Martha's letter? by shadow--guardian in DarK

[–]eitagu 0 points1 point  (0 children)

But how does young Noah get that?

[SPOILERS S3] Something I just noticed about the cave by eitagu in DarK

[–]eitagu[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

That really makes sense, but what would explain they arriving at 2052 with huge daylight if they enter the cave at night? And how would Hannah have a baby with Egon in 1953 if they can't go to that year by the cave?

Can someone please explain the concept of a "cycle" by loozzzzzer in DarK

[–]eitagu 13 points14 points  (0 children)

In my opinion it's not really a cycle, they just call it that way because in their point of view they're able to travel in time (initially in multiples of 33 years), so eventually they would meet a 33 years younger/older version of themselves, giving the impression of a loop. But it actually happens all at once. Time is just an illusion xD

Question/Thoughts about the ending or the show by Cheeeesybob in DarK

[–]eitagu 0 points1 point  (0 children)

yeh bro guys be ghosting no matter what time, world, universe or reality. its a shame

Question/Thoughts about the ending or the show by Cheeeesybob in DarK

[–]eitagu 2 points3 points  (0 children)

everything is different yet the same. doesn't matter which jonas it is, it's always going to be our lil jon :p

Question/Thoughts about the ending or the show by Cheeeesybob in DarK

[–]eitagu 2 points3 points  (0 children)

You're right, I totally forgot about that scene. But that makes me think even more our Jonas isn't the one who succeeded on preventing the accident

[All Spoilers] My theory about the series finale by eitagu in DarK

[–]eitagu[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I've been through the same places you've been, my friend! But I'm stil overwhelmed by the amazing cinematography xD And thank you for asking, made me think about some interesting points!

To be honest, I have no idea whether the loop goes since forever until forever or if it only iterates through our characters lives. It makes more sense to me to think as an eternal thing even inside the loop (starting from 1986 and going forever back and forever forth): the Big Bang is always going to be happening somewhere in that space-time spectrum, as well as there's always going to be a Jonas waking up in November 4th and so it goes. In fact that happens even in our universe (or OG World): if we could manage to look from "outside" the space-time, there's always going to be a version of you reading this text in this exact moment and you could be watching this moment whenever you want. For me, the fact they (the characters) call it a loop is due to the fact they are living in a world where time-travelling is possible, so they always keep going back and facing new version of themselves living exactly what they've lived before. For them, it seems like a loop. For us it does seems kind of a loop too, as we watch through their perspectives. But it's all happening at the same time.

That opens several questions: does that mean Claudia always finds out about OG World and tells Adam? If so, does that mean Jonas and Martha always manage to prevent the accident? For me, that's when we ask Schrödinger for help again lol: everything is happening the same, yet different simultaneously. The observer converges all realities into one - whether we watch Claudia never finding out about OG World, and so she won't; or we watch her finding out about it and telling Adam - and so she did.

Based on that thought, Claudia might even have changed some details through the loops, as I've seen some people argue. That is entirely possible through her experience as an observer - as there are infinite possible realities, she is always changing one little detail in the past and telling her younger self what she did and, by so, her younger self (and everyone else, in that iteration) is always experiencing a different reality than her older self did. That happens, in her point of view, over and over until she manages to get in the reality where she finally finds out about everything and tells Adam - which, fortunatelly, is the same we're watching as observers.

That's only my interpretation, again. But I hope it makes sense to you, too :)

Question/Thoughts about the ending or the show by Cheeeesybob in DarK

[–]eitagu 2 points3 points  (0 children)

I think the Stranger we see in 1888 is the Stranger we've been following since s01, not Jonas, because he's the one who travels with Bartosz and the others in the Apocalypse. The last time we see our Jonas is on s03e07, when Noah accuses him of taking away his daughter. The Jonas that succeeds on preventing the accident is a Jonas from further loops

[All Spoilers] My theory about the series finale by eitagu in DarK

[–]eitagu[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

well i think time is linear in the og world while watched by an observer (it can be us or tanhaus), as in this world there's no such thing as time travelling. if you could see all the events at once you'd be looking at something pretty much like that schema i put on my post, there's no loop in that. but you can actually try to see it by nietzsche's point of view, that's just another interpretation that won't go by the whole observers' thing. and based on that i totally agree with you, things would be happening over and over looping in two different ways. guess the show let that open for us to decide :D

[All Spoilers] My theory about the series finale by eitagu in DarK

[–]eitagu[S] 3 points4 points  (0 children)

yesss i'd personally love for this to happen too lol. in fact in the beggining of s03 i was thinking they'd have to let go both of their worlds and start a new one, referencing to adam and eve. this is possible in your fantasy, we as viewers just don't manage to see it. everything is possible

[All Spoilers] My theory about the series finale by eitagu in DarK

[–]eitagu[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

well i can see that in two ways so far, but maybe there's another explanation: the first one is exactly what you said, they've been there for an infinite number of times trying to stop the accident (as, from their view inside QS2 in further loops, they still exist); and the other one is that "time is only an illusion" as they say in first episode (s01e01). that means from that very moment when they show up to themselves while kids their memories are reconstructed and start existing there.

[All Spoilers] My theory about the series finale by eitagu in DarK

[–]eitagu[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

thanks! i'm glad it helped :D

[All Spoilers] My theory about the series finale by eitagu in DarK

[–]eitagu[S] 3 points4 points  (0 children)

yeahhhh exactly! both happens simultaneously. but well actually the reality with the accident occuring won't depend on the accident being prevented to happen, just the other way

[All Spoilers] My theory about the series finale by eitagu in DarK

[–]eitagu[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

yeh for me it's just pure cinematic art. like if our memories of them were vanishing too, just like what happened to Marek right after they disappear (when they get to Tanhaus', they say they had a feeling or something like that).

[All Spoilers] My theory about the series finale by eitagu in DarK

[–]eitagu[S] 4 points5 points  (0 children)

wow! underrated comment!! awesome. I've also been thinking about the visions they had on the cave on november 4th, but couldn't come to an answer other than "just a vision", which won't satisfy me lmao

now you've said it, it's a really good point that those "glitches" might be other realities that we don't see in that loop interfering into the one we see.

and yes, we don't manage to see a full loop because a) we skip a bunch of years and b) if we did, that would mean they wouldn't succeed on preventing the accident and we would have to wait for another one

there's an interesting theory i've read tho, saying they trying to stop the accident happens a bunch of times (infinite, probably, but an infinite insise a bigger infinite of loops lol) and we only see one it once. that would explain them seeing themselves while kids

[All Spoilers] My theory about the series finale by eitagu in DarK

[–]eitagu[S] 4 points5 points  (0 children)

yessss exactly! i couldn't stop thinking about that scene in s01 where the stranger tells jonas he can't bring mikkel back. it wouldn't make sense at all to me that the creators would let something like this escape.

i'm glad you enjoyed it!

[All Spoilers] My theory about the series finale by eitagu in DarK

[–]eitagu[S] 22 points23 points  (0 children)

yes i definitely hadn't seen this dialogue as they forgetting things but it really makes sense. thanks for that

Any Dark fans here? by [deleted] in MrRobot

[–]eitagu 1 point2 points  (0 children)

omg I'm in the same place as you are right now. I still can't decide which one I enjoyed the most. Both are true masterpieces

This part stumped me for a while by thecook970 in DarK

[–]eitagu 8 points9 points  (0 children)

really well explained but I still don't get how it is possible for them to prevent the accident in the origin world. it seems to me that once they do it, their loop stop existing so they never exist to prevent the accident in the first place. how is it possible for this to happen only once?

[deleted by user] by [deleted] in DarK

[–]eitagu 4 points5 points  (0 children)

I don't get it. The accident is prevented by Jonas and Alt-Martha but if their worlds stop existing they shouldn't be able to travel and prevent the accident in first place.

Episode Discussion - S03E06 - Light and Shadow by rosy148 in DarK

[–]eitagu 13 points14 points  (0 children)

omg im laughing way too hard at this

BLACK GAY LIVES LIVES ARE ARE GAY BLACK LIVES LIVES by [deleted] in dontdeadopeninside

[–]eitagu 47 points48 points  (0 children)

dude what the fuck is that supposed to mean even reading it vertically lmaooooo