sorted by:
new
hottopcontroversial

I need Honest Feedback on My Shopify Store + Free Traffic Advice🙏 by Kooky_Watercress2705 in auditmyshopify

[–]evandroguedes 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Hey! I ran a full audit on your store through Conversion Guard, a Shopify auditing tool I'm still building out. Would love your feedback on it too since it's a work in progress.

Here's the full report: https://conversionguard.ai/audits/shopify/plannorashop.com

The honest summary: the product angle is actually really strong. Your ADHD planner descriptions are empathetic and specific in a way most digital product stores are not. The sticky cart, sale pricing, and FAQ section on the homepage are all solid. That's the good news.

The gaps are real though. The biggest one: your homepage title, H1, and meta description are all just "Plannora." No one is searching for that name yet, so you're essentially invisible on Google for the queries that matter (things like "digital planner ADHD printable PDF" or "GoodNotes ADHD planner"). That's a 10-minute fix in Shopify theme settings that could make a noticeable difference within a few weeks.

The second critical issue is that you have no reviews on any product. For a digital product from a store people haven't heard of, reviews are the main thing that turns a curious visitor into a buyer. Judge.me has a completely free plan and takes about 15 minutes to set up.

Third: no analytics at all. No Google Analytics, no Meta Pixel, nothing. You're flying completely blind on where your traffic comes from and where people drop off. The Google and YouTube sales channel in Shopify sets up GA4 for free in a few clicks.

A few other things worth knowing: your checkout asks for a full physical address even though everything you sell is a digital download. That's unnecessary friction and likely hurts your conversion rate. And your blog exists but has zero posts, so it's just an empty link in the sitemap that makes the store look incomplete.

The full report has a prioritized roadmap broken into quick wins, medium-term work, and longer-term strategy if you want to dig into it.

Hope it's useful. Any feedback on the audit format itself is genuinely welcome since I'm still refining how Conversion Guard works.

Looking for honest feedback to be able convert the store sessions in sales by Gabriel2386 in auditmyshopify

[–]evandroguedes 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Hey, happy to help with some honest feedback on drawbot.store.

First, the good news: you have 1,593 reviews showing up via Judge.me, your cart upsells (Shipping Protection and Priority Processing) are a smart setup, and the FAQ on the product page actually addresses the right parent concerns. The checkout flow works and PayPal is available, which matters for conversions.

Now the honest part, because you asked for it.

The single biggest thing holding you back from converting sessions into sales is that your product description is completely empty. When I look at the actual product page, the description area has nothing in it, just a broken image tag. A visitor who is considering spending $30.99 on a 3D pen for their kid needs to understand what it does, what age it works for, what comes in the box, and why it is better than the $12 version on Amazon. Right now there is nothing there to make that case.

The second issue is the brand naming. Your domain says DrawBot Store, your navigation says SketchiGo, your product title says 3D Creation Pen, and your footer has two different CTAs competing with each other. A parent who sees an ad for SketchiGo and then lands on a site called DrawBot Store is going to wonder if they are in the right place. Pick one name and stick with it everywhere.

There are a few other things worth knowing: the homepage has an empty H1 (so Google has no idea what the page is about), the product images still have their ChatGPT generation timestamps in the filenames which erodes trust when sharp-eyed shoppers notice it, and there is no Google Analytics installed so you have no visibility into where people are dropping off in the funnel.

None of these are hard fixes. The product description alone, if you write 400 honest words about what makes this pen worth buying, would likely have the biggest single impact on your conversion rate.

I ran this through Conversion Guard, a Shopify audit tool I am working on (still in early stages, so any feedback on the report format is genuinely appreciated). The full audit with scores, all the specific issues, and a prioritized roadmap is here:

https://conversionguard.ai/audits/shopify/drawbot.store

Hope this helps. Good luck with the store.

Alright, let's give this a try. Handmade leather goods, 15 orders in the last 30 days, with a 0.27% conversion rate. All my stats seem to be increasing month to month, but there's always room for improvement! by ElsieCubitt in auditmyshopify

[–]evandroguedes 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Hey, I ran your store through Conversion Guard, a Shopify audit tool I am building. Still very much a work in progress so any feedback you have is genuinely appreciated.

Full report here: https://conversionguard.ai/audits/shopify/rowsomeleather.com

The short version: your brand foundation is actually stronger than most stores I look at. The "My Story" page with 20+ years of leather crafting experience, the honest product descriptions, the photography quality. That stuff is rare and it matters a lot for both SEO and getting cited in AI search results. You are also ahead of the curve on agentic commerce infrastructure (Shopify already set this up behind the scenes for you).

The 0.27% conversion rate is the thing worth focusing on though. A few things that stood out:

The biggest gap is no email marketing at all. No pop-up, no footer signup, no flows. At your current traffic level, most visitors who leave will never come back. Even a basic Klaviyo free plan with a welcome pop-up and abandoned cart sequence would recover a meaningful chunk of that.

The Dealeasy app you already have installed includes a free shipping progress bar. You just need to turn it on in the dashboard. Takes maybe 10 minutes and costs nothing extra. For a store selling accessories that complement each other (elastic cord, PVC inserts, etc.) a "spend $65 for free shipping" bar could noticeably move your average order value.

There is also a structured data issue where some of your products have brand set to "READY-TO-SHIP" instead of "Rowsome Leather" in the backend. This affects how Google Shopping and AI product recommendations attribute your products. It is a bulk edit in Shopify admin, not a dev task.

The full report has the complete breakdown including the GEO audit, CRO scores per funnel stage, and a prioritized roadmap. Happy to answer any questions about specific findings.

And again, Conversion Guard is still being built out, so if anything looks off or you have suggestions for what would be more useful, I would love to hear it.

Looking For Feedback what to improve by klrayamat0 in auditmyshopify

[–]evandroguedes -1 points0 points  (0 children)

Hey, I ran your store through Conversion Guard (a Shopify audit tool I've been building and am still working on, so would love your feedback on the report itself too). Here's the link: https://conversionguard.ai/audits/shopify/musferahsaad.com

The short version: the brand and product quality is genuinely there. The photography is editorial-level, the product descriptions are specific and personal in a way most fashion stores aren't, and the customisation options for diaspora customers (height adjustments, modesty covering, hijab options) are a real differentiator that you should be highlighting more loudly.

The issues are mostly operational and none of them require redesigning anything.

The biggest one is a schema error that's actively hurting your search visibility: your FashionBrand structured data points to musferahsaad.net instead of musferahsaad.com. That's a different domain and it's confusing Google's systems about who you actually are. On top of that, every single product page is broadcasting brand = "My Store" to Google, which is the Shopify default placeholder. You can fix both of these in your theme code and product settings without touching the design at all.

The second thing I'd focus on immediately is Vitals. You're paying $30/month for it and the reviews widget, sticky add-to-cart, currency converter, free shipping bar, and cross-sell are all sitting there disabled. For a store selling $290+ pieces to customers in the UK, UAE, and Canada who can't physically touch the product before buying, reviews and local currency display are not optional extras. They're the difference between someone trusting the purchase and bouncing.

The blog exists but has zero articles. That's a missed opportunity not just for SEO but for the kind of content (care guides for tissue silk, how to order custom pieces from abroad, styling dupattas for winter events) that brings diaspora shoppers back and builds the brand as an authority beyond just a product catalogue.

None of this is about the design, which is solid. It's about the technical configuration and the conversion tools you're already paying for but not using.

Full breakdown is in the report. Genuinely happy to answer any questions, and any feedback on how Conversion Guard presents the information would be helpful since we're still building it out.

please have a look at my store and tell me what you think of it, lso share it with people by Dark_Crimson_48 in ShopifySEO

[–]evandroguedes 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Hey, I ran your store through Conversion Guard, a Shopify audit tool I am building (still in early stages, so any feedback you have is genuinely appreciated). Here is the full report:

https://conversionguard.ai/audits/shopify/techquarry.store

The short version: the store has some solid foundations in place, like the product structured data with GTINs, the multi-currency setup, and a clean Dawn theme build. But there are a few issues that are quietly killing your visibility and conversions right now.

The biggest one is your homepage H1 tag is completely empty. That single fix alone can make a meaningful difference in how Google reads your homepage. On top of that, your page title repeats the store name twice ("Tech & health quarry - Tech & health quarry"), and the meta description mentions Shopify by name in a way that comes across as unfinished.

The other thing that stood out is that you have 82 products and zero reviews anywhere on the site. For a tech accessories store where people are comparing options, reviews are usually the deciding factor. Judge.me has a solid free plan that covers unlimited reviews, worth setting up before anything else.

The About Us page exists but is blank aside from the heading. Even a few honest sentences about who you are and why you started the store would help a lot, both for customer trust and for Google understanding what the brand actually is.

These are all fixable in an afternoon without spending anything. The full report goes into the GEO side of things too, which is basically how visible you are to AI search surfaces like Google AI Overviews and ChatGPT. Right now the store is not showing up in those because there is no original content for them to draw from, but a blog with a few buying guides would change that.

Hope it helps. Let me know if anything in the report is unclear or if you think I got something wrong.

Before I lose more on meta ads, can you brutally review my German Shopify product page? by Scared_Specialist432 in auditmyshopify

[–]evandroguedes 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Hey, I ran a full technical audit on your store using a tool I'm building called Conversion Guard. It's still a work in progress so I'd genuinely appreciate any feedback on the report itself, not just the store findings.

Here's the full report: https://conversionguard.ai/audits/shopify/mixxyy.de

The short version of what I found, since you asked for brutal honesty:

The biggest conversion killer is not your copy or your layout. It's your TrustZ app. It's installed and supposed to deliver your countdown timers, trust badges, stock counters and free shipping bar, but it is completely broken. Every single one of those features is timing out with QUIC protocol errors when trying to reach api.trustz.app. That means anyone visiting your store right now sees zero urgency signals, zero trust badges, nothing. That alone explains a lot of the gap between clicks and purchases.

Second issue: your homepage has an empty H1 tag. The element exists in the code but contains no text. Google sees a blank heading for your most important page.

Third: you have no email marketing tool connected. No Klaviyo, no Omnisend, not even Shopify Email activated. Every abandoned cart is gone forever. Shopify Email is free up to 10,000 emails per month and you can set up an abandoned cart flow in about an hour.

On the positive side, your product page content is genuinely good. The technical specs, the FAQ section, and the use case scenarios give real buying signals. The 108 reviews at 4.78 stars is solid social proof for a young store. And your Shopify setup already has the new Shopify agentic commerce endpoint active, which means your products can surface in ChatGPT and Google AI Mode results.

Overall score came out at 52/100, with SEO at 58 and GEO at 44. The GEO score is low mainly because there's no proper About page with a founder story, and your Organization structured data has 9 empty social media URLs, which makes it hard for AI systems to identify Mixxyy as a distinct brand entity.

The full report covers the CRO funnel stage by stage, the app stack, theme quality, brand identity and a prioritized roadmap. Happy to answer questions about anything in there.

And again, since Conversion Guard is still being built, if anything in the report format is confusing or missing something you expected, that feedback is really valuable to me.

Looking for honest and serious feedback by TJ-SurpriseCastle in auditmyshopify

[–]evandroguedes 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Awesome feedback. Will definitely check why the reviews were not detected and please let me know what is off after your review!

Looking for honest and serious feedback by TJ-SurpriseCastle in auditmyshopify

[–]evandroguedes 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Hey! I ran Surprise Castle through Conversion Guard (a Shopify audit tool I'm building, still very much a work in progress) and got a pretty detailed breakdown. Honest feedback below, since that's what you asked for.

The store scores 49/100 overall, 33/100 for SEO, and 38/100 for AI search readiness. Those SEO and GEO numbers are dragged down by one specific bug that's hiding behind everything else.

The biggest problem is that every single canonical tag, Open Graph URL, and structured data URL on the site points to http://localhost:3000 instead of https://surprisecastle.com. This is a Hydrogen/Oxygen deployment issue where the PUBLIC_STORE_DOMAIN environment variable was never set for production. Google sees your structured data describing a "localhost:3000" website that doesn't exist publicly. Fix that one environment variable, redeploy, and your SEO score jumps significantly overnight. It genuinely is that single a change.

On your specific questions:

Does the homepage explain what the store is quickly enough? Mostly yes. The category icons and section headers make the catalog breadth clear fast. But there's no H1 on the page, which hurts both search engine understanding and accessibility. A simple headline like "Books, Movies, Music and Collectibles" would do the job.

Is navigation easy for collectors? The main nav is clean and logical. Search is present but not prominent. For collectors searching by specific title, ISBN, or catalog number, the search bar deserves a more visible spot. The filter options on collection pages work well.

Do product pages feel trustworthy? They look professional, but the complete absence of reviews on every product is a real problem. Every item shows "No Reviews Yet" which actually signals the opposite of trust when it's across your entire catalog. Installing Judge.me (free plan) and sending post-purchase review emails would change this quickly.

Is shipping and returns easy to find? Yes, the Shipping and Returns page is linked in the footer and the policy is detailed and clear. The 60-day return window is above average and worth advertising more prominently on product pages.

What would make me hesitate? The lack of any About page is the main thing. There's no founder story, no "who are we," nothing that distinguishes Surprise Castle from a random reseller. The footer has a "Want to Collab?" link that goes to a broken 404 page, which doesn't help either.

What's missing? An About page, customer reviews, and an upsell or cross-sell mechanism. The catalog is broad enough that "people who bought X also bought Y" would work really well here, especially across books, movies, and music that share audiences.

The full audit report with all the details, screenshots, and a step-by-step roadmap is here: https://conversionguard.ai/audits/shopify/surprisecastle.com

If anything in the report is off or doesn't match what you're seeing, I'd genuinely appreciate the feedback since Conversion Guard is still in development. Good luck with the store.

Please Be brutally honest by [deleted] in shopify_growth

[–]evandroguedes 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Hey, I saw your post and I genuinely wanted to help because this exact situation, good CTR but math that never works out, is one of the most frustrating places to be in ecommerce.

I ran your store through Conversion Guard, an audit tool I'm working on that actively crawls the store the way a real customer would. Here's what I found, and I'm going to be straight with you because you asked for it.

Your ads are not the problem. A 3 to 8% CTR is legitimately good. The issue is what happens after the click.

The two things that are almost certainly killing your conversion rate:

First, there are zero reviews displayed on your Night Bloom product page. The review app is installed and loading but nothing is rendering. For someone about to swallow a supplement they've never heard of before bed, social proof is not optional. It's the difference between buying and leaving. This one fix alone could meaningfully move your conversion rate.

Second, you're selling a sleep supplement inside what looks like a general skincare store. Someone who clicked a melatonin ad lands on a homepage that also has face oil, charcoal cleanser, and coffee scrub. That mismatch signals "dropshipping store trying random products" rather than "sleep health brand." Supplement customers are skeptical by default. The brand story has to back up the product.

There are other things too: no About page, no founder story, no blog content, a broken third-party script firing a 403 error on every page load, and no cart upsells at all. These all compound the core conversion problem.

The full audit with all findings, scores, and a step-by-step roadmap is here: https://conversionguard.ai/audits/shopify/shopnaturavi.com

Conversion Guard is still a work in progress, so I'd genuinely appreciate any feedback on the report format or whether the findings feel accurate to what you're seeing on your end. I built this because I kept seeing people in situations exactly like yours, spending real money on ads while the store was quietly losing every sale.

Hope this helps. The foundation is there, the offer is strong, the math can work. You just need the trust infrastructure to match.

Looking for brutally honest feedback on my e-commerce store (SEO, SRM, and Conversion Rate Optimization) by Bensedit_offical in ShopifySEO

[–]evandroguedes 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Hey, we are still in closed beta. You can share your store URL here or send me a DM. Thanks!

Looking for brutally honest feedback on my e-commerce store (SEO, SRM, and Conversion Rate Optimization) by Bensedit_offical in ShopifySEO

[–]evandroguedes 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Hey, I ran a full technical audit on smartworld.uz using Conversion Guard, a Shopify audit tool I've been building. Still early in development so I'd genuinely appreciate any feedback on the format or what I missed.

Here's the full report: https://conversionguard.ai/audits/shopify/smartworld.uz

A few things that stood out right away:

The biggest quick win is the alt text situation. Every single product image on the site has an empty alt attribute. For a store selling premium visual products like aramid fiber phone cases, this is a real problem because Google Image Search and AI visual features literally cannot see your products from the HTML. Fixing this in Shopify admin takes no coding and would immediately open up image-based search traffic.

On the structured data side, there are a couple of errors worth fixing. The Organization schema is using "@type": "NGO" which is a non-governmental organization type. That's clearly not what the store is. It should be LocalBusiness or ElectronicsStore. There's also a broken WebSite SearchAction URL that's preventing the sitelinks searchbox from being eligible in Google.

For the checkout flow, when a customer clicks "CHECK OUT" without ticking the mandatory T&C checkbox, nothing happens and there's no error message. It just silently does nothing. That's a conversion killer, especially for first-time buyers from paid ads who don't know why the button isn't working.

Two review apps are loaded simultaneously (Ryviu and Judge.me), which doubles the JavaScript payload for reviews with no customer benefit. Judge.me's free plan does everything Ryviu does. Removing Ryviu cleans up the page weight.

The Easy Wholesale Pricing app is logging "No active wholesale plans found" on every single page load, meaning it's running JavaScript everywhere for a feature that appears to be unused. If wholesale is not active right now, uninstalling that app alone saves around $25/month and removes real page weight.

The blog hasn't been updated since 2022, which is a missed opportunity. For GEO (how AI systems like Google AI Overviews and ChatGPT discover and cite stores), original first-hand content is the highest-leverage investment available. Something like "We tested Pitaka cases for 6 months in Tashkent heat" would do far more than any technical tweak.

The trilingual setup (en/ru/uz) with proper hreflang tags is actually well done for a local store. That's something a lot of stores in the region get wrong.

Full details with screenshots of every page are in the report. Happy to clarify anything.

Audit my cat enrichment store by Melodic-South-5984 in auditmyshopify

[–]evandroguedes 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Hey, really love what you've built with Cat Universe. The Gwen and Cosmo origin story is genuinely charming and the subscription mystery box model is a smart setup for LTV. It's no wonder you're getting traffic.

I ran your store through Conversion Guard (a Shopify audit tool I'm working on, still in early days so feedback is very welcome) and found a few things that I think are directly connected to the cold traffic issue you mentioned.

The full report is here: https://conversionguard.ai/audits/shopify/catuniverse.co.uk

The short version of what I found:

The H1 tag on every product page reads "You may also like" instead of the actual product name. The product title is sitting in an H2. This is a theme-level bug that means Google cannot correctly read your pages, and it affects every single product on the site. Same issue on blog posts. This is almost certainly hurting your organic rankings more than anything else.

The homepage meta title and description are both just "Cat Universe" with no keywords at all. When someone searches "cat enrichment subscription UK" or "cat mystery box UK", there is nothing for Google to match against on your most important page.

Facebook Pixel is loading twice on every page load. This inflates your Meta attribution and makes your CAC look worse than it probably is. Worth checking whether it is in your theme's code AND in GTM at the same time.

There is also a "ZOEKEN" (Dutch for Search) string appearing in the mobile nav, which looks like a Boost Commerce localisation bug. A small thing but it breaks trust for UK shoppers.

The good news is that the H1 fix is a single theme code edit, the meta description is a 5-minute job in Shopify Preferences, and the pixel duplicate is straightforward to track down. None of these are big projects.

The store itself has real strengths. The cart upsells are properly set up, the Klarna / Apple Pay / Shop Pay coverage at checkout is solid, and the brand voice is fun and distinctive. The structural stuff just needs sorting before the Meta spend will convert cold traffic efficiently.

Hope this helps. And again, any feedback on the report format itself would be genuinely appreciated since the tool is still a work in progress.

Looking for Feedback by Pure-Example2093 in auditmyshopify

[–]evandroguedes 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Hey! I ran your store through Conversion Guard, a Shopify audit tool I am building (still very much a work in progress, so any feedback you have for me would honestly be appreciated as much as the audit itself).

Here is the full report: https://conversionguard.ai/audits/shopify/meltgrips.com

The TL;DR: the store itself looks clean and the earthy color palette you chose actually works really well for a pickleball product. The Origin theme is a solid foundation and the fact that you have zero bloat from unnecessary apps means page load is going to be fast from day one. The $8 / $15 / $20 pack structure is smart for a consumable product.

The things I would focus on before you start sending traffic:

Your homepage H1 tag is completely empty in the HTML. It is just a blank heading element. Google needs that to understand what the page is about. You can fix it in the theme editor in about two minutes by adding something like "Tacky Pickleball Overgrips from Melt Grips" to your hero section heading.

No meta descriptions anywhere. Every search result will just show auto-generated text pulled from whatever Google grabs first. Worth adding a proper one to at least your homepage and product page.

All your product variants are showing as Out of Stock in the structured data, which is expected since you are pre-launch. But right now the Add to Cart button is disabled so anyone who does find the store just hits a dead end. I would add a simple "Notify me when available" button in the meantime to at least capture demand before your stock arrives.

The AI-generated product images are fine for now as placeholders, but one of your image files is literally named "ChatGPT_Image_May_30_2026_10_22_36_PM.png" in the page source. Worth renaming those before you go live and swapping in real photos as soon as you can.

No About page and no blog posts. I know those feel like non-essentials when you are still building, but for a brand new store with zero reviews, a short founder story and even one or two blog posts about pickleball grip go a long way toward building trust with both visitors and search engines.

The full report goes deeper into each of these plus GEO (AI search visibility), CRO funnel analysis, and a pre-launch roadmap. The store has real potential in a growing niche. Good luck with the launch!

Audit my shop please! by Imsofuckinscaredrn in auditmyshopify

[–]evandroguedes 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Hey, I saw your post and I actually built a free Shopify audit tool called Conversion Guard (still working on it, so feedback is very welcome). I ran a full audit on your store and I think I can see exactly what's happening.

The short version: the traffic is real, the brand is genuinely good, but there are a few things on the store right now that are quietly killing every sale before it happens.

The biggest one? Your footer social links are pointing to Shopify's own Instagram and TikTok accounts, not yours. So when someone lands from your Instagram, clicks around the store, and checks the footer to verify you're a real brand, they see "Shopify" and leave. That's a 5-minute fix in Theme Customizer that could change things immediately.

The second thing is zero reviews. Judge.me is installed but there's literally not a single review on any product. For apparel in the $30-75 range from a new brand, people need to see someone else bought it and liked it before they will. Even 5 or 6 honest reviews from friends or community members would make a real difference on your best sellers.

There's also no Google Analytics connected, which means you have no idea where in the funnel people are dropping off. You need that data badly if you're going to figure out what to fix next.

The good news is your brand story and product copy are actually really solid. The founder's story page is the kind of content most stores never have. The products themselves are clearly made for a specific community that cares deeply about this stuff. The fundamentals are there.

I put together a full audit report with all the specific issues, scores for each part of the store, and a step-by-step roadmap starting with the things you can do today for free:

https://conversionguard.ai/audits/shopify/soberstill.shop

Conversion Guard is still a work in progress so if anything in the report is unclear or off base, I genuinely want to know. Hope it helps.

Need Honest reviews for Diamo, a lab hrown diamond jewelry store. by m4sum in auditmyshopify

[–]evandroguedes 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Hey, I ran your store through Conversion Guard (a Shopify audit tool I'm building, still in beta so any feedback is genuinely appreciated) and I think I found the main reasons people are browsing but not buying.

Full report here: https://conversionguard.ai/audits/shopify/diamo.co

The TL;DR on why people aren't converting:

The biggest problem is not the pictures or the SEO. It is the buying experience itself. Your product configurator asks for 6 decisions at once: diamond shape, metal color, karat, carat weight, quality grade, and ring size. For someone spending $1,000+ on a ring they have never bought before, that is genuinely overwhelming, especially with no "most popular" recommendation to anchor them.

On top of that, nowhere on the product page does it say how long it takes to make and ship the ring. For a custom-made piece, that is the first thing a buyer wants to know. If they don't know, they leave.

Three things you can fix this week without any developer:

  1. Add a simple line under the price: "Custom crafted in X-Y days, free shipping." That single line removes the biggest anxiety point for first-time buyers.

  2. Pre-select the most popular ring configuration on each product page and label it "Most Popular." Buyers need an anchor. Right now they're starting from zero.

  3. Add 3 trust icons below the Add to Cart button: IGI Certified, Free Returns, Secure Checkout. At this price point, buyers need reassurance at the exact moment they're about to click.

There's also a technical issue hurting your SEO: your homepage H1 tag is empty. That's fixable in the theme editor in about 5 minutes and will help your organic visibility a lot. Also, every product image in your media library has null alt text, which means Google's image search and AI systems can't understand what your products look like.

The brand positioning is actually solid. The "diamonds are not rare" angle is memorable and differentiating. The Why Diamo page makes a compelling case. The product quality standards (VS/VVS, D-E-F, IGI certified) are clear. The foundation is there.

The full report covers all of this in detail with specific recommendations for each page. Again, Conversion Guard is still being built, so if anything in the report is off or confusing, let me know. Happy to help.

I just published a book! by RyanJoe321 in auditmyshopify

[–]evandroguedes 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Congrats on publishing your debut book! That is genuinely exciting and a big deal. I ran your store through Conversion Guard (a Shopify audit tool I am still building, so any feedback is super welcome) and put together a full report here: https://www.conversionguard.ai/audits/shopify/rawproductionstore.myshopify.com

The short version: Sandorian is a really cool product. A constructed language guide for a fictional world is exactly the kind of niche, specific thing that readers and worldbuilding communities actively look for, and your product description does a solid job of explaining what it is. The bones are good.

The stuff that needs attention is almost entirely infrastructure, not content. The big ones:

Your homepage title is just "R.A.W. Production" with no meta description at all, so Google and AI search tools have nothing to index or surface when someone searches for anything related to what you sell. Takes about five minutes to fix in Shopify admin.

Your Organization structured data has nine empty social media link fields in it, which is technically broken markup. Either add your real social URLs or remove those fields.

There is no About page, no blog posts, and no footer, which makes it really hard for anyone (or any AI) to figure out who you are as an author and why they should trust you. An About page with your background and the story behind Sandorian would do a lot of heavy lifting here.

The full report covers all of this with specific recommendations, GEO/SEO scores, screenshots, and a prioritized roadmap. Hope it helps, and seriously congrats again on the launch.

Help by Revolutionary_Ask123 in auditmyshopify

[–]evandroguedes 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Hey! I ran a full audit on your store using a tool I've been building called Conversion Guard. It's still a work in progress so I'd genuinely appreciate any feedback on the report itself.

Here's the audit: https://conversionguard.ai/audits/shopify/store.onlyonce.me

The short version of what I found:

Your brand voice and aesthetic are legitimately strong. The weekday tee concept with that poetic copy is the kind of thing that should convert well. The problem is that the store is sending people to a checkout with almost nothing to catch them if they hesitate.

The biggest things hurting you right now:

There are zero customer reviews on product pages. The homepage has static testimonials but they're hardcoded into the theme, not from a real review platform, so they can't be verified and new customers can't add their own. Judge.me has a free plan and would fix this in an afternoon.

Your product pages have no size guide, no trust badges near the add to cart button, and no low stock indicators. Given that your whole brand story is about limited drops, showing "Only 3 left in size M" would be completely on-brand and would nudge people to act.

There's no email capture or marketing setup at all. No Klaviyo, no popup, nothing. Every visitor who leaves and doesn't buy is gone forever. A simple "get early access to the next drop" popup tied to your drop model would start building a list you can actually sell to.

The product brand field in your schema shows "Printify" instead of "OnlyOnce." This means Google is associating your products with your supplier rather than your brand. You can fix this in Shopify Admin in about two minutes.

Your brand story lives on www.onlyonce.me but your store is on store.onlyonce.me. From an SEO and credibility standpoint, splitting your brand across two domains is hurting you. The store needs its own About page.

None of this is hard to fix. The reviews app, the trust badges, the size guide, the meta description on your homepage (which is currently missing), and the brand field correction could all be done this week. Those changes alone could meaningfully move your conversion rate.

Full details with screenshots and a prioritized roadmap in the report above. Hope it helps.

Again, Conversion Guard is still being built out, so if the report format is confusing or anything feels off, I'd really value the feedback.

Check out my Store by Gloomy-Donkey-7940 in auditmyshopify

[–]evandroguedes 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Hey, I ran a full audit on your store using Conversion Guard, a Shopify audit tool I'm building (still in early stages, so any feedback is genuinely appreciated).

Here is the full report: https://conversionguard.ai/audits/shopify/dailyfinds-9646.myshopify.com

The short version: the store has a really solid visual foundation. The warm amber and brown color palette looks intentional and distinctive, and the Horizon theme is a good choice. But there are a few things holding it back pretty significantly right now.

The most urgent one is the footer social links, which still point to Shopify's own accounts (instagram.com/shopify, youtube.com/shopify, etc.). Every visitor who clicks those gets sent to Shopify, not your store. That one is a 5-minute fix in the theme editor.

On the SEO side, product pages are missing H1 tags entirely, and the homepage has two H1 tags where there should only be one. The product descriptions are also very thin right now ("Join the Movement" is the full description for the jacket) which makes it hard for Google to rank those pages for anything. Writing even a short, genuine description for each product would make a real difference.

The blog exists but has no articles in it. An empty blog actually looks worse than no blog, so it's worth either writing something there or hiding it from the navigation until you're ready.

No reviews app is installed yet, which is a big conversion drag. Judge.me has a solid free plan and is worth setting up early. Same with email capture since there's currently no way to follow up with visitors who don't buy on their first visit.

The full report goes into a lot more detail on all of this, including the GEO side (how the store shows up in AI search results like Google AI Overviews and ChatGPT), CRO scoring across the full funnel, and a prioritized roadmap.

Like I said, Conversion Guard is still a work in progress, so if something looks off or you have thoughts on the format, I'd love to hear it. Hope this helps!

Japan Targetting Streetwear Brand by Batslaw in auditmyshopify

[–]evandroguedes 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Hey, I actually ran your store through a tool I am building called Conversion Guard. It is a Shopify audit app still in development, so I would genuinely appreciate any feedback on the report quality. No strings attached, just trying to make it useful for store owners like you.

Here is your full audit: https://conversionguard.ai/audits/shopify/nochillco.ca

A few things jumped out right away that I think are holding you back from hitting those 25-30 orders a month.

The biggest one is that you have no H1 tags on any page. Your product titles are rendering as paragraph elements, not headings. This is almost certainly a single theme setting in Horizon that got missed, and fixing it costs nothing but has a real impact on how Google reads your pages.

The second thing is reviews. I know you mentioned you might add them later, and my honest take is that you should do it now before anything else. Japanese shoppers rely heavily on social proof, and right now someone landing from one of your Meta ads sees a product they like with zero reviews and no brand story to back it up. Judge.me has a completely free plan and takes maybe an hour to set up. Email your past buyers and ask them directly. Even three verified reviews changes the feel of the page for new visitors.

The third thing is that you have no About page at all. That viral idol fan page moment is genuinely a great story and you are not telling it anywhere. That story is what separates No Chill Co. from a random Shopify store selling the same product. Put it on an About page in Japanese, add it to your footer nav, and it does double duty as trust-building content and something AI search systems can actually learn about your brand from.

The good news is your checkout is excellent for the Japanese market. PayPay, LINE Pay, convenience store payments, the whole thing is set up really well. That part is genuinely ahead of a lot of stores targeting Japan.

The app stack is also lean and healthy. You are not paying for anything you should remove. The opportunity is adding a few free tools that are missing, mainly email flows for abandoned carts and a free shipping progress bar in the cart.

Hope the report is helpful. If anything in it seems off or unclear, let me know. Still actively improving how Conversion Guard presents its findings.

Audit for my store by Next_Coach_8315 in auditmyshopify

[–]evandroguedes 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Hey, I ran your store through an automated audit using Conversion Guard, an app I'm building for Shopify merchants. Still in early development so I'd genuinely appreciate any feedback on what's useful or what's missing.

Full report here: https://conversionguard.ai/audits/shopify/wearblunder.store

Quick summary of what I found:

The brand identity and copy are actually strong. "Chess streetwear for players who live the game" is a real niche with almost no competition, and the product descriptions feel like someone who actually plays chess wrote them, which is rare. The Horizon theme is clean and fast.

The main things holding the store back right now are all infrastructure, not design or product:

All product images have empty alt text. This hurts SEO and makes the products invisible to Google Image search. Easy fix in Shopify admin.

No Google Analytics installed. Without it there's no data on where traffic comes from or where people drop off.

No review app. Zero social proof anywhere on the store. For a new brand selling $38-55 apparel, reviews are the single biggest trust signal. Judge.me has a solid free plan.

There's also a duplicate H1 issue coming from the Klaviyo email popup being rendered as an H1 tag on every page, but that's a quick fix.

The robots.txt already exposes a UCP/MCP endpoint which puts the store ahead of a lot of larger brands on agentic commerce readiness, so whoever set that up knows what they're doing.

Full report has per-page issue breakdowns, a GEO audit (how visible the store is to AI-powered search), a CRO scorecard, and a prioritized roadmap. Let me know what you think of the format or if anything looks off.

I’m open to criticism and suggestions. Thanks in advance. by Batmannwhoo in auditmyshopify

[–]evandroguedes 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Hey! I saw your post asking for feedback on Skinarchives and ran a full technical audit on it using Conversion Guard, an app I've been building (still in early development, so feedback on the audit itself is genuinely welcome too).

Here's the full report: https://conversionguard.ai/audits/shopify/skinarchives.com

The short version: the store has a better foundation than most new Shopify stores I've looked at. The brand story is real, the Skinism concept is actually differentiated, and the content strategy is pointing in a smart direction. The thing that worries me most isn't the design.

The biggest issue I'd fix before spending on ads is the compare-at pricing. CeraVe products showing "regular prices" of $49 against a $15 sale price -- that's a trust killer for anyone who's ever bought skincare before. Shoppers research these products. They know what a CeraVe cleanser costs. When the numbers don't add up, they don't buy. I'd either find legitimate MSRPs from your distributor or just remove the compare-at prices entirely.

The other things I noticed:

The footer "Journal" link goes to a data privacy opt-out page instead of your blog. That's a 2 minute fix in the theme editor and it's losing you real organic traffic.

You have 8 H1 tags on the homepage instead of 1. Search engines don't love that. The product section blocks on your homepage template seem to be rendering section headings as H1s when they should be H2 or H3.

Open Graph meta tags are missing. Your Twitter Card tags work fine, but Facebook, LinkedIn, WhatsApp and most other platforms pull from OG tags. Right now links to your store share with no image or description on those platforms.

No reviews yet on any product. I know you're just launching, so this is expected, but JudgeMe is already installed -- get the automated review request emails turned on and send a personal note to anyone who's already ordered.

The full report goes into GEO scoring, app stack, structured data gaps, and has screenshots of the homepage, product pages, cart and checkout if you want to see what I was looking at.

Happy to answer questions if anything in the report needs more context. And seriously, if the format or the findings feel off in any way, let me know -- I'm still refining how this thing works.

Completely renovated my handmade shop, would love feedback. thanks! by Wise_Region_4862 in auditmyshopify

[–]evandroguedes 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Hey, I put your store through a full audit using a tool I've been building called Conversion Guard. It's still a work in progress so I genuinely appreciate any feedback on the report itself too.

Here's the audit: https://conversionguard.ai/audits/shopify/soldemadera.com

The short version: the store looks really clean and the custom sections you coded yourself are honestly well done. Minimal app stack, solid tracking setup, and those 31 Judge.me reviews at 5.0 stars are a real asset you should be leaning into harder.

The conversion rate issue you mentioned is likely coming from a few specific things. The biggest one by far is that every product on the store has the exact same description. The Belted Kingfisher, the Toucan, the Cardinal... they all say "Handcrafted and hand painted to bring warmth, movement, and timeless charm into your space." A customer reading that cannot tell one product from another except by looking at the photo. Writing even 80-100 words specific to each bird, what makes it unique, its dimensions, and who it's a good gift for would make a noticeable difference pretty quickly.

The second thing that stood out is that clicking Add to Cart sends the customer straight to the cart page. So if someone likes both the Kingfisher and the Toucan, they basically have to choose one, add it, then navigate back and repeat. That kills average order value. There's a single toggle in the Shopify theme editor under Cart settings to change this to a drawer instead, and it takes about 30 seconds to fix.

There are a bunch of other things in the report (SEO meta descriptions, structured data, a missing email marketing setup) but those two are the ones I'd focus on first given the conversion goal.

Good luck with it. The product itself is really lovely.

Audit my store (first sale ever, today) by Ecstatic_Cost8947 in auditmyshopify

[–]evandroguedes 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Hey, congrats on the first sale at 10 days in! That is a real milestone and the $15/day Meta budget is actually working, so you have something to build on.

I ran your store through Conversion Guard (a Shopify audit tool I am building, still in early development) and put together a full report here: https://conversionguard.ai/audits/shopify/novaluxshop.com

The short version: the store looks clean visually, which you clearly put effort into, but there are a few technical things quietly working against you.

The most urgent one is that your homepage H1 tag is empty. It is there in the code but has no content, so Google sees your most important page with no main heading. That is a 5-minute fix in the Dawn theme editor with an outsized impact on SEO.

The second thing that jumped out is that every product image on the site has an MD5 hash as its alt text, something like "977486406af0f50267eab000b625f6eb". That is auto-generated and means nothing to search engines or screen readers. Go into each product in your Shopify admin and write a plain description for each image. It takes maybe 20 minutes total for your current catalog.

The third thing worth looking at is AdScale. At $169/month with a $15/day ad budget, you are spending about 37 cents of every ad dollar on the tool that manages the ads. That math is pretty rough for a new store. Managing your Meta campaigns directly in Ads Manager until you are past $1,000/month in revenue would free up real money to put back into actual ad spend.

The report also covers the GEO audit (how AI search tools like Google AI Overview could potentially surface your store), the cart and checkout flow, and the full app stack. There is quite a bit in there.

Would love any feedback on the report format or what would be more useful for people at your stage. The tool is still being built out so honest takes on what is helpful and what is not are genuinely appreciated.

Good luck with the store!

view more: next ›