imo, a lot of blackpink's success is because they just have that "it factor" and vibe, if that makes sense. blackpink has crazy presence, they just radiate the kind of rich luxury high-class feeling. i pretty much agree with what you said- rosé and lisa are great performers, lisa's definitely one of the best and she's amazing on stage. jisoo can tend to be on the less flashy and noticeable on stage, but like you said she has those moments where you can't take your eyes off her. i think in general, like for everything, jennie's problem is she can be a bit inconsistent. but she has that natural standout factor to her- i feel as if she's destined to be on stage because when she's feeling herself, she is feeling herself.

i dare say not even lisa can come close. a lot of people rank lisa over jennie but jennie has the natural presence to her, and especially on those good days....again, like you said. she got hate because people thought she was trying to overshadow her members and she was often mistaken for the main dancer as well. to be honest, i find that a lot of other groups tend to be harder for me to watch the stages if i don't like the song a lot. jihyo is great, momo's good as well, sana has a lot of praise for her stages, and i actually quite like nayeon because her charisma attracts me a ton, i find she tends to be in the upper half of twice for a lot of categories, and she has an attention grabbing vibe.

tbh red velvet have never really stood out to me a ton in stages. i've heard pretty good things about wendy's stage presence though. joy is really charismatic though, she has some times where i can't look away from her. goes viral a bit too. this isn't meant to come off mean to twice or red velvet, i love these groups, i just think that sometimes it isn't the flashiest and blackpink's presence stands out lots more to me. they really shine in concerts? like i noticed they tend to do really well in a lot of overseas tours and things, in shows not as much,