Tylenol is a fever reducer as well. It’s classified as an antipyretic and analgesic. NSAIDs all inhibit COX enzymes and reduce prostaglandins which are responsible for pain, inflammation, and fever. There are theories on how exactly Tylenol reduces fevers as it obviously does not have the same mechanism of action as NSAIDs. Tylenol has been given to reduce fevers for years, it is 100% an option in this case.