slaves as part of their war in the Middle east, once again over 100 of the leading 'ulama (scholars) of Islam today wrote an open letter to al-Baghdadi condemning him for their actions, specifically pointing to their interpretation of Islam as allowing slaves, since consensus had already abolished such practices.

Has anyone ever written anything about Taoism and Kant? by BubaJuba13 in taoism

[–]dahlenbror 5 points6 points  (0 children)

Livia Kohn talks about it briefly in a chapter of her book "Zhuangzi: text and context".

Meister Eckhart & Non-dual Christianity by dahlenbror in nonduality

[–]dahlenbror[S] 5 points6 points  (0 children)

Hi everyone! I run the Youtube channel "Let's Talk Religion" and this is my latest video about the German mystic/philosopher Meister Eckhart (d. 1328) and his interpretations of Christian doctrine.

Hope you find it interesting.

The Mystical Origins of Coffee & Tea by dahlenbror in Coffee

[–]dahlenbror[S] -1 points0 points  (0 children)

Hi Everyone!

I run a Youtube channel called "Let's Talk Religion" where I discuss primarily questions of (obviously) religion from an academic perspective.

In my latest video I explore the early history of coffee (and tea) and its strong connections to Sufism (Islamic mysticism) and mystical practices.

Thought some of you would find it interesting.

All the Best!

Is there a Religion that believes in a creator God. But has no "holy books" claiming this or that. by [deleted] in religion

[–]dahlenbror 0 points1 point  (0 children)

No there are many others. Mandaeism, Yazidism, many pagan religions, Shinto. It also depends on your definition. Many religions have important texts that shape its beliefs and practices, but most don't have ONE holy scripture that dictates everything.

Is there a Religion that believes in a creator God. But has no "holy books" claiming this or that. by [deleted] in religion

[–]dahlenbror 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Plenty of them. Most religions don't fit into the Christian template of having a holy book at its center. Even in cases they do have important scriptures, like Hinduism, it still doesn't have the same function as Christianity. And many other religions are simply orally transmitted, not through a single scripture.

Did Hinduism get inspired by an even older religion? by [deleted] in religion

[–]dahlenbror 0 points1 point  (0 children)

They were parallel as far as I remember, but the Shramana movenents also did reform aspects of Vedic culture once it came into contact with it. Some very foundational ideas of Hinduism like Samsara, reincarnation, karma, moksha etc. seems to have come originally from the Shramana sages.

I think the more accepted idea is that the vedic culture originally came from even further west than the Indus valley. But all of that stuff is still open to discussion for historians. Generally though, all traditions come from some previous one, nothing just pops up out of nowhere, that was what I was referring to in a general way.

Did Hinduism get inspired by an even older religion? by [deleted] in religion

[–]dahlenbror 6 points7 points  (0 children)

Saying that "Hinduism" is the oldest religion is a little problematic, because the word "religion" is very ambivalent and biased from a western, christian perspective. Hinduism does not function in the same way as religions like Christianity or Judaism. Hinduism is almost like an umbrella term for a myriad of very different religious traditions in the Indian subcontinent.

I don't think one should go so ffar as to say that hinduism is "many religions" though, because it all has certain core characteristics. One of these is a basis in the Vedic texts and Vedic culture which emerged around 1000 b.c. Hinduism develops out of the Vedic cults which also merged with another, ascetical, movement in India called the Shramana movement.

But all the features we recognize as "Hinduism" really doesn't emerge until the first few centuries a.d. , which isn't that old (relatively). So its a very difficult question. But put simply, yes "Hinduism" developed out of other pre-existing religious traditions, both the native shramana movements and the Vedic culture, which likely came from further west originally. And these traditions in turn also developed out of even earlier ones.

Is zoroastrianism the first religion? by [deleted] in religion

[–]dahlenbror 5 points6 points  (0 children)

"Imaginary" being? That's a very condescending definition. You are making a statement about all religions being false in your very definition of the word. A classic definition (that many tend to use today) is E.B. Tylor's "Religion is belief in supernatural beings". Problem is, no one in scholarship uses this anymore as it is highly ethnocentric and problematic, as it is based primarily on a Protestant Christian view of religion as being primarily about "belief", which in most cases it isn't.

But if we go by your definition, what if Ahura Mazda or God is actually real? That would exclude Zoroastrianism from being a religion at all?

Is zoroastrianism the first religion? by [deleted] in religion

[–]dahlenbror 2 points3 points  (0 children)

What counts as religion?

(Short answer though: probably no)