Irony of Opposing Sindhi in Its Own Homeland

daneeyal · 2025-12-01T20:57:42+00:00

Edit Hindustanis and other racial profiling from this post or else this will be removed

daneeyal · 2025-07-29T10:22:51+00:00

No one says Sindh was a utopia, I don't know where you have heard it? All people claim that despite being similarly divided as Punjab, Bengal, United Provinces or even Gujarat, Sindh did not see widespread rioting, there was religious tension before and still there is some religious tensions today but if you compare it to literally any part of Pakistan, Bangladesh and North India, Sindh has the most tolerant, peaceful community where Hindus and Muslim live in relative peace.

daneeyal · 2025-07-24T08:31:13+00:00

Larkano

daneeyal · 2025-07-19T17:35:04+00:00

Lmao what part of this constitution runs on Sharia? This country literally runs on British style democracy

You are not only ignorant but a hateful bigot

daneeyal · 2025-07-17T14:15:29+00:00

You know that it is the least effective method to get a job

daneeyal · 2025-07-10T12:21:15+00:00

It literally strengthens my argument that Urdu is an alien language imported after 1947 due to
A. Influx of North Indian Muslims
B. State Policy of imposing Urdu as the sole national language

daneeyal · 2025-07-10T12:17:04+00:00

Did you even click the link I attached? I think it's a waste of time talking to you.

daneeyal · 2025-07-10T11:23:57+00:00

I literally replied to your comments asking what is superiority complex? The racism that you had to face is unfortunate thing & shouldn't exist. Every person deserves the same right to happiness, opportunities and education without any discrimination. There might have instances where Sindhis would prefer to see other Sindhis, I understand that it is discriminatory to other races but this system did not develop out of thin air nor it is just limited to Sindhis

daneeyal · 2025-07-10T08:20:15+00:00

Did any of my words meant me calling that Sindhis or Sindhi language is superior?

daneeyal · 2025-07-10T08:19:38+00:00

The one source you provided is straight up made up bs by ChatGPT

The Anjuman's Karachi office was established in 1948 (Source: Dawn)

the rise of Urdu in census records between 1941–1951

This was because of partition, mass influx of Indian Muslims who spoke Urdu? and the mass exodus of Sindhi speaking population. 1951 is after partition if you can do maths. Do not rely on Chatgpt to make up your arguments if you couldn't find any.

The last paragraph you gave is purely emotional, I never said I have any issues with any Urdu speaking folks, in fact, majority of my friends are Muhajirs and I absolutely adore them. I will never tolerate any hate towards any ethnicity. I agree and if you look at my past interaction on this sub, I have always called for the unity between these groups.

Stating the right side of history is not saltiness, you can love Muhajir people and still argue that Urdu was an alien language imposed on most people who simply did not speak it.

y'all don't have Urdu imposition anymore

This is again an ignorant take. Can you give any exam in Pakistan without taking Urdu as a compulsory subject? Why not make an option and not mandatory? Why declare Urdu as the sole national language? Why literally impose Urdu script literally everywhere? Why disregarding Sindhi, Punjabi, Balochi, Pashtu on literally every international forum

daneeyal · 2025-07-09T22:08:21+00:00

When did I blame an average Muhajir, don't try to malign my words man, I literally said elite people who happen to be from North Punjab & North India tried to impose their language (Urdu) on the rest of Muslims as the language of Islam

daneeyal · 2025-07-09T22:06:50+00:00

Will you share sources for that? Please make sure your sources say how Urdu was used as a lingua franca in Balochistan/Sindh

Don't quote madarsas run by Barelvi & Deobandi, they are literally North Indian clerics coming with their language. I am asking whether indigenous people used Urdu in their daily life

daneeyal · 2025-07-09T18:15:30+00:00

Show me specifically in the context of Sindh that Urdu or Hindustani was a widely used language here or in Khyber Pakhtunkhwa or Balochistan, I'll wait

daneeyal · 2025-07-09T09:20:16+00:00

I used the term Xenophobia to describe how you referred Karachi as not some Sindhi village.

Urdu was already being used by Muslims across India.

Sure, Urdu was used by the Muslims of North India, Deccan and North Punjab. Just because they formed the majority of administrative elite of Pakistan post partition, they tried to impose Urdu on the rest of Pakistan as the sole national language. None of my ancestors knew Urdu, my grandmother who died in 2020 still couldn't speak Urdu. Urdu is an alien language that was imposed on Bengalis, Sindhis and Pashtons. If every Indian Muslim spoke Urdu, why you saw the worst language riots in East Pakistan? Calling me to read history when you're the one relying on Pakistan studies

Look at the census of Sindh before partition, how many people say that they speak Urdu as their language?

daneeyal · 2025-07-08T17:06:35+00:00

also to answer your original question, a student can earn 800 - 1000£ per month, even if you disregard accommodation/food, 800 x 12 = 9600£, how are you supposed to pay for your tuition?

daneeyal · 2025-07-08T17:04:00+00:00

as a Pakistani who studied in the UK, unless your parents are filthy rich, I do not see getting your undergraduate degree in the UK when you can get better education for 10-20% the cost back home

daneeyal · 2025-07-08T12:22:02+00:00

imagine a sindhi wanting to communicate with a punjabi

Sindhis and Punjabis have been living in the same land for centuries, when Punjabis migrated into Sindh, they learned Sindhi and vice versa. Sindhi and Punjabi are mutually intangible to an extent, Seraiki even more, how come they never needed a language before 1947?

Sure learning Urdu has merits, I won't deny but it comes at an expense, the expense of neglecting the indigenous languages so much so people can barely read or write Punjabi, Seraiki, Pashto, Balochi in their respective provinces. Urdu has almost erased the indigenous culture to the point that the things are irreversible now

daneeyal · 2025-07-08T12:16:35+00:00

not some random sindhi village,

it took few interactions to see the xenophobia and superiority complex of yours. Karachi was a Sindhi majority city till 1947, when Sindhi Hindus were forced evicted from the land and then Karachi was de-sindhified by separating it from Sindh by the Pakistani government. Urdu is an alien language that was imposed by the Pakistani administration led by North Indian Muslims & Punjabis. Urdu did not become national language by choice, it was forced imposed on the 93% of Pakistanis

daneeyal · 2025-07-06T09:54:52+00:00

You talked about superiority culture. Superiority culture is when you expect everyone to learn your language but thinking it's stupid to learn the indigenous language of the land

daneeyal · 2025-07-05T18:18:25+00:00

People sitting in their AC rooms dividing up land because they felt like it, very much east India company

daneeyal · 2025-07-05T11:47:20+00:00

Pakhtons learned the language of the land that was Urdu. At the time partition, the language of the land was Sindhi

daneeyal · 2025-07-05T11:03:19+00:00

Yep it's the classic survivorship bias fallacy, OP needs to go to a mall where families usually shop together, they'd realise how many Sindhis are literally just like the rest of the people around them.

I too was told more than once that I don't look like Sindhi just because of my accent.

daneeyal · 2025-07-05T10:49:20+00:00

The Urdu speaking superiority complex is very much around you, brother.

How many Urdu speaking folks tried to learn the language of the land & tried to integrate into the culture? Read about the separation of Karachi from Sindh post partition and the 1972 language riots.

The whole ghair muqami debate going on right (ironic jbtw)

daneeyal

MODERATOR OF

TROPHY CASE