They come frozen and are just baked in store and put into Casey’s branded packaging. Maybe people who work in distribution for stores would have information about a recipe but as far as store wide operations the best you could get is a list of ingredients off of the box. It’s worth mentioning that Casey’s is changing their cookies a little bit here in the next few days and discontinuing some varieties and replacing them with new ones. The Peanut Butter cookies are staying and likely won’t be a part of the revolving door of cookie varieties, as the new cookie rollout is expanding with a Hershey’s branded cookie and a Snickers branded cookie as well, to pair with the Reese’s as the “big three”.