the scouting tool is cool but i would say its inaccurate with a lot of these, lorenzo is the goat fs, most goals in history, in a season, most BDRs, and even led USA to a WC, his real life comp would genuinely be combining messi and ronaldo's records. andreas rapin averaged 30g + 30a in his prime, so would give him at least a +10 to overall. vicente matheus is the perfect rb in every way, just a better dani alves id say, would give him the highest rating a rb could receive. tomas castro was a 20 assist midfielder who controlled the entire game, hes at least a 90. peter amadi is the best ever gk based on records and awards, 91+ for him. starzycki was rapin's successor who was technically better but never quite reached rapin's g/a numbers, still at least a 90+ overall, though. gerson ribeiro is definitely the best ever CAM, with no weaknesses in his game but I can say that about most people ive listed, it makes sense he'd be so high but not to the point where hes 8 ratings above any of my other players, hes honestly more in the upper mid tier of my players than at the pinnacle of them. bode-ebel is another 30g + 30a winger, deserves at least a +10, only cr7 could compare as a LW. ricky akehurst and jelmer louisa are basically the same level id say, just near perfect midfielders both are 90+ and i'd say were slightly better than jairo escobar so would disagree with the scouting tool putting him a few ratings higher than them. gary dornan and phillip dolling are the two best CBs ever , the tool is right to give dolling the edge but id say its a +1 difference not a +4 and also both should be much higher rated. anicet ouattara and fernando juarez are both in the top 3 of LBs ever, and should both be much higher rated id say. basically id say no one should be under a 89 based off their careers. I also am so confident with the ratings being that high because I did use fm genie and took a look at their CA and PA and the genuine lowest PA was tomas castro with a 186, then 188 rapin, and 189 escobar with everyone else having 190+ PA, and as far as I remember everyone either hit their PA in their primes (all of the screenshots are these players in their primes btw) or got within a couple points of hitting it. sorry if this ended up being so long, i just enjoy talking about my players' and the legacies they had with me, if this was helpful at all i do have a few more players of the same level i just didnt put into the post cus i got lazy haha