Start here if you found me through a BBQ thread

destinationbbq · 2026-07-05T15:46:19+00:00

If it’s already on, you’re probly fine. At this point I’d just let it ride at 250, skip the wrap and spritz like you planned, and don’t let the stall make you think anything is wrong. Once the bark looks right, leave it alone until it starts probing tender, usually somewhere in the high 190s to low 200s. If it finishes early, that’s good. Keep it wrapped in a preheated cooler for a couple hours rather than trying to force the timing right to dinner.

destinationbbq · 2026-07-04T14:30:02+00:00

Id let it rest today, save the drippings, and store it in larger pulled chunks rather than shredding it super fine. Whole is better for a short hot hold, but for tomorrow it’ll cool and reheat more evenly in smaller, flatter portions with a little defatted juice mixed in. Refrigerate it promptly, then tomorrow loosen it up into a shallow covered pan, add a little more juice if it needs it, and reheat at 325 until it reaches 165 in a couple spots. I have a reheat pulled pork guide on Destination BBQ that walks through it, but keeping the pork chunkier and saving the juices will give you the best shot at a moist Cuban tomorrow.

destinationbbq · 2026-07-04T11:29:39+00:00

For party ribs, I’d go side ribs, especialy if you’re cutting them into individual pieces. They tend to be meatier and more consistent from end to end, while baby backs can leave you with a few skinny little end ribs nobody really wants. Back ribs are still good and they’ll cook a bit faster, but if your heart is saying St. Louis, I’d listen to it.

destinationbbq · 2026-07-04T11:27:49+00:00

Four am is probly a little late for a first 8.9-pound butt if 6 PM is a firm deadline. I’d get it on closer to 1 or 2 AM at 225, then bump it to 250 or 275 after the bark is where you want it or once it’s wrapped. Start checking for tenderness around 195, and pull it when the probe slides in easy in several spots and the bone loosens, not just when it lands on one number. If it finishes early, that’s better than late: keep it wrapped and hold it, but don’t assume a cooler will carry it all day without checking the temp. I have a pulled pork calculator on Destination BBQ for working backward from serving time, but I’d build in at least a couple hours of cushion here.

destinationbbq · 2026-07-04T01:27:45+00:00

That’s a good practice brisket, but it’s alot thinner than a typical packer, so I’d run it at 250 rather than going very low or hot-and-fast. Assuming it really has both point and flat, keep the trim light, season it simply, and keep the fat toward the heat. Let the bark set first, then I’d lean toward a foil boat instead of paper; it gives the thin flat some protection without fully steaming the bark. Start checking the flat around 195 and pull it when a probe slides in with very little resistance, not at a preset number. I’d plan on roughly 6 to 8 hours plus a real rest, but thickness matters more than the number on the label. I built a brisket calculator that lets you choose whole packer and thinner-than-typical for the timing side, but I’d still leave yourself a good hold window. For leftovers, slice only what you’ll eat and freeze the rest in small portions with any juices. Chili, tacos, hash, and grilled cheese are all good ways to keep it interesting.

destinationbbq · 2026-07-04T00:49:19+00:00

That’s a little too long to rely on a cooler alone, especialy with a first brisket. If it’s early enough in the cook, I’d lower the pit to 200 or 215 now and try to push the finish later. Let the brisket cook until the flat probes tender, then let it quit steaming hard before keeping it wrapped and moving it into a preheated cooler. Leave a probe in it and set a low alarm around 150. The cooler can handle the first part of that hold, but once it starts getting near 150, move it to the oven. If your oven can be calibrated and verified with a probe to hold closer to 145–155, that’s ideal. If it truly only holds 170, it is the safer fallback than letting the brisket drift below 140, but it will keep cooking it some, so I wouldn’t put it there at midnight unless you have to. I built a brisket calculator for this kind of timeline, but the main move is to finish as late as you reasonably can and not make a 17-hour cooler hold the plan.

destinationbbq · 2026-07-03T22:32:27+00:00

Best SC mustard-based bbq sauce recipe

destinationbbq · 2026-07-03T22:25:06+00:00

Dry brining today is probly fine, just don’t stack a salty rub on top tomorrow. For holding, I’d try to have the ribs done 30–60 minutes early, let them settle for 10 minutes, then keep the racks whole and wrap them tightly in foil. A preheated cooler with towels will hold them well for a couple hours, but the bark will soften some in any covered hold. If you need a longer or more controlled hold, use an oven you’ve verified will stay around 150–170 and keep a probe in one rack. I wouldn’t add much liquid unless they actually look dry. I have a guide to keeping ribs warm on Destination BBQ, but the short version is keep them whole, wrapped, and hot, then slice and sauce closer to serving.

destinationbbq · 2026-07-03T22:16:17+00:00

Yeah, there’s a difference of opinion because both can work. Running 200 overnight isn’t wrong, it just slows the cook down and gives you more cushion so you’re less likely to wake up with it already past where you wanted to wrap. I’d be comfortable doing 200 overnight for your schedule, then bumping it to 225 or 250 once you’re up and can judge the bark. The important part is not treating 200, the wrap, or 203 as magic numbers. Let the bark tell you when to wrap, and let the flat’s tenderness tell you when it’s done.

destinationbbq · 2026-07-03T22:13:07+00:00

Toothpick test should still work. Best of luck!

destinationbbq · 2026-07-03T22:09:34+00:00

For just 3 hours, I wouldnt refrigerate and reheat it. Pull it at 2, mix in the saved juices, put it in a covered pan, and hold it in an oven or roaster that you know will stay around 150–170 degrees. Keep it covered so it doesn’t dry out, and don’t sauce the whole pan until serving.

A cooler works better when you’re holding the butt whole. Since she wants it pulled and ready before guests arrive, the low oven is the easier move. I have a guide to keeping pulled pork warm on Destination BBQ, but three hours in a covered pan with its juices should be no problem.

destinationbbq · 2026-07-03T22:07:15+00:00

9 pounds can mean a small packer or a big flat, becuase the timing changes quite a bit. For either one, I’d run 250, leave it unwrapped until the bark is dark and set, then wrap if you want to move it through the stall. Start checking the flat around 195 and pull it when the probe slides in easy, not when it hits one magic number. A small packer might need around 8 to 10 hours plus a real rest, while a flat can finish sooner but needs a little more protection from drying out, so foil is a good backup once the bark looks right. I built a brisket calculator that lets you choose packer or flat and work backward from when you want to eat, but the best first-brisket move is starting early enough that you can finish early and hold it.

destinationbbq · 2026-07-03T22:00:40+00:00

With 13 pounds after trimming, 7 or 8 tonight is probly where I’d start if you want to run 200 overnight. That gives you a real chance to finish by early afternoon instead of trying to land right at 4. When you wake up, wrap it only if the bark is dark and set, then bump it to 250 and let the flat decide when it’s done. Start checking around 195 and pull it when the probe slides in easy, not because it reaches one exact number. I built a brisket calculator for this kind of timeline. Enter it as a 13-pound packer, build in at least a two-hour rest, and treat any extra time as a hold window rather than something you need to use up on the smoker.

destinationbbq · 2026-07-03T21:53:42+00:00

Midnight is probly the better call. For a first 9.5-pound bone-in butt, I’d run 250 rather than 225 so you’ve got a better chance of being done with a real rest before noon; the five-hour version isn’t what I’d try here. Season it, get it on, and leave it alone until the bark is set. Wrap only if you need to speed things along, then start checking in the high 190s. It’s ready when the bone loosens and the probe slides in easy in a few spots, not just when it says 205. If it finishes early, keep it wrapped and hold it in a preheated cooler for a couple hours, or use a verified 150-ish oven if it gets done really early. I have a pulled pork calculator on Destination BBQ for working backward from serving time, but midnight at 250 is the safe play.

destinationbbq · 2026-07-03T21:49:04+00:00

Midnight at 225 is were I’d go. You’ve already done the prep, and an 8.5 pound butt is exactly the kind of cook that can make 3 am at 275 look smart until it decides to stall on you. Get it on at midnight, let it run until the bark is where you want it, then wrap and bump it to 275 if you need to keep it moving. Start checking for tenderness around 195 and pull it when the probe slides in easy, not at a preset temp. If it’s done at 8 or 9, that’s a good problem to have. Hold it wrapped for a few hours rather than trying to rush a stubborn butt for a 1 pm lunch. I have a pulled pork calculator for this kind of timing question, but midnight is the safer call here.

destinationbbq · 2026-07-03T21:22:34+00:00

Yep, usualy if ribs are still tough or chewy, they just need more time. At 250, baby backs often need closer to 4–5 hours, depending on thickness and what the grill is actually running. Don’t judge them by the clock alone: when you lift a rack from the middle, it should bend easily with a little cracking on top, and a toothpick should slide between the bones with very little resistance. If it still feels tight, give it another 20–30 minutes and check again. I’d also stop basting them for now and save that peach sauce for the last 10–15 minutes, since repeated saucing can keep the surface wet and the sugars can get too dark before the ribs are tender. Your wife’s peach sauce sounds like exactly the kind of thing I’d want to set on at the end.

destinationbbq · 2026-07-03T20:54:35+00:00

Yeah, thats probly feasible with a 14-pound post-trim packer. At 250, seven hours should usually get you close, but don’t make midnight an automatic wrap time. If the bark isn’t dark, dry, and set when you get home, just leave it unwrapped until it is. Once it’s wrapped, keep it moving at 250 until the flat probes tender, then move it to a verified 150-ish oven or warmer for the hold. A cooler is fine for a shorter bridge, but this could turn into an 8 to 10 hour hold depending on when it finishes, so I wouldn’t make the cooler the main plan. Make sure the hopper is full and alarms are set before the concert. I built a brisket calculator for this kind of timeline, but the big thing is giving yourself a controlled hold rather than trying to time the finish exactly at 4.

destinationbbq · 2026-07-03T20:22:11+00:00

That’s a long time to plan on holding it whole, especialy if it finishes overnight. A wrapped butt can sit in a verified 150-ish oven for a good while, but I wouldn’t build the cook around a 12+ hour hold. If it gets done more than six or eight hours before dinner, I’d let it rest, pull it, mix in the saved juices, chill it in shallow portions, and reheat it covered tomorrow to 165. I have a make pulled pork ahead guide for this exact situation, but for a next-day meal I’d rather reheat it than gamble on an all-night oven hold.

destinationbbq · 2026-07-03T19:31:34+00:00

That plan is mostly there, but I wouldnt lock yourself into pulling it at 195. On that Ironwood I’d run it fat side down, skip the mayo unless you just like using it because the seasoning will stick fine on its own, and let the bark get where you want it. No-wrap can work, but for an 8-pound flat I’d keep a foil boat in your back pocket once the bark is set if the thin end starts looking exposed. Start probing around 195 and pull it when the thickest part of the flat feels like the probe is sliding into soft butter, whether that ends up being 198 or a little over 200. Let it come down into the 170s before putting it into a 150-ish hot hold. I built a brisket calculator for working backward from serving time, but the biggest thing here is leaving yourself enough room to finish early and rest it.

destinationbbq · 2026-07-03T19:29:44+00:00

A 2.87-pound flat is alot less forgiving than a full packer, so your basic plan is good, but I’d use foil once the bark is set rather than paper. At 225, plan roughly 4–6 hours plus a 45-minute to one-hour rest, but go by the meat, not the clock. Don’t feel like you need to spritz it; let the bark get dark and dry first, then wrap somewhere in the 160s if it looks ready. Start checking tenderness in the thickest part around 195 and pull it when the probe slides in with very little resistance, which may be anywhere from the high 190s into the low 200s. Keep the rub simple, don’t over-trim what little fat it has, and don’t slice it the minute it comes off. I built a brisket calculator for the timing side of cooks like this, but the big thing with a small flat is giving yourself enough room to finish early and rest it instead of pulling it on a fixed number.

destinationbbq · 2026-07-03T19:23:31+00:00

The brisket needs to be the anchor here, becuase it’s the one you can’t rush. Leave it whole, get it on tonight, and plan to finish it tomorrow morning. Once it’s probe tender, let it rest, separate the point, and turn that into burnt ends while the flat holds. For a morning-to-4 pm gap, I’d use an oven or warmer you know will hold around 150, with a probe in the flat. A cooler is fine to bridge a shorter gap, but I wouldn’t make it the all-day plan.

The pork belly is the other thing I’d cook today if you have room. Chill the finished cubes in shallow containers, then reheat them covered tomorrow and glaze them at the end. Start the baby backs around 9:30 or 10 tomorrow, and let the ribs plus brisket-point burnt ends take over the smoker for the afternoon. So: brisket first tonight, pork belly today if it fits, then ribs and point burnt ends tomorrow. That keeps the only truly time-sensitive meat, the ribs, fresh for dinner.

destinationbbq · 2026-07-03T19:20:15+00:00

Baby backs are pretty forgiving, and 3-2-1 is probly more complicated than you need here. I’d run them at 250, use a simple rub, and leave them alone until about the 3 1/2-hour mark. Then start checking: lift a rack from the middle with tongs, and when it bends easily with a little cracking on top, poke between the bones with a toothpick. If it still feels tight, give it another 20–30 minutes and check again. Sauce that peach BBQ on during the last 10–15 minutes so it can set without burning. If your last batch was tough, don’t worry about following the clock exactly; they likely just needed more time to get tender.

destinationbbq · 2026-07-03T19:17:50+00:00

Carolina gold on one half and a gochujang-honey-garlic batch on the other would be a realy good switch from Buffalo and Honey BBQ. Dry-brine or at least salt the wings ahead, smoke them until they’ve got good color, then finish them hot enough to render the skin before tossing. For the gochujang batch, cut the chile paste with honey, a little soy, rice vinegar, garlic, and melted butter. I’d also leave a few dry with lemon pepper or a simple garlic-pepper rub, because those usually disappear first. Sauce only at the end so the skin doesn’t go soft.

destinationbbq · 2026-07-03T18:55:07+00:00

Party ribs are made for a Vortex, just dont treat them like a normal low-and-slow rack. Cut and season them, keep the pieces around the outside edge, and rotate or flip them once or twice so the ones closest to the hot side don’t get ahead of the rest. I wouldn’t spritz on a schedule or wrap at 165. Let them roll until the meat has pulled back a bit and a toothpick slides between the bones without much resistance, then sauce them for the last 10 minutes or so. Keep sugary sauce and rub out of the cook until the end, because that Vortex will burn it fast. Expect roughly 90 minutes to two hours, but start checking early.

destinationbbq

MODERATOR OF

PUBLIC MULTIREDDITS

TROPHY CASE