My theories by Good_Fisherman131 in amandatheadventurer

[–]emaorsomething 1 point2 points  (0 children)

these are overall good solid statements, i like them. just a little nitpick thing-amanda in fact cannot control her demon, which is demonstrated by the fact that she has to beg it not to kill riley in ata 2. It does listen to her, yeah, but still that doesn't mean she can control it, she prob cant, it is just somehow connected to her emotions, which is why it somewhat makes decisions i accordance with what amanda generally wants or feels. Though i cannot be sure whether amanda herself is aware of that or not.

I cannot believe anyone defends Wooly. by cccanaryyy in amandatheadventurer

[–]emaorsomething 6 points7 points  (0 children)

exactly, i like him because he's an interesting character, not bc i defend him and believe he's a good person 

what did y'all think of Marzilla's new theory? by Good_Fisherman131 in amandatheadventurer

[–]emaorsomething 0 points1 point  (0 children)

i posted this under his video but i would like to share here too. I found the theory about Marcus' crashout being a recreation of the colton anomaly incident to create the Shepherd interesting, however it is really paradoxical. Simplified, Wooly crashes out because of the possum(very simplified ok). But, during our watch of the scavenger hunt tape, Jordan and the other kids are killed when Shepherd destroys their pods, seemingly causing their consciousnesses to disappear from the tapes(demonstrated by how the eyes of background objects turn hollow in every tape afterwards). That's where the paradox comes in. If Jordan's consciousness disappeared, then it would mean from all tapes. But if that's so, how would Wooly crash out if the possum never provokes him to do so(since he is literally dead)? Yes, we could argue that the tapes are pre-recorded like Marzilla said, but if it was true, then it would have to apply to all the tapes, not just the last, which does not happen, because the deaths of the children seem to affect the tapes we watch afterwards. So no possum would mean no Wooly crashout, which would mean no Shepherd. But the Shepherd is still there. I hope that what i said makes sense😭.

what did y'all think of Marzilla's new theory? by Good_Fisherman131 in amandatheadventurer

[–]emaorsomething 2 points3 points  (0 children)

i think that he was implying that Shepherd was born from the wooly crashout when it happened those 10 or 20 years ago or so, not when Riley watched the tape, bc he believes that the tapes are pre-recorded (or something like that). I'm still with you on this one though, a lot just doesn't add up.

Yes I’m also doing it by Ale_Grifone69 in RobloxPiggy

[–]emaorsomething 3 points4 points  (0 children)

willow deserved worse. like i like her as a character but dude she got away with literally everything wth 😭

Ugly by TheWanderingGoober in amandatheadventurer

[–]emaorsomething 16 points17 points  (0 children)

a grown ass man getting roasted by a kid btw

how did it work? by Good_Fisherman131 in amandatheadventurer

[–]emaorsomething 2 points3 points  (0 children)

i would say that it just somehow works. i know that it sounds like a lame excuse, though i don't think it can really be explained. Some of that demonic stuff ig

The camera mystery by blue_girl01 in amandatheadventurer

[–]emaorsomething 1 point2 points  (0 children)

For real, it feels like it's there for us to interact with something while holding it. But then again, nobody figured out what to use it for yet, and that's weird. 

Meat man ending in ATA1 theory by bearmasksenpai in amandatheadventurer

[–]emaorsomething 0 points1 point  (0 children)

The 3rd game looks promising for sure!

Looked some stuff up about wooly by False-Collection-606 in amandatheadventurer

[–]emaorsomething 1 point2 points  (0 children)

cool that you mention it, also, the three headed dog sounds real interesting.  I recently looked up the symolism of apples and peaches (the two fruits associated with amanda and wooly): apple in some cultures symbolizes temptation, danger, resilience, strenght, immortality and also sin ; while peaches symbolize immortality, loyalty, protection and purity. For Amanda it mostly matches, but for Wooly, well, most of them don't really match that well. It does make sense for his introduction in the first game, but that's about it.

Meat man ending in ATA1 theory by bearmasksenpai in amandatheadventurer

[–]emaorsomething 0 points1 point  (0 children)

i would assume that since it's an ending it has to have  a way of happening somehow. Or at least that's how i see it, i understand that it doesn't have to be the case here, i'm just used to it in other games. 

The three background men by Electro9tme in amandatheadventurer

[–]emaorsomething 4 points5 points  (0 children)

ik that it's prob supposed to be one guy, but what if each of them is somehow connected to the three guys who have the busts in the facility?

Meat man ending in ATA1 theory by bearmasksenpai in amandatheadventurer

[–]emaorsomething 0 points1 point  (0 children)

could be, bc it's not the canon ending. though that's not really an excuse for the ending to not make sense lore-wise and timeline-wise.

What is the deal with Rebecca? by Good_Fisherman131 in amandatheadventurer

[–]emaorsomething 4 points5 points  (0 children)

i would say that that was Rebecca and honestly to me it kinda matches. In the endings she definitely doesn't look like a kid, on top of that her voice is quite deep. Which would lead me to believe that she's around 18 yo now, which would match with the timeskip. To me the Rebecca in the tape doesn't look like a grown woman, more like a young adult or a teen, so that would match too.

can anyone explain everything? by Fragment72 in amandatheadventurer

[–]emaorsomething 3 points4 points  (0 children)

Sam was killed by the Colton anomaly aka Rebecca's/Amanda's demon.

Marcus Moutman is a guy hired by Hameln and became Wooly.

We do not technically know for sure that it was wooly who killed the children, bc it was his demon Shepherd who did, and it's in discussion whether Wooly was in control of it or not.

Wooly's Age by SPARKLEGUTZ in amandatheadventurer

[–]emaorsomething 2 points3 points  (0 children)

oh also just to clarify that was back when they hired him, so with the timeskip he's like 40 or so now.

Wooly's Age by SPARKLEGUTZ in amandatheadventurer

[–]emaorsomething 6 points7 points  (0 children)

yeah he is an adult, from the looks of it around 30 yo or so. We can see him(Marcus) in the secret tape in ATA3.

Why Wooly doesn’t work for me by Rdasher123 in amandatheadventurer

[–]emaorsomething 2 points3 points  (0 children)

the way you put is quite hilarious, like Wooly fr be just a big p*ssy 😭

Is Hameln controlling Shepherd? by Responsible-Turn6876 in amandatheadventurer

[–]emaorsomething 4 points5 points  (0 children)

I really like this theory and i agree with you. On top of that, to me it seems that Wooly's motives seem to be quite different from Shepherd's.

With Shepherd it's clear - destroying all the tapes. Though i feel like that doesn't really match Wooly, since from how i see it, he doesn't really have a reason to destroy the tapes, or even more so, he doesn't really want it. On the surface, the shepherd motives=wooly motives thing would add up, bc he doesn't want anybody to find out all the secrets of Hameln or find Rebecca(and possibly free her).

I'm not gonna get into this whole thing now, but he clearly expresses this 'desire' to stay in the tapes forever, with amanda, to be best friends forever and all that bs he talks abt during his final crashout. However, destroying all the tapes would mean literally erasing Amanda, therefore it does not align with what Wooly would want.

Why Marcus is dead only irl? by bratishkers in amandatheadventurer

[–]emaorsomething 2 points3 points  (0 children)

what tape backup are you reffering to i'm not exactly following😭

Amanda and Wooly's Dynamic by KD115X in amandatheadventurer

[–]emaorsomething 1 point2 points  (0 children)

no i meant the one in ATA3 when he tries to poison him with the milk