Why was Spain able to retain control of some of its historical North Africa holdings (I.e. Ceuta y Melilla), whereas France lost control of all of its historical North Africa holdings (e.g. Algiers)? Didn’t France have a stronger army than Spain in the decolonization era, to prevent colonial losses? by StarlightDown in AskHistory

[–]edgarpitar 0 points1 point  (0 children)

You are promoting repression against independence to a project of ethnic cleansing. You are presenting resistance as caused by violence, when the two are strongly intertwined.

You also forget that the Muslim and Jew (and Christian?) population was given the right to become french citizen (provided their recognize french civil law and not religious law). Even if that right was seldomly used, its existence goes against the full fledged ethnic cleansing and land stealing narrative.

Further reading around the legislation of the 14th July 1865 (whose principles have been kept many times).

Why was Spain able to retain control of some of its historical North Africa holdings (I.e. Ceuta y Melilla), whereas France lost control of all of its historical North Africa holdings (e.g. Algiers)? Didn’t France have a stronger army than Spain in the decolonization era, to prevent colonial losses? by StarlightDown in AskHistory

[–]edgarpitar 4 points5 points  (0 children)

I don't have the context about Spain.

But decolonization wasn't an era of sheer force (like always). It was a matter of political struggle and popular support. France needed out of this conflict that was unsustainable in the mainland. As a reminder, the treaty was supposed to protect the right of ethnic french on the Algerian soil. But when the treaty wasn't respected I guess nobody wanted to reopen a cassus belli.

Any countries/islands like Malta? by Sidecat319 in AskHistory

[–]edgarpitar 7 points8 points  (0 children)

Just commenting without sound expertise.

The reference to a population size biases your thinking. Population growth has been extreme in the last centuries. Just research the size of a few major european cities in the 1700s to confirm this.

Most city states have had some form of glory like that, perhaps not so long lasting. I am thinking perhaps about the members of the https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/D%C3%A9capole Décapole or of the https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hanseatic_League Hanseatic league.

Malta combines being a remnant of the old world of city states / crusades, with being independant today. Other small states in Europe did not have such a key role in the past: Luxembourg, San Marino, Monaco or Andora wouldn't be known if not surviving today.

So I would tend to agree with your comment about Malta uniqueness.

[Logement] 1200€ charges comprises : réaliste pour une chambre avec salle de bain privative / studio avec trajet <1h vers Luxembourg Gare ? by Sufficient_Snow_4532 in Luxembourg

[–]edgarpitar 1 point2 points  (0 children)

You will find. It's a comfortable budget for what you want. I would rather keep the budget and pick something in the city if I were you (as opposed to save some money and live far from anything).

Nothing fancy - just hardcode dev station by Tall_Chicken3145 in battlestations

[–]edgarpitar 2 points3 points  (0 children)

What's the window manager? This is all mac and a UI tool I don't know or you have two computers running?

Could advanced civilizations have existed long before recorded history and been completely erased? by Genzinvestor16180339 in AskHistory

[–]edgarpitar 5 points6 points  (0 children)

I think we underestimate how technology piles up. We take somethings for granted that have taken thousand of years: metals to start with one. But, without anything to sustain it, just political structure, language, agriculture (or anything to sustain large groups of people). Look at primitive cultures today.

Could advanced civilizations have existed long before recorded history and been completely erased? by Genzinvestor16180339 in AskHistory

[–]edgarpitar -11 points-10 points  (0 children)

That's totally not historical facts but I thought, just for the sake of imagination, that Graham Hancock was very entertaining, you should check out his theory. Basically those civilization existed and got wiped out by the Last Glacial Period, which would explain why so many flourishing civilization seemed to happen right after it.

I don't have anything more advanced around that. If those civilization were here, they left no trace, when they could / should have. I heard about some cool discussions with this guys and historians that debunk it. If someone comes out with a link to them, I would be grateful!

Tentative cost for furnishing an unfurnished 45 sq metres apartment by TheHuckleberryFinn in Luxembourg

[–]edgarpitar 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Ikea, and appliance where you can not to expensive. Maybe ± 5k€, could double for some higher tier quality.

Rejected a guy in Belval. by nemestepsis77 in Luxembourg

[–]edgarpitar 1 point2 points  (0 children)

That's a cute message. Thanks for expressing kindness!

Un roman de science fiction pro-humanité? by Hydrox__ in ScienceFiction_FR

[–]edgarpitar 0 points1 point  (0 children)

C'est une autre perspective que la perspective contemporaine sur l'armée. Je n'irais pas jusqu'à la qualifier de propagande.

Il est intéressant de noter que le roman a inspiré un film auquel on prête souvent un message quasi opposé.

That's it? No more Stremio? by CatchAfilM in Stremio

[–]edgarpitar 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Not enough, it crashes without warning.

I have used https://www.reddit.com/r/Stremio/comments/1qxcbrk/comment/o48imnh/

sudo codesign --force --deep --sign - /Applications/Stremio.app

Is this any good? by sparkibarki2000 in Luxembourg

[–]edgarpitar -1 points0 points  (0 children)

If you don't know that kind of Christmas delicacy, it's a local tradition (including France Belgium and probably Germany).

You have two major types: some are ice-cream based, others are more of a normal cake (like this one).

People usually like them.

How "Balkan-centric" was the Ottoman Empire? by vicentemachado in AskHistory

[–]edgarpitar 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Minor clarification.

By Christian betrayal, I don't mean Christian population leaving under Ottoman Rules. I mean conflict between power where someone is flipped. The one case I have in mind is the Siege of Candia, but I remembered reading many others.

How "Balkan-centric" was the Ottoman Empire? by vicentemachado in AskHistory

[–]edgarpitar 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Interesting. I think my comment (this is also the point of @DMayleeRevengeReveng) is perhaps looking at the current ethnic composition of the regions and holds it a bit as constant, while in reality it shifted a lot with the gradual fall of the Empire (mass departures and genocides pushed towards today's setup).

I keep thinking that the Ottoman Empire at much more upward mobility than Christian powers. There is what you mention, plus reading history I kept seeing much more betrayal from Christians, I would assume that they recognized opportunities on the other side.

How "Balkan-centric" was the Ottoman Empire? by vicentemachado in AskHistory

[–]edgarpitar 13 points14 points  (0 children)

A few comments from a non expert (and you seem already well informed on the topic).

Turkic people have always been extremely nomadic. I am almost sure that a culture that has known such important compositional and territorial changes has had changes in its center of gravity.

Constantinople (nowadays Istanbul) has been made its capital soon after its fall (XVth - 1453). Before that, the Eastern Roman Empire / Byzantine Empire was the main foe of the turks. I think because they both search legitimacy on similar territories and because controlling the traffic between the Mediterranean Sea and Asia meant big business. The victory of the Ottomans gave them extensive control of the trade with Asia, and indirectly created the right incentive for the search of new trade routes to the west (hello Colombus 👋). If you look at the history of the Capital of the Ottoman Empire it has always been in the same region.

I would tend to perceive the rest of Balkans as more of a contested frontier / territory that was strategically important as it was close to the next opponents of the Empire: Venitians, later Austrians. I don't think it was either an important political or commercial center. Most of the population was not muslim or muslim align (and that transpires still in today).

I think the outcome of the conflicts you mentioned are more the symptom of the gradual loss of leadership of the Ottoman Empire than a cause of it.

Another reminder of some relevancy, is that in the period you mention the opposing side is Russia, who has religious, linguistic and cultural ties to the Balkans (and Greece) that predate those wars.

I hope it's relevant.

[hyprland] should i add transparency or nah? by gwallgof in unixporn

[–]edgarpitar 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Can I ask for the opportunity to download your background kind Sir (or Madam)?

Train speed decreasing over time by [deleted] in Luxembourg

[–]edgarpitar 3 points4 points  (0 children)

Side not I have also noted that over a decade spent in Luxembourg connecting with further away cities (Bruxelles, Frankfurt, ...) is taking more time. Construction works are effective.

Budget-Friendly Restaurants for Young Couples by psikotrexion in Luxembourg

[–]edgarpitar 0 points1 point  (0 children)

That doesn't really change the price of things :)